He was asked to start a Republican club by Whitman’s president, then his window was spit on and his room was doxxed
Whitman Republican Club chair David Dunbabin says senators had decided to reject his group before his presentation, then questioned him for a full hour.
(David Dunbabin)
(David Dunbabin)
The chair of Whitman College’s Republican club says student senators had already decided to reject his group three minutes before he walked in, then kept him in the room for an hour of questions about Donald Trump, ICE and Title IX anyway.
David Dunbabin, a junior economics major from Mercer Island, chairs the Whitman Republican Club that the Associated Students of Whitman College Senate (ASWC) refused to affiliate in March. The Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression (FIRE) sent a letter this week to Whitman President Sarah Bolton demanding the private Walla Walla college reverse the denial, and it gave the school until September 14 to respond. Seattle Red first reported the contents of that letter and the senate minutes behind it on Tuesday.
The vote was not quite unanimous, and the meeting was not quite a review
The senate vote has been described as unanimous. Dunbabin says three senators did not cast a ballot at all.
“Technically, it wasn’t necessarily unanimous,” Dunbabin said on The Jason Rantz Show on Seattle Red 770 AM. “There were three people that did not vote, one of them which was not there, and the other two, ironically, one of them was DEI chair.”
He also says the outcome was settled before his club presented anything.
“Three minutes beforehand they decided practically to reject us without even thought, without even our presentation,” Dunbabin said. “We showed our presentation. And the ironic thing is that within the ASWC’s own bylaws and constitution, they have an anti-discrimination clause, and particularly they mention political belief.”
That clause matters. Dunbabin says the student government’s own anti-discrimination language protects political belief while the college’s does not, which means the senate wrote a rule and then ignored it.
An hour of questions about harm nobody could define
Routine affiliation hearings at Whitman run about 15 minutes or so. But Dunbabin says his ran about an hour, and that the questions had nothing to do with paperwork. His club had held an event about ICE that week, and a letter about the state ballot measure restricting girls’ sports to biological females had run in the student paper.
“It was a 60-minute long, and I’ll call it interrogation,” he told Rantz.
“They were asking just hostile questions claiming that we’re causing harm,” Dunbabin added. “It was basically we are causing harm, and ‘we can’t give you reasons. You’re contradicting yourselves.'”
Planned Parenthood is affiliated, the Republicans are not
ASWC already affiliates Planned Parenthood Generation Action and the Climate Justice Coalition, both of which take positions in one direction and receive funding and campus resources for it. Dunbabin says he raised that in the hearing.
Senators also told the club they would follow up with guidance on how to fix its application. According to Dunbabin, that never happened.
“They normally suggest that we’ll give you feedback,” he noted. “They never gave us feedback. They never emailed us feedback at all.”
What it costs to run the club
Dunbabin says President Bolton personally encouraged him to start the chapter after he mentioned his work with the local GOP, which is part of why he expects the administration to side with the students once it engages.
“Bolton, I think, will actually be in support of us, because she was the one to ask us to start this club,” he said. “She asked me directly to start it, because I mentioned that I work with the local GOP.”
Six months later, the club is still unrecognized. Dunbabin says the personal cost has been steep, and that roughly half his board are immigrants who he believes have taken worse treatment than he has. One of them, he alleges, was surrounded by other students and prevented from leaving.
“My room has been doxxed,” Dunbabin said. “I’ve had my window spit at multiple times from having Israeli flag. I’ve been called a fascist and Nazi. I’ve been literally told stay out of local politics. I can keep going.”
Whitman struggles with free speech
Whitman carries a yellow light speech code rating from FIRE for policies loose enough to invite arbitrary enforcement, and it was named the best college in Washington in a 2024 WalletHub ranking that put it ahead of the University of Washington and Gonzaga. Conservative students and faculty elsewhere in the state have found relief in court, including a UW professor who won at the Ninth Circuit last year after the school retaliated over a parody land acknowledgment.
Dunbabin plans to reapply this fall. He says he would do the whole thing again.
“Honestly, it’s worth it,” he said. “Whitman’s already under a Title IX from the state and a Title VI from the feds for investigations. I believe that we make this college more bipartisan, and trying to treat it and challenge people’s ideas.”
He had one piece of advice for students watching from a safe distance.
“You have to stay true to yourself,” Dunbabin said. “I want to become a beacon for hope for other people that, ironically, are hiding in the closet Republican, not being public to it. The social backlash is there.”
Listen to The Jason Rantz Show on weekday afternoons from 3 p.m. – 7 p.m. on Seattle Red on 770 AM (HD Radio 97.3 FM HD-Channel 3). Subscribe to the podcast here. Follow Jason Rantz on X, Instagram, YouTube, and Facebook.






Comments
5 Comments
These children must be shown what Democracy is. They do not get to terrorize someone or some group BECAUSE THEY DONT AGREE WITH THEM. And a group of Republicans not be able to form a group is simple. It is Authoritarianism. Since this is a College, EDUCATION INSTITUTE, this should be VERY WELL UNDERSTOOD what that means. Hey, anyone know what kind of system of Governance is closely aligned with AUTHORITARIANISM!? COMMUNISM!
The STUDENTS ARE LIVING OUT COMMUNISM AT Whitman College. Good to know the parents money is being well spent on DESTROYING AMERICA.
This College is a DEN of Communism. Unfortunately, I do not believe this is an anomoly but normal in todays student population. Their future is so screwed.
The student government obviously cannot be trusted to decide which clubs get support. The president of Whitman should put that power back with the administration, and require even-handed principles to be followed.