Chris Cargill: The hidden costs of Washington’s minimum wage hike
Washington’s $17.13 minimum wage is being sold as a win for families, but the data shows higher teen unemployment, rising prices, and mounting pressure on small businesses across the state.
A teenage employee works an entry-level job, the kind most vulnerable to being cut when labor costs rise under aggressive minimum wage mandates. (Photo by Michael Hickey/Getty Images for GE Appliances, a Haier company)
(Photo by Michael Hickey/Getty Images for GE Appliances, a Haier company)
A recent social media post from a news organization in Spokane celebrated Washington’s new $17.13 minimum wage as “good news for families,” boasting it’s the highest state rate in the country. But good headlines don’t make good policy — especially when the real effects rip through the labor market and everyday life.
Yes, on January 1, Washington mandated a 2.8% increase to $17.13 per hour. That’s more than double the federal minimum of $7.25, which hasn’t budged in over a decade. But let’s not kid ourselves: mandating higher pay does not create value out of thin air. It forces businesses — especially small ones — to shoulder steep labor costs. And when costs go up, businesses react by changing how and where they hire.
One group that gets hit hardest? Young workers, who rely on entry-level jobs to gain experience.
Data tells the full story on the impact of minimum wage hikes
Look at the data: in Washington and other high-wage states, the unemployment rate for teens is notably higher than the national average. Recent figures show Washington’s teen unemployment rate has hovered around 14.8%, which is well above what millions of Americans experience overall — and worse than states with lower wage floors.
Meanwhile, national youth unemployment statistics show that even before policy shifts, young joblessness is elevated: roughly 10.8% of U.S. youth were unemployed in July 2025. When you already have a structural challenge getting teens and young adults into the workforce, piling on higher hiring costs makes that problem even worse.
Here’s the painful reality policymakers and cheerleaders often ignore: A mandatory wage floor doesn’t distinguish between someone with 10 years of experience and someone with no experience at all. Employers facing rising labor costs don’t say, “I’ll pay more but hire the same number of entry-level workers.” They say: “I’ll cut hours, require more experience, automate tasks, or simply hire fewer people.”
That’s not speculation — it’s basic market behavior. And it’s exactly why young people and other at-risk workers are most vulnerable when minimum wages are pushed ever higher without regard for local job markets and living costs.
Will the minimum wage hike truly help Washington families?
It’s particularly absurd to celebrate wage hikes without asking basic questions like: Will this actually help families who struggle with childcare costs, housing, groceries, and utilities? Many low-income households earn above the minimum wage already. Meanwhile, families on fixed incomes will pay more as businesses pass labor costs onto consumers.
And for small business owners — the folks who are woven into the fabric of our communities — this isn’t abstract theory. It’s real life. They’re the ones deciding whether to keep a second location open, give workers more hours, or cut staffing altogether. Minimum wage mandates don’t make them reckless; they make them cautious — rationally so.
Arguing that higher wages are “good news” without acknowledging these predictable consequences is not just careless — it’s disingenuous. It treats economic policy like a slogan, not a system with winners and losers.
Focus on opportunity
If we truly want to help families and future workers, policymakers should focus on expanding opportunity, not erecting barriers. Lowering the cost of essentials, investing in job training and apprenticeships, and encouraging pathways to higher-paying careers — those are the solutions that actually grow prosperity.
Washington’s minimum wage hike might look great on a sign or a social media post — but for many young workers, families paying rising prices, and struggling small businesses, it’s bad news dressed up as good public relations.
Chris Cargill is the President of Mountain States Policy Center, an independent free market think tank based in Idaho, Montana, Wyoming and Eastern Washington. Online at mountainstatespolicy.org.






Comments
3 Comments
Any wagers as to how long it’ll take State Dems (all levels Gov) to try and figure a way to unionize the new and upcoming AI “bot” workforce? They really never were in it for “the people”.
Minimum wage is largely irrelevant outside of some service industries and food vending.
Two major flaws in Seattle and/or WA min wages - 1) eliminating the tip credit, and 2) not having a carve-out for teenagers under 19.
The latter simply means fewer teen jobs. Teens - with few exceptions - don't require a living wage. And entry-level teens typically will require more heads than more-experienced folks who will barely make higher wages. There are also special work rules for teens - as to hours, supervision, etc.
I own and operate ice cream shops. One of my first jobs was in an ice cream shop and I see the lifetime value that job had on my career path. The duties of working in an ice cream shop also fit well with restrictions set for minors by L&I. I deeply desire to provide teens this same opportunity, but I am finding it really hard. I am small. For those with little or no job experience, I need to put 2 of them on a shift to cover the job that one more experienced employee can easily cover themselves. My customers don't want to pay $10 for their ice cream cones. There is no training wage. My seasons are short and match up well with school schedules, making working with us a great job for students. In past years I invested time and money to give teens a chance and it hurt my business. I have attended sessions at our ice cream convention where shop owners in other states have been able create successful training and compensation plans with meaningful raises to recognize advancement and job performance. I can't provide raises for than 50 cents or maybe $1. My workers do earn well above minimum wage with tips, but they all essentially work at the same level, regardless of performance.