ADVERTISEMENT

SEATTLE NEWS ARCHIVES & FEATURES

Judge hears Puyallup wrestler’s plea for protection from male opponents

A federal judge in Tacoma heard arguments Tuesday over whether Kallie Keeler can be guaranteed female-only opponents after an alleged assault.

Washington state high school wrestler Kallie Keeler....

A federal judge in Tacoma heard arguments Tuesday in the case of a Puyallup wrestler who says she was sexually assaulted during a girls tournament match. (Alliance Defending Freedom)

(Alliance Defending Freedom)

Kallie Keeler says a biological male sexually assaulted her during a girls tournament match in December 2025, and eight months later her school district still refuses to promise her mother it will not happen again. Now, a federal judge in Tacoma is deciding whether the Puyallup teenager can return to wrestling this season without being put on the mat against a male opponent.

Keeler was 15 and a sophomore at Rogers High School when she wrestled a male competing in the girls division at a Dec. 6, 2025 tournament. Nobody at the school told her. Nobody told her mother, Stephanie Brown, who recorded the match from across the gym. Alliance Defending Freedom sued the Washington Interscholastic Activities Association (WIAA), state schools Superintendent Chris Reykdal and the Puyallup School District in June on behalf of the family.

On Tuesday, ADF attorneys went before the U.S. District Court for the Western District of Washington asking for emergency relief before classes resume.

What ADF asked the judge to order

Kate Anderson, senior counsel at Alliance Defending Freedom and director of the ADF Center for Parental Rights, explained what the family wants from the court.

“She’s a girl who’s been wrestling since she was four, but she was unknowingly placed on the mat to wrestle against a male athlete, and her school didn’t tell her, and didn’t tell her mother ahead of time. That athlete then sexually assaulted her. She reported it,” Anderson said on The Jason Rantz Show on Seattle Red 770 AM.

The relief sought is specific and, by Anderson’s account, entirely within the district’s power to grant.

“So, we were asking the court to step in and to ensure that she can both transfer to another high school so that she doesn’t have to wrestle or take classes under the same administration and with the same coaches who didn’t protect her last year, and then that she be able to wrestle and be promised by her school that she will only be matched against female athletes, and they can do that using the information that they have, but they have declined to promise her or her mom this kind of notice and opt out going forward,” Anderson said.

ADVERTISEMENT

The district says there is no right to opt out

Rather than concede the notification request, the district defended the policy itself.

“They’re defending their policy and saying that they have every right to have a policy where males can participate in women’s sports if they identify as female, and that there’s no requirement under the constitutional law that parents get to opt their kids out of that,” Anderson told Rantz. “It’s not how the recent case law from the Supreme Court works.”

The U.S. Supreme Court ruled in June that states may bar biological males from girls athletics, but that decision does not impact Washington state’s decision to continue allowing it. Anderson argued the school has a far simpler off-ramp available.

“We certainly think federal law protects her outright, but at most, this school needs to provide her mom the information she needs specific to matches, so that she can make the right decision,” she said.

ADVERTISEMENT

Two Rogers administrators face criminal charges

Running alongside the civil case is a criminal one. Pierce County prosecutors charged Rogers High School Principal Jason Smith and athletic coordinator Peter Collins in July with failing to comply with Washington’s mandatory reporting law, a gross misdemeanor. Brown reported the alleged assault in writing on Dec. 8. A school resource officer did not learn of it until Jan. 30, 53 days later, well past the 48 hours state law allows.

“The prosecutor in… Pierce County decided to go ahead and charge two of the officials that received Kallie’s reports and the reports from her mom and then failed to pass those on under their mandatory reporting requirements for several months. The reporting requirements are pretty clear. If there’s an allegation of sexual assault, it needs to be reported to authorities,” Anderson noted.

ADVERTISEMENT

ADF is not a party to that case.

What happens next?

Anderson said the judge appeared to grasp how little time is left before the school year begins.

“The judge did a wonderful job of listening carefully. He had read everything carefully, that was clear, and was struggling with the right, difficult questions on a case like this. I think he’s thinking very deeply about the issues here, and he assured the parties that he understood the urgency, too, with the school starting so soon in just a couple of weeks,” she said. “But you can never tell exactly how a case is going to go.”

Public reaction has run heavily in Keeler’s favor, including in a state whose officials wrote the policy at issue. Anderson said the response has not been uniformly kind.

“There are meaningful differences between men and women, and there are reasons why federal law, for decades and decades, has separated men and women in their sports. And what happened in particular to this girl is particularly horrific, and so I think it has awakened some people to the realities that are there already because of this shocking incident,” she said. “It has been a bit disturbing in this case to see some of the backlash and just some of the horrible things people have said to her.”

ADVERTISEMENT

Case filings are posted at the ADF case page for K.M.K. v. Washington Interscholastic Activities Association. A ruling is expected within weeks.

Listen to The Jason Rantz Show on weekday afternoons from 3 p.m. – 7 p.m. on Seattle Red on 770 AM (HD Radio 97.3 FM HD-Channel 3). Subscribe to the podcast here. Follow Jason Rantz on X, Instagram, YouTube, and Facebook.

Comments

1 Comments

J
joe smalltown 3 months ago

I got a dollar that says the judge will side with the m0lester and his accomplices, the admins at Rogers.

The judge will probably say she was asking for it.