ADVERTISEMENT

IDAHO

“This rumor is completely false”: Idaho GOP Senator slaps down bizarre claims that he may try to circumvent the November election

Senator Jim Risch (R-Idaho) has vehemently denied a bizarre rumor that he may try to use a century-old state law to avoid holding an election this November.

Idaho Republican Senator Jim Risch has fervently denied rumors that he is trying to avoid holding a...

Idaho Republican Senator Jim Risch has fervently denied rumors that he is trying to avoid holding an election this November. (Photo from Senator Risch on X)

(Photo from Senator Risch on X)

With Election Day right around the corner, a bizarre rumor has begun to swirl about Idaho Republican Senator Jim Risch. He is being accused of potentially wielding a never-used state law that’s over a century old to avoid the democratic process altogether.

The 1917 law states that if a U.S. Senator from Idaho resigns or dies with 30 days of the general election then the governor can appoint someone to fill the vacancy and “no election for United States senator to fill said vacancy shall be held at such general election.”

Risch, 83, has served in the Senate since 2009 and is seeking his fourth term.

Risch is giving the rumors no quarter

Risch has come out and vociferously denied these rumors. Idaho has long been a reliably red state and there’s no indication that Risch’s reelection bid is in any danger this cycle.

“This rumor is completely false,” Risch’s campaign manager Marc Kilmer told the Idaho Capital Sun in an email. “Jim Risch is leading in the polls. He is running an aggressive campaign. He will be victorious on November 3. This conspiracy theory is being perpetrated by our desperate opponent to take attention away from his liberal record. The only people who gamed the system this election were our opponent’s supporters who coerced Democrat David Roth to drop out and clear the field for Todd Achilles.”

Risch’s opponent Todd Achilles is running as an independent even though he served as a Democrat in the Idaho Legislature. David Roth won the Democratic primary but dropped out of the race last month, citing a lack of support from the party. The Achilles campaign took offense to the notion that they started the rumors.

ADVERTISEMENT

“What’s concerning is that Jim Risch is pointing fingers instead of assuring voters that he won’t use the law in a way that would bypass the will of the voters,” Achilles’ Communication Director Crispin Gravatt wrote in an email. “He should clearly state that he will remain in the race through Election Day and, if elected, intends to serve the full 6-year term until he is 89 years old.”

It’s not clear if the law is even legal

Even on the off chance that Risch would try to pull a fast one on Idaho voters, it’s not clear if the law would pass constitutional muster anyway as courts have never had a chance to weigh in on it.

“I think the arguments (against the law) would stem from provisions in the Idaho Constitution as well as in the U.S. Constitution that provide qualified citizens the right to vote,” McKay Cunningham, a director of the master of applied public policy at College of Idaho told the Idaho Capital Sun. “There are a lot of Supreme Court cases that talk about this constitutional right.”

ADVERTISEMENT

Cunningham said he could also see a scenario where candidates filed a lawsuit over the law due to violations of due process rights for their candidacy if an election were not held.

“It would create such a mess,” added Cunningham. “I think at the heart of it, and this is not a legal argument necessarily, but the heart of it is representational democracy and the right to vote is preservative of all other rights.”

Follow Seattle Red on-air at 770 AM, on the Seattle Red app, and streaming audio and video on SeattleRed.com.

Jackson Meyer Producer, The Jason Rantz Show

Born and raised in Issaquah, Jackson is a lifelong Washingtonian. He is an avid sports fan, particularly of baseball, which he played at the varsity level in High School. He worked at the Seattle-based conservative think tank Discovery Institute for… Read more

Comments

0 Comments