WSJ torches Attorney General Nick Brown for rigging the ballot against income tax repeal
The Wall Street Journal editorial board accuses WA AG Nick Brown of writing misleading ballot language to sink the November income tax repeal initiative.
Representative Matt Marshall says a recall of Attorney General Nick Brown would rest on RCW 43.10.030.(Attorney General Nick Brown/Facebook)
(Attorney General Nick Brown/Facebook)
The Wall Street Journal editorial board is blistering Washington Attorney General Nick Brown, accusing him of writing deliberately misleading ballot language designed to sink the voter initiative that would repeal the state’s new income tax.
In an editorial published July 30, the Journal put Brown at the center of what it describes as a national effort by Democrats and their union allies to strangle citizen initiatives that threaten their taxing power. The paper singled out the one-sentence disclosure Brown’s office attached to Initiative 645, the measure Let’s Go Washington qualified for the November ballot after collecting more than 511,000 signatures. That sentence tells voters the repeal would cut money from schools, colleges and health care.
There is one problem with it. The tax has not collected a dollar and will not for years.
What the ballot language actually says
The disclosure drafted by Brown’s office reads, “This measure would decrease funding for public K-12 education, higher education (including universities and community colleges), and human services (primarily healthcare).”
Those 21 words appear below the ballot title, where voters will read them before marking their choice. The 9.9% tax on income above $1 million does not take effect until 2028, and the state does not expect revenue until 2029. The Journal dismantled the claim in a single line, noting that blocking a tax which has produced no revenue cannot reduce funding that does not yet exist.
“Democrats are trying to deceive voters because they know that raising income taxes isn’t popular. Many voters for good reason don’t buy their promises that their ‘millionaire’s tax’ won’t be extended to them. That’s the history of income taxes. Democrats inevitably seek to soak the middle class because that’s where the money is,” the editorial wrote.
The editorial also walked through the legal history Democrats are trying to route around. Washington’s constitution bars graduated taxes on intangible property, and the state Supreme Court has read that as a ban on progressive income taxes since 1933. Lawmakers passed the tax anyway, then watched the court rule it was necessary for state government and exempt from a public vote, forcing repeal backers into the harder initiative process with double the signature requirement.
The Journal ties Washington to a national playbook
Brown does not appear in the editorial as an isolated case.
The Journal presented Washington alongside Colorado, where the state Supreme Court threw out a measure requiring voter approval of large new fees, and California, where the court removed a tax-limitation initiative from the ballot in 2023 after Gov. Gavin Newsom sued. In each instance, judges appointed by Democratic governors kept the question away from voters.
The Journal concluded that Democrats mislead voters because they know income taxes poll badly, and that voters have good reason to doubt promises the tax will stay confined to millionaires. That skepticism has plenty of local critics. Seattle Red previously reported on internal emails showing Brown’s own spokesman privately trashing reporters who exposed his office’s role in engineering the tax, and on documents showing the office handed tax opponents redacted records after giving friendly reporters the unredacted versions.
Two lawsuits now target the disclosure
Let’s Go Washington is not waiting for an editorial page to fix the problem. The group filed suit in Thurston County Superior Court asking a judge to rewrite the language, arguing in its petition that the statement is inaccurate and would prejudice voters against the measure if it appears on the ballot. The campaign wants the sentence replaced with wording saying passage would increase funding for the current general fund.
Spokesman Darren Littell put it more plainly in an interview with The Center Square.
“It’s not accurate, because nothing is being cut from programs by voting yes for initiative 645,” he said.
A second suit, filed by open government advocate Arthur West, challenges whether the state can bolt government-written language onto a citizen initiative after signature gathering ends. West supports taxing high earners and signed I-645 anyway, worried lawmakers would eventually lower the threshold. A hearing is set for Aug. 7, and any ruling can be appealed directly to the state Supreme Court.
Follow Seattle Red on-air at 770 AM, on the Seattle Red app, and streaming audio and video on SeattleRed.com.






Comments
4 Comments
I love the Initiative feature of WA government. However, there seem to be 2 fatal flaws:
1) the idea is that regular people can challenge government overreach. But if the very people who wrote the laws that we regular people want to challenge are the ones writing the text to be included on the ballot, then the people have already lost
2) after the car tabs initiative fiascos, government is emboldened to just ignore the initiatives they don't like. In my opinion, that inherently means all initiatives.
I have zero faith that anyone in WA State government represents me. Taxation without representation.
Nick Brown doesn't give a poo.
Interesting the sign in the Lil' Nicky photo says "Don't let Trump Change the Constitution". Seems to me the DSA's (I refer to them as something that's not postable here beginning with "Dumb" and ending with "Hole") are the ones wanting to change the Constitution, publicly wanting to get rid of the Senate, pack the Supreme court, kill Jews, espouse communisim...
But he is only doing what the party requires. How can that be his fault? :oP