Puyallup school officials charged over 55-day silence in wrestler’s assault report
Rogers High School's principal and athletic coordinator face charges after prosecutors say they waited 55 days to report a wrestler's sexual assault claim.
Alliance Defending Freedom filed an emergency application with the U.S. Supreme Court on behalf of Puyallup wrestler Kallie Keeler. (Photo: Alliance Defending Freedom)
(Photo: Alliance Defending Freedom)
Two administrators at Puyallup’s Rogers High School are now criminal defendants, accused of sitting on a teenage wrestler’s sexual assault report for nearly two months instead of calling police within the 48 hours state law allows.
Principal Jason Smith, 55, and athletic coordinator Peter Collins, 49, were charged July 21 in Pierce County District Court with failing to comply with Washington’s mandatory reporting law, a gross misdemeanor, according to The News Tribune. An arraignment was set for Aug. 3, and both men waived their right to appear.
The charges stem from a Dec. 6, 2025 match at Emerald Ridge High School in South Hill. Kallie Keeler, then 15, alleges her opponent, a biological male competing in the girls division, penetrated her on the mat while her mother recorded from across the gym. Keeler and her mother sued the WIAA, Superintendent Chris Reykdal and the Puyallup School District in federal court in June.
State law gave the school two days to pick up the phone. Prosecutors say it took 55.
What the charging documents describe
Keeler’s mother emailed wrestling coach Lucia Scott about the incident on Dec. 8, and Scott forwarded the message to Collins that afternoon. Collins looped in Smith. Court records state Smith told Scott he would contact Emerald Ridge’s athletic director and open an investigation. Keeler’s mother handed over video of the match that evening.
Then, nothing. On Jan. 28, Keeler messaged Scott through a school platform asking what had happened to the investigation. Scott replied that Smith would not tell her anything and pointed the girl back to the two administrators now facing charges.
Keeler filled out a school incident report on Jan. 30. Only that day, prosecutors say, did Smith flag the matter to a school resource officer and ask him to watch the video. That officer wrote the first police report to exist in the entire ordeal. Smith allegedly told him Keeler’s mother had raised something in December but had never mentioned a sexual assault. When Smith finally reported to the Department of Children, Youth and Families on Feb. 12, prosecutors say he gave a different account, this time citing a Dec. 9 phone call with the mother.
Prosecutors passed on the wrestler, not the adults
Pierce County prosecutors declined in June to charge the athlete Keeler accused, saying case law on consent in athletic contests made a conviction unlikely. Keeler never consented to wrestle a biological boy. Deputies had earlier described the video as inconclusive even as prosecutors weighed a rape charge. The adults who allegedly buried the report for 55 days did not get the same benefit of the doubt.
Smith’s attorney, Michael Stewart, defended his client to The News Tribune, calling him a beloved and award winning educator of more than 30 years who has put children first.
“Jason is a former Principal of the Year for the State of Washington and has a strong reputation for building a culture and climate that fosters staff and student success,” Stewart said. “Jason has faith in our legal system to get it right and looks forward to presenting his defense in court.” Collins’ attorney, Brett Purtzer, declined to comment.
Follow Seattle Red on-air at 770 AM, on the Seattle Red app, and streaming audio and video on SeattleRed.com.






Comments
3 Comments
Can their backsides, Take their pensions, Revoke their credentials and throw them
In prison. Send a message.
They broke the law and failed this student. They need to be prosecuted and held accountable.
Good. They failed this young woman in favor of a political agenda. They should be fired and charged with obstruction and accessories after the fact.
The only disappointment is the male predator that committed the awful offense is not punished. That is SO WRONG.