Bob Ferguson’s office gave full-time telework for home renovations but denied it to ten women citing their faith, petition says
Ten women fired under Ferguson's AGO vaccine policy ask the full Ninth Circuit to revive their religious discrimination case, citing precedent a panel ignored.
Ten former Washington Attorney General's Office employees filed a petition September 8 asking the full Ninth Circuit to rehear their religious discrimination case against Bob Ferguson. (Governor Bob Ferguson's Office)
(Governor Bob Ferguson's Office)
Ten women fired from the Washington State Attorney General’s Office (AGO) under Bob Ferguson’s COVID-19 vaccine policy are asking the full Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals to take up their religious discrimination case, arguing a three-judge panel tossed it without mentioning the court’s own precedent. Their petition, filed September 8 and reviewed by Seattle Red, accuses the panel of deciding a claim the women never made.
The plaintiffs, investigators, paralegals, legal assistants and a fiscal analyst, sued Ferguson, who is now the governor, and the AGO officials who denied their accommodation requests. A federal judge in Tacoma dismissed the case on qualified immunity grounds, and on August 11 the panel affirmed, writing that the women had not identified a single case invalidating a vaccine mandate on free exercise grounds.
The petition says that reasoning missed the point. The state conceded in court that the AGO was never covered by Governor Jay Inslee’s Proclamation 21-14; Ferguson’s office wrote its own policy and built its own exemption system, which the women say is where the alleged discrimination happened.
The numbers the AGO kept
According to the petition, the AGO accepted 33 religious exemption requests as sincere. Its records report outcomes for only 24, three of which were accommodated; the other nine are unaccounted for. Over the same period it accommodated eight of 16 medical requests and granted full-time telework for home renovation, childcare and commute reduction. Internal communications directed staff to interpret religious exemptions “as narrow as possible.”
Seven of the ten plaintiffs had their beliefs accepted as sincere, but none received an accommodation. All but one had worked remotely for roughly 18 months when the denials came. A former Seattle police officer made a similar claim against the City of Seattle after he was fired despite winning a religious exemption.
Attorney Jennifer W. Kennedy, who filed the petition, said the panel misidentified the right her clients were asserting.
“The right at issue is not a ‘right to refuse Covid vaccination,’ it’s the clearly established right to be free from religious discrimination in the workplace. And for the top lawyer in the state of Washington, it cannot be said that the AGO was unaware of the rights it was trampling,” Kennedy said in a statement.
A precedent the panel never cited
The petition relies on Bacon v. Woodward, a 2024 Ninth Circuit opinion that reinstated a lawsuit by Spokane firefighters denied religious exemptions under the same Inslee proclamation.
The AGO told the Washington Supreme Court in July that at least 323 plaintiffs in state and federal court have pending religious accommodation claims tied to vaccine requirements. Kennedy also represented eight Snohomish Regional Fire and Rescue firefighters whose exemption appeal the Ninth Circuit rejected last year.
Lead plaintiff Allison Hanson, a former tort investigator, described what the denial cost her.
“I was three months shy of 25 years of service when my employment ended because of my sincerely held religious beliefs. My religious exemption had been approved, and I had been teleworking successfully for nearly two years,” Hanson said.
Former paralegal Jennifer Wagner recounted losing her home, her insurance and her retirement.
“If I had not been terminated, I would have continued my career with the Attorney General’s Office and retired as I had planned at 67. I now struggle to meet my daily needs. I don’t know whether I will ever be able to retire, and I don’t know if I will ever again have a home of my own,” Wagner said.
En banc review is rarely granted. If it is, the women want the case sent back to Tacoma for discovery.
Follow Seattle Red on-air at 770 AM, on the Seattle Red app, and streaming audio and video on SeattleRed.com.






Comments
0 Comments