Rantz: Outrageous natural gas initiative ruling makes these five Supreme Court races impossible to ignore
The I-2066 ruling shows why Washington’s five Supreme Court races deserve far more attention from voters this November.
The steps of the Washington State Supreme Court.(Washington State Supreme Court/YouTube)
(Washington State Supreme Court/YouTube)
Nearly 2 million Washingtonians voted for Initiative 2066, but six Washington Supreme Court justices just decided the law they approved cannot stand. If that doesn’t convince voters to pay attention to the five state Supreme Court races on the November ballot, I’m not sure what will.
The Washington Supreme Court struck down I-2066 in a 6-3 decision Thursday, concluding that the natural-gas initiative violated the state Constitution’s single-subject rule. The majority determined that the initiative contained multiple subjects and invalidated the measure in its entirety. That means a law approved by 1,941,474 Washington voters in 2024 is gone.
Whatever your position on natural gas, that ought to clarify something voters too often ignore: Supreme Court races have enormous consequences. And you can’t sit out the five races on the November ballot.
Six justices just overruled a statewide vote
Courts are supposed to determine whether laws comply with the Constitution. A law does not become constitutional simply because it is popular. But the I-2066 ruling demonstrates how much authority Washington gives nine people on the state’s highest court.
Voters passed the initiative with 51.71% of the vote, according to the Secretary of State. Then six justices concluded that the voters’ law violated Article II, Section 19 of the Washington Constitution. Three justices disagreed with the majority’s conclusion. Judicial philosophy is not an academic issue when those interpretations determine whether a law approved by nearly 2 million people remains in effect.
Five Supreme Court races are on the November ballot
Now consider the timing. Washington voters are choosing justices for five of the court’s nine positions in the Nov. 3 general election. That is more than half of the court appearing on the ballot in the same election.
Yet these races will inevitably receive a fraction of the attention devoted to congressional and legislative campaigns. That makes little sense when you consider the power involved.
State Supreme Court justices ultimately decide major disputes involving initiatives, taxation, gun laws, criminal justice, elections, executive authority and limits on legislative power. They always seem to side with the Democrats in Olympia, contorting themselves into pretzels in order to uphold the will of the party in power, not the people. I-2066 is simply the latest reminder.
More initiative fights are already coming
The court’s role could become even more consequential almost immediately.
Washington voters will decide three statewide initiatives in November, including Initiative 645 concerning state and local taxes. That initiative targets the state’s new income tax, another policy almost certain to generate major legal fights regardless of what happens politically.
Let’s Go Washington founder Brian Heywood, whose organization backed I-2066 and the current initiatives, raised the obvious issue when I interviewed him after last Thursday’s ruling: voters cannot treat Supreme Court races as an afterthought when the court has the power to determine the ultimate fate of those initiatives.
He’s right about the significance of the races. You do not have to agree with Heywood about I-2066, his initiatives or his criticism of the court to recognize the larger lesson.
Stop skipping the judicial races
Washington voters spend months being bombarded with information about congressional candidates and legislative races. Then many reach the judicial section of their ballot knowing almost nothing about the candidates. That is backwards.
The people elected to the Supreme Court can determine whether a tax survives, whether executive power has gone too far, whether legislation complies with the state Constitution and whether an initiative approved by voters actually becomes lasting law. Thursday offered an unusually clear demonstration. Nearly 2 million voters approved I-2066. And six justices concluded that it violated the Constitution. Three disagreed.
And now five Supreme Court positions are before voters.
The I-2066 ruling should make one thing impossible to ignore: The names in those judicial races can ultimately matter every bit as much as the politicians at the top of the ballot. Deserving of your vote? Scott Edwards, Judge David Stevens, Judge Sean O’Donnell, Judge Dave Larson and Todd Bloom.
Listen to The Jason Rantz Show on weekday afternoons from 3 p.m. – 7 p.m. on Seattle Red on 770 AM (HD Radio 97.3 FM HD-Channel 3). Subscribe to the podcast here. Follow Jason Rantz on X, Instagram, YouTube, and Facebook.






Comments
12 Comments
vote every one of these fascists out just to send a message...you will NOT ignore the will of the voters...
Good Point. I did question that as well. I want to be sure to NOT vote for the BIASED Judges. We need UNBIASED Judges to that they work for We the People and NOT them the politicians.
As someone in a previous thread said;
The next initative should read; "ALL Bills introduced by the State Legislature MUST be REQUIRED to adhere to the SAME rules andstipulations that citizens' initiatives are required to follow."