Starbucks’ hometown loses coffee crown to Orlando as Seattle cafés battle $21.30 wages and street crime
Seattle, home of Starbucks, finished fifth in WalletHub's 2026 coffee city ranking. Are the city's wage mandates and soft-on-crime policies squeezing cafés?
Seattle finished fifth in WalletHub's 2026 ranking of the best coffee cities in America. (Jason Rantz)
(Jason Rantz)
Seattle, the birthplace of Starbucks, finished fifth in WalletHub’s 2026 ranking of America’s best coffee cities, behind Orlando, Portland, Miami and Long Beach. The city that taught the country to order a venti latte now trails Florida’s theme park capital.
The personal finance site published its study on September 16, comparing the 100 largest U.S. cities across 12 metrics. Orlando topped the list with a score of 68.55, while Seattle posted 64.27. Seattle also placed fifth last year and hasn’t cracked the top three since 2024.
WalletHub’s formula doesn’t measure what it costs to keep a café open in Seattle. Local shop owners pay one of the highest wages in America, in a downtown where Nordstrom says police responded to just 29% of its flagship store’s 911 calls. Imagine the rankings if they took that into account.
Seattle coffee drinkers still spend, but the shops are losing ground
A Seattle Red review of WalletHub’s methodology shows where the city is vulnerable.
Only two of the 12 metrics get double weight, coffee shops per capita and affordable shops rated 4.5 stars or higher per capita. Both depend on how many cafés can survive in a given city.
The city ranked fourth in average household coffee spending, ahead of Portland and Orlando.
“But the costs of having one or more cups of Joe daily can add up, especially as prices inflate. In the cities that are craziest about coffee, the average household may spend as much as $327 per year on the beverage,” WalletHub analyst Chip Lupo said in the study.
Wage mandates and street crime squeeze Seattle cafés
Seattle’s minimum wage jumped to $21.30 an hour in January, while the statewide minimum comes in at $17.13. The city also stopped letting small employers count tips toward the wage in 2025. The Washington Hospitality Association warned last fall that restaurants were already squeezed before the latest increase.
“Normally when costs go up, you dip into your margins. Well, Washington has one of the lowest profit margins in the country, down to 1.5%,” association President and CEO Anthony Anton told The Center Square.
Crime adds to the bill, too
Starbucks closed several Seattle stores in 2022, including locations at Westlake Center and Union Station, citing safety concerns. In January, the owner of Unwind Café in West Seattle told West Seattle Blog that burglars broke in overnight and stole her online ordering tablets. King County prosecutors say organized retail theft is already driving some stores out of vulnerable neighborhoods.
Earlier this month, 38 of the region’s largest employers, including the chief executive of Starbucks, sent Mayor Katie Wilson a letter demanding a 100-day public safety plan. Seattle Police Officers Guild President Kent Loux has argued that enforcing low level crime is how Seattle keeps businesses alive.
“We need to be business friendly. We need to be attracting businesses, and part of that is enforcing low level misdemeanor crime so that businesses can flourish, pay their rent, pay their employees, and ultimately pay their taxes,” Loux told The Jason Rantz Show on Seattle Red 770 AM in April.
Follow Seattle Red on-air at 770 AM, on the Seattle Red app, and streaming audio and video on SeattleRed.com.






Comments
0 Comments