ADVERTISEMENT

ECONOMY

Rantz Exclusive: Fire authority rejects cheapest bid over paperwork error, then warns the contractor about attorney fees if he sues

Puget Sound Fire rejected a Spanaway contractor's low bid over a list emailed 38 minutes late. Taxpayers are set to pay $283,770 more for the Station 84 job.

Broussard Construction...

The Puget Sound Regional Fire Authority rejected the lowest bid on its Station 84 remodel over a subcontractor list submitted 38 minutes late. (Broussard Construction)

(Broussard Construction)

The Puget Sound Regional Fire Authority threw out the lowest bid on its Station 84 remodel because one page showed up 38 minutes late, and taxpayers are now set to pay $283,770 more for the same job.

Broussard Construction of Spanaway bid $1,540,230 on the Station 84 tenant improvement project. According to a bid tabulation the Kent-based fire authority sent Seattle Red, the work is instead headed to CDK Construction at $1,824,000. Broussard’s list naming its HVAC, plumbing and electrical subcontractors was missing from the sealed bid when it was opened on September 3. Until the Legislature changed RCW 39.30.060 in 2025, bidders got a full hour to turn that list in.

The fire authority insists it had no power to overlook the mistake. But emails obtained by Seattle Red show it also said it would not have overlooked it even if it could.

One missing page, no second chance

Staff flagged the missing form at the bid opening.

“I said, ‘I’m going to email it over right away.’ I don’t even think I had left the building yet before it was in their email inbox. And that’s the issue I’m having. I totally own the idea that the subcontractor list was missing. I totally own that, and I take responsibility for it,” owner Phillip Broussard told The Jason Rantz Show on Seattle Red 770 AM.

The list exists to stop bid shopping, where a contractor wins a job and then dumps its subcontractors for cheaper ones. In writing, Broussard told the agency he picked DAC Electric, Pac West Plumbing and AZ Heating & Air before the deadline, and that neither his subcontractors nor his price changed.

ADVERTISEMENT

The current law still gives bidders 48 hours to fix errors in subcontractor license information. Broussard says that invites the very scam the rule targets.

“If I had submitted a fraudulent list, I would be allowed to have 48 hours to correct it,” he noted. “So effectively, this bid shopping rule that they wanted to end, they now have explicitly allowed it.”

Fire authority refuses to budge

Procurement Manager Robert McMartin rejected the bid as non-responsive on September 24 and called the decision final, with no appeal. Broussard cited Washington court rulings allowing waivers of minor bidding errors. After consulting legal counsel, McMartin held firm.

“Even if those cases supported the position that we could waive strict compliance with RCW 39.30.060, we would not exercise that discretion as any such waiver would subject the RFA to the risk of a legal challenge based on an attempt to waive a mandatory statutory requirement. We are unwilling to take on that risk,” McMartin wrote on September 25.

ADVERTISEMENT

He repeated a warning that the agency would seek attorney fees if Broussard pursued a restraining order.

Responding to criticism

Asked how paying roughly $283,770 more squares with the agency’s duty to taxpayers, Division Chief Pat Pawlak, the fire authority’s public information officer, replied, “We followed the requirements in RCW 39.30.060 as currently written and our obligation to our taxpayers is to ensure that we follow all applicable laws and regulations.”

Pawlak added that whether Broussard changed subcontractors or price was not a factor in the decision. The CDK contract is not signed yet, and staff plan to ask the fire authority’s Governance Board to approve it at its next meeting.

Broussard said he has contacted state Senator Jim McCune’s office about the rule and has records requests out to more than a dozen agencies tallying what the rule has cost. Seattle Red has not independently verified those costs.

ADVERTISEMENT

“I could have sworn it was in there. It’s not in there, but again, one piece of paper shouldn’t cost the taxpayers $300,000,” Broussard said.

Listen to The Jason Rantz Show on weekday afternoons from 3 p.m. – 7 p.m. on Seattle Red on 770 AM (HD Radio 97.3 FM HD-Channel 3). Subscribe to the podcast here. Follow Jason Rantz on X, Instagram, YouTube, and Facebook.

Jason Rantz Talk Show Host and Columnist at Seattle Red

Jason Rantz hosts The Jason Rantz Show on Seattle Red 770 AM weekdays from 3 p.m. to 7 p.m.

Comments

2 Comments

G
George Payne 2 months ago

Who cares if your spending other peoples money.

M
mike will made 2 months ago

Sour grapes