ADVERTISEMENT

JASON RANTZ OPINION

Rantz: The Seattle Times says 98% of millionaires will stay and pay, but Washington’s budget does not run on headcounts

Washington's income tax revenue rests on a few hundred filers. The Seattle Times counted people instead of dollars and called it reassuring.

Seattle Times newspaper sign (Jason Rantz)...

Former Seattle Times sports columnist Matt Calkins says the paper would have spiked nearly every column he has written since joining OutKick. (Jason Rantz)

(Jason Rantz)

The Seattle Times spent a full feature asking whether Washington millionaires are really leaving to dodge the new 9.9% income tax, then answered the question with a headcount. Bodies do not fund state government. Dollars do. Nobody at the paper seemed curious about the difference.

State revenue officials estimate 25,000 households will owe roughly $3.5 billion a year once the tax hits in 2028. Cornell sociologist Cristobal Young told the Times that Washington should expect to lose about 1.9% of its million-dollar earners, which works out to 475 people. “98% of millionaires are staying and paying that higher tax,” he claimed. That is comforting only if all 25,000 households write checks of identical size, which is not remotely how this works.

Washington already ran a version of this experiment with the capital gains tax.

Ten filers, half the revenue

In its first year, the capital gains tax brought in $786 million, and the ten largest payments accounted for $394 million of it. Ten filers. Half the money. The next year the total fell to $433 million before swinging back up to roughly $1.5 billion. That is the revenue model Democrats are now scaling up, and they have committed the spending in advance.

So ask the follow-up the Times never bothered with. Which 475 leave? If the wrong dozen households redomicile to Nevada before 2029, the 24,988 who stay put will not cover the hole. Young’s own research measures what happens when a state nudges its top rate a point or two over years. Washington had no income tax for 90 years and is installing 9.9% in one move. The paper concedes that in a single sentence, then keeps quoting the model as if the sentence were not there.

ADVERTISEMENT

Olympia panicked first

Here is the fact the Times gave one paragraph near the bottom. Washington Democrats hiked the state estate tax to 35%, the highest in the country, watched wealthy residents start calling their attorneys, and rolled it back to 20% within a year.

The same Democratic party that calls wealth flight a right-wing fairy tale believed in wealth flight enough to undo its own tax, then turned around and passed an income tax five times steeper. They also know who is watching. A Gig Harbor investment executive who went public about leaving over the income tax got a Department of Revenue audit notice two weeks later.

An upgrade of our rich people

The Times chose to end its piece with a tech executive who supports the tax and figures departing millionaires get swapped out for better ones.

“To some extent this is an opportunity for an upgrade of our rich people,” Bryan Kirschner said. The paper could have closed on the volatility or the estate tax retreat, and instead handed the last word to a guy suggesting Washington will be issued nicer millionaires. Underneath that quote is the disclosure that Microsoft Philanthropies partially underwrote the media coverage, but don’t worry, the Times tells us the coverage is totally independent of the interests that fund it.

ADVERTISEMENT

You do not make a million dollars, and you still have a stake here. When top-heavy revenue misses, and it will, lawmakers do not cut. They come back for your sales tax, your gas tax, and the B&O tax on your employer.

Ballots go out in October, and conservatives who skip this one are voting against repeal whether they mean to or not.

Listen to The Jason Rantz Show on weekday afternoons from 3 p.m. – 7 p.m. on Seattle Red on 770 AM (HD Radio 97.3 FM HD-Channel 3). Subscribe to the podcast here. Follow Jason Rantz on X, Instagram, YouTube, and Facebook.

Jason Rantz Talk Show Host and Columnist at Seattle Red

Jason Rantz hosts The Jason Rantz Show on Seattle Red 770 AM weekdays from 3 p.m. to 7 p.m.

Comments

8 Comments

E
Evan Lattimore 3 months ago

Did they do a piece on how tax money is being squandered? There's capital flight, it's going down the drain giving no returns for tax payers. All The Seattle Times ever does is spin and flat out lie. If they were to shutdown the region and state would benefit greatly.

D
David Anfinrud 3 months ago

I am not surprised that the Seattle Times gives such a one sided view on the subject. Acting like thy know everything. Hiding the real cost of ever rising State and Local government spending which never fixes anything. Billions spent on homelessness nothing solved just growing numbers and even more pollution in the streets from the homeless camps. I saw a guy today outside a 7-11 this morning calling to kill the jews. No one there he just kept ranting away. The clerk says he come daily and does it for an hour then goes away. We both agreed that this guy needed help but current policies do not help those with issues like this. But enable the bad behavior. Government looks to spend more money on issues but never solves it. What is that money being used for actually. That is the question no one looks at. Who is getting rich at the cost of lack of help to those in need.

D
Dee Davis 2 months ago

Seattle Times always says crazy things, however, they never bring the receipts for what they say. Zero integrity. Anybody can make up stats!