ADVERTISEMENT

JASON RANTZ OPINION

Rantz: Democrats are now promising to expand income tax to households making $250,000

Democrat Cindy Ryu floated taxing $250,000 households in a KUOW debate, and opponent Jesse Salomon wants $750,000. So much for a tax on millionaires only.

state rep cindy ryu...

Democratic State Representative Cindy Ryu said during a KUOW debate that Washington's income tax should reach households earning $250,000. (Photo: TVW)

(Photo: TVW)

State Representative Cindy Ryu, who is now running for a state Senate seat, wants Washington’s new income tax to reach households earning $250,000 a year. Her opponent, incumbent Democratic Senator Jesse Salomon, says the next step should have been $750,000. Both are contradicting the talking point the party has been running on all summer.

Both candidates made the case during a KUOW Soundside debate in the 32nd Legislative District, which covers Shoreline, Lynnwood, Mountlake Terrace, Woodway, and parts of Edmonds and northwest Seattle. The district is so blue that no Republican made the general election ballot. Whoever wins, voters there will send a Democrat to Olympia who has publicly discussed dropping the threshold.

Democrats sold the 9.9 percent tax as a levy on millionaires only. That was always a lie. Six months after Governor Bob Ferguson signed it, two more members of his party are arguing over how far down it should go next.

Ryu floats a $250,000 threshold

Moderator Libby Denkmann pointed out that Ryu has previously said she wants to explore extending the tax to lower income brackets at a lower rate. Denkmann also noted polling shows support for the tax drops when the threshold falls. Ryu did not retreat.

“I mean, do you really need more than a million dollars to live well in Washington State? I think not, and so let’s look at what is the median. I think the middle income right now is more than 100,000 for a household because everything is so expensive. So maybe not $100,000,” Ryu said.

She then settled on a number.

“Can we live well on $250,000 a year of net income? We’re not talking about gross income. We’re not talking about when we calculate the B&O tax, where we tax everyone on their gross activities. When we are looking at the net income, and let’s take a look at how well can most of us live pretty well at an arbitrary number, absolutely at 250,000. Especially if we can bring that rate down from that 9.9%, which I know is very offensive,” Ryu argued.

ADVERTISEMENT

Ryu called her figure arbitrary. Any figure written into statute is, of course, and any future legislative majority can change it with a simple vote, though proponents of the income tax are pretending it would require a vote of the people. She also conceded the people paying the tax today could leave the state over it, since only income above the first million is taxed. Her answer was essentially to spread the burden.

“We do not want that, and so we want everyone to stay in the state if they want to live here and yet be able to afford to pay for the basics,” Ryu added, an acknowledgment that her colleagues are lying when claiming no one is leaving the state.

The ‘moderate’ Democrat wants it lower, too

Ryu launched her challenge by calling Salomon too moderate. Salomon told the audience he was a sponsor of the income tax in the Senate. His complaint is that the House turned most of it into new revenue instead of tax relief, which he believes cost Democrats the public trust needed for a second step.

ADVERTISEMENT

“I think we really blew a long-term opportunity to engage the public trust on this. If we had shown that we could do a short-term revenue reduction for a long-term revolutionary change in the tax code, then they might have said, ‘What do you have next for us? I’m interested.’ And what next would have been lowering it to $750,000 as a threshold in exchange for dollar for dollar property tax relief,” Salomon said.

Salomon did warn against piling on.

“At this point, I think we’re sort of cutting into the principle, so I think if we raise taxes even more, we’re going to hurt the economic engine of this area. Puget Sound, we know we’re facing a lot of layoffs in the tech industry,” he cautioned.

What Democrats promised

The law, Senate Bill 6346, imposes a 9.9 percent tax on household income above $1 million, and it will hit roughly 20,000 households once collections begin in 2029. Senate Majority Leader Jamie Pedersen was the lead architect of the tax.

ADVERTISEMENT

In January, Ferguson said he would not sign an income tax that targets non-millionaires. He previously said he wouldn’t back an income tax at all, or denied he’d support raising taxes before green lighting the largest tax increase in state history. He was always lying. In February, House Majority Leader Joe Fitzgibbon told reporters that lawmakers were not looking at lowering the threshold. But that, too, was a lie.

When Republican Senator Chris Gildon offered an amendment to lock the 9.9 percent rate and the $1 million threshold into law, Democrats on the Senate Ways and Means Committee rejected it by voice vote without discussion.

Initiative 645, on the November 3 ballot, would repeal the tax outright if voters vote yes. That is the vote DocuSign co-founder Court Lorenzini has urged, warning the threshold will not hold. Ryu just admitted Lorenzini is right.

Listen to The Jason Rantz Show on weekday afternoons from 3 p.m. – 7 p.m. on Seattle Red on 770 AM (HD Radio 97.3 FM HD-Channel 3). Subscribe to the podcast here. Follow Jason Rantz on X, Instagram, YouTube, and Facebook.

Jason Rantz Talk Show Host and Columnist at Seattle Red

Jason Rantz hosts The Jason Rantz Show on Seattle Red 770 AM weekdays from 3 p.m. to 7 p.m.

Comments

30 Comments

B
Buck Futz 2 months ago

Can Washington State Government live on less than 157 Billion? Answer, yes
Remember these are the same people who don’t know what a woman is, Love to spend money on illegals, homeless, sue anyone that doesn’t agree, appoint SC judges that can’t reasonably judge a law, think they can solve the worlds climate problem and the ones forcing you into ridiculous fuel prices.
Comparison, I was in Kansas City yesterday and gas was $3.99 and Diesel was $5.94. Still too high but nowhere near our extreme prices here.

P
Pablo Abo 2 months ago

This was always the plan.
While the $1M earners pack up and leave, WA will continue to spend like drunken sailors into a massive deficit. In 2028-2029 Dems will say it is an emergency and will 100% guaranteed lower the threshold to more people.
They will say, if you are making $750K, you can share a little of those ill begotten gains that rightfully belong to the state. The slide into the abyss has begun.

C
Clockwork Wyrm 2 months ago

Strictly speaking the income tax already applies to everyone, they just have to lower the deduction levels.

The REALLY insidious part of the new income tax are the adjustment lawmakers made to other laws, effectively stripping tax protections from retirement accounts, pensions, and other long-term planning accounts. Sure, you may not make $1M now, but how's that pension looking? To the Leftists in Olympia, it's looking like a stuffed goose ripe for carving.