ADVERTISEMENT

ECONOMY

John Stossel: Seattle vowed to help gig workers. Its $26 wage law did the opposite

John Stossel says Seattle's $26 minimum pay law for gig workers backfired, raising prices and cutting tips, just like a similar rule did in New York City.

Red DoorDash delivery backpack on the ground behind a delivery courier's legs...

Seattle's app-based pay law pushed delivery costs up, and drivers say the orders dried up. (Photo: Andrew Harrer, Getty Images)

(Photo: Andrew Harrer, Getty Images)

Anyone who has ever entered the gig economy in Seattle knows it is outrageously expensive. Whether you’re ordering food on DoorDash or calling an Uber to the airport, you’re going to end up burning a serious hole in your wallet.

These high prices can all be traced backed to Seattle’s minimum wage hike that went into effect in 2024. The logic was simple; Seattle is an expensive place to live so drivers deserved to have their pay bumped up to $26 an hour.

Two years later though, data shows the legislation has actually hurt gig workers. Why? Political commentator and author John Stossel explained in a new video.

Why a higher minimum wage backfires on workers

Stossel spoke with the Manhattan Institute’s director of research Judge Glock. Glock explained how a higher minimum wage resulted in less money in workers’ pockets.

“Obviously, when you’re increasing cost to businesses, you’re going to increase cost to customers,” said Glock. “These are very almost unimaginably complicated markets where the company’s main job is actually interfacing between restaurants and delivery workers and customers.”

DoorDash says it received 1.7 million fewer orders after the minimum wage was raised. “That’s what happens when politicians micromanage,” said Stossel.

ADVERTISEMENT

Seattle’s experience is the rule, not the exception

Stossel also pointed out that Seattle isn’t a one-off. This kind of top-down management of the economy has failed everywhere it’s been tried. New York City is another prime example where app-based delivery workers had their hourly wage increased to $19.56, which resulted in fewer tips.

“It’s this continual whack-a-mole tendency, where yes, the market responds, we need a new regulation to try to prevent that response,” said Glock. “They think that the next regulation is somehow going to squelch the greed out of the system, but there’s simply no way to do that.”

Stossel says competition is the only effective way to benefit both workers and consumers. He said he even reached out to the Seattle City Council and asked them why they believe they know better than the market. Not surprisingly, he didn’t hear back from them.

ADVERTISEMENT

“A lot of politicians want to believe there’s a free lunch or just a fixed pot of money that they can give out to the neediest people in America,” concluded Glock. “The actual effect was not to improve the well-being of any workers, but it was to increase costs for customers and to sabotage one of the most successful businesses in the city.”

Listen to The Jason Rantz Show on weekday afternoons from 3 p.m. – 7 p.m. on Seattle Red on 770 AM (HD Radio 97.3 FM HD-Channel 3). Subscribe to the podcast here. Follow Jason Rantz on X, Instagram, YouTube, and Facebook.

Jackson Meyer Producer, The Jason Rantz Show

Born and raised in Issaquah, Jackson is a lifelong Washingtonian. He is an avid sports fan, particularly of baseball, which he played at the varsity level in High School. He worked at the Seattle-based conservative think tank Discovery Institute for… Read more

Comments

1 Comments

J
Jake Morningwood 5 months ago

Before the cost increase I ordered with Uber Eats once a week. I have not used it once since. I'm sure there are lots of people like me. Politicians who have never run a business making policy that involves economic dynamics is a prescription for disaster.