ADVERTISEMENT

ENERGY

Jay Inslee ripped for celebrating Washington Supreme Court ruling striking down voter-approved I-2066

Former Washington Gov. Jay Inslee faced backlash after celebrating the state Supreme Court’s decision striking down voter-approved Initiative 2066 on natural gas.

former Governor Jay Inslee...

Former Washington Gov. Jay Inslee celebrated the state Supreme Court’s decision striking down Initiative 2066, prompting critics to accuse him of dismissing the will of voters who approved the natural gas measure in 2024. (Photo by Mat Hayward/Getty Images for for Community Change Action)

(Photo by Mat Hayward/Getty Images for for Community Change Action)

Former Washington Gov. Jay Inslee celebrated the Washington Supreme Court’s decision to strike down a natural gas initiative approved by nearly 2 million voters, prompting critics to accuse the Democrat of showing contempt for the voters whose decision was nullified.

The Washington Supreme Court ruled 6-3 Thursday that Initiative 2066 violated the Washington Constitution’s single-subject requirement. Voters approved the measure in November 2024. The court’s majority concluded the initiative contained multiple subjects and that its provisions could not be severed, making the entire measure unconstitutional.

Inslee, whose administration pursued policies aimed at transitioning Washington away from natural gas, quickly celebrated the result.

“Today, the Washington Supreme Court ruled I-2066 unconstitutional,” Inslee posted on X.

“Above all: This is a major victory for the health of Washingtonians, for our clean air and water, and for our utility bills—prevailing over the deception of corporate special interests and big polluters.”

Jay Inslee blasted for reaction

The response from critics was immediate, with several accusing Inslee of celebrating the nullification of a decision made directly by voters.

“Everyone hates you. How is Idaho?” PNW Conservative responded, referencing the rumor that Inslee moved out of state after helping make Washington astronomically expensive.

Attorney Hollaría Briden wrote, “Washingtonians shouldn’t be allowed to vote – it creates extra work for democrats who want to overturn results.”

ADVERTISEMENT

Another X user, Elan, called the decision “a hit for democracy,” adding: “Voters need to be represented, not ruled.”

Beth Dutton responded to Inslee: “You always support doing the opposite of what Washingtonians want or vote for. Why is that?”

Brian Heywood, founder of Let’s Go Washington and one of the leading forces behind I-2066, was more pointed.

“So this world class moron thinks (ok, fair point, maybe ‘think’ is too generous of an assumption) that eliminating clean natural gas in just Washington state will 1) have any kind of meaningful impact on the environment and 2) lower utility costs,” Heywood wrote in response to Inslee.

What happened to I-2066

As Seattle Red previously reported, I-2066 was filed by the Building Industry Association of Washington to stop state and local governments from banning, restricting or discouraging natural gas service. It repealed portions of House Bill 1589, the 2024 law affecting Puget Sound Energy’s transition away from natural gas, and rolled back energy-code provisions affecting gas heating in new construction.

ADVERTISEMENT

Climate Solutions, Washington Conservation Action, Front and Centered, King County and the city of Seattle were among the plaintiffs challenging the initiative.

King County Superior Court Judge Sandra Widlan invalidated the measure in 2025. The state Supreme Court’s Sept. 17 opinion affirmed that outcome, but on the single-subject issue.

Here’s what the Justices said

Chief Justice Debra Stephens wrote for the majority that the initiative contained provisions with distinct purposes and regulatory effects.

“It is not possible by judicial construction to sever and save any of the separate provisions and therefore I-2066 is unconstitutional in its entirety,” Stephens wrote.

Justice Salvador Mungia dissented, joined by Justices Charles Johnson and Sheryl Gordon McCloud. Mungia argued the court could have removed constitutionally defective portions while allowing much of the voter-approved law to survive.

ADVERTISEMENT

“Courts are required to construe initiatives in favor of constitutionality when possible,” Mungia wrote. “This court can uphold much of I-2066 as constitutional and should do so.”

The ruling eliminated the natural gas protections approved by Washington voters. Inslee’s celebration then shifted part of the political debate from the legal merits of the ruling to whether elected officials should celebrate when courts invalidate measures passed directly by voters.

Follow Seattle Red on-air at 770 AM, on the Seattle Red app, and streaming audio and video on SeattleRed.com.

Comments

2 Comments

Q
Quint M 2 months ago

Should arrest him for fraud waste and abuse. The ferries where he had them cut up the diesel engines which cost 100s of thousands to show we were moving away from diesel in his little wonder land. The ferries still use those engines so he wasted several for some show stunt. Tax dollars at work.

S
Sean S 2 months ago

The federal DOJ should really look into a former governor of a state that he no longer lives in but is still agitating for political agenda that he had a part in, put a fine cone through any conflicts of interest and his resources.