Rantz: A vacancy tax plan so bad that even Portland killed it. Will Seattle do the same?
Portland councilors dropped their vacancy tax plan after a city study said it would not work. Seattle Mayor Katie Wilson campaigned on the very same idea.
Portland councilors abandoned a proposed fee on vacant storefronts and apartments after a city study found it would not work. (Jason Rantz)
(Jason Rantz)
Portland killed a proposed vacancy tax idea before it could do any damage, and the reason should embarrass every Seattle politician still flirting with one.
Two Portland city councilors dropped a proposed fee on vacant storefronts and apartments after a study they commissioned found the policy was legally complicated and unlikely to fix the problem it was sold to solve. Seattle’s mayor campaigned on that same policy.
City Councilors Jamie Dunphy and Sameer Kanal each told the Portland Business Journal they are no longer pursuing a vacancy fee. The study commissioned by councilors concluded that taxing or fining property owners would not address the root cause of Portland’s empty space, and commercial real estate executives warned the fee would give investors one more reason to avoid a downtown where Colliers pegged office vacancy at 27% at the end of 2025.
Is Seattle still technically pursuing the idea?
Seattle may keep chasing what Portland abandoned
Mayor Katie Wilson ran on a vacancy tax or fine aimed at owners of empty commercial space, pitching it as a way to push landlords into filling storefronts. The numbers she inherited are worse than Portland’s. Reported Seattle vacancy rates go from 25% to 34.7% depending on the survey, with downtown office space among the emptiest in the country.
The vacancy is a symptom, however.
Seattle taxed payroll and did little to address safety concerns downtown, then acted surprised when employers moved across the lake. The Puget Sound Regional Council reported the region shed 12,900 jobs in 2025, the first annual decline since the Great Recession bottomed out in 2009. And it’s seemingly getting worse in 2026. Buildings do not empty themselves.
The legal issue nobody in city hall wants to discuss
Even if Wilson decides the punishment is worth it, Washington’s Constitution is in the way.
The Uniformity Clause requires a uniform and equal rate of taxation on all property in the state, with real estate treated as a single class, which is why Tacoma’s council looked at vacancy taxes years ago and backed off. San Francisco’s commercial vacancy tax was struck down in 2024. Honolulu shelved its own version, too.
So Seattle gets a choice. Portland studied the vacancy tax, learned it would not work, and walked away. Wilson can do the same, or she can spend a year of staff time and legal fees proving a point Portland already conceded.
Listen to The Jason Rantz Show on weekday afternoons from 3 p.m. – 7 p.m. on Seattle Red on 770 AM (HD Radio 97.3 FM HD-Channel 3). Subscribe to the podcast here. Follow Jason Rantz on X, Instagram, YouTube, and Facebook.






Comments
3 Comments
Wait, you mean taking a dump on a piece of bread isn't a sandwich? But it sounds like a sandwich. Seattle should eat that sandwich, what could possibly go wrong?
seems ever so likely seattle will double down on it
But Jason, socialist Katie will draw on her vast business and economic experience to do the vacancy tax right. Things that never work will eventually work if you just do them right.