ADVERTISEMENT

PORTLAND

Portland councilor floats new rules on how stores set prices with AI and surveillance

Portland Councilor Eric Zimmerman is drafting rules on algorithmic retail pricing, with public testimony set for August 11 before the City Life Committee.

a man grocery shopping...

A Portland city councilor is developing legislation to regulate personalized algorithmic pricing on retail goods. (Photo by Brandon Bell/Getty Images)

(Photo by Brandon Bell/Getty Images)

A Portland city councilor wants to write new rules for how stores set their prices, starting with a practice nobody has yet shown is happening inside Portland retail shops.

Councilor Eric Zimmerman announced on July 30 that he is developing legislation to regulate what his office calls surveillance-based, algorithmic pricing on retail goods. The target is personalized pricing, in which a business uses personally identifiable information and an algorithm to charge one customer more than another for the identical product.

The proposal is still in what Zimmerman’s office describes as the discovery phase, meaning there is no ordinance text yet. Registration for public testimony opens August 7, with the City Council’s City Life Committee taking comment on August 11 at 2 p.m.

What Zimmerman wants Portland retailers to do

The announced framework would set expectations for when and how retail prices may change, limit how frequently a retailer can raise a price, and require stores capable of dynamic pricing to disclose that fact to shoppers. Store loyalty programs, rewards accounts, subscription memberships, coupons and ordinary sales would be untouched.

“Affordability is top of mind for Portlanders right now,” Zimmerman said in the release. “We’re already seeing surveillance pricing when we shop online, book travel, and use rideshare apps. As this practice expands, we must establish reasonable consumer protections, preserve loyalty programs and discounts, and allow retailers to remain competitive while preventing exploitative pricing practices.”

ADVERTISEMENT

Every example Zimmerman cites involves online checkout carts, airline booking sites and rideshare apps. None of them is a Portland grocery store, which is precisely the scenario his release asks readers to imagine.

A council that keeps writing rules for storefronts it cannot fill

This council has spent the past two years handing local shop owners new obligations. It mandated all-user restroom signage that businesses must pay to install, commissioned a $62,000 study on fining property owners for empty storefronts, and banned gas-powered leaf blowers. Meanwhile, respondents to Gov. Tina Kotek’s own Prosperity Council survey said taxes and regulation are what make Oregon businesses hard to keep open.

Food costs have climbed roughly 33 percent nationally since 2019 and economists say prices rise fast and fall slowly, which has almost nothing to do with algorithms and quite a lot to do with the cost of operating a store. Zimmerman’s answer is a new compliance regime for retailers rather than a look at the fees and mandates his own council keeps stacking on top of them.

ADVERTISEMENT

Portlanders who want a say can register starting August 7.

Follow Seattle Red on-air at 770 AM, on the Seattle Red app, and streaming audio and video on SeattleRed.com.

Comments

0 Comments