Alaska Airlines asked a question, then fired the Christians who answered. One lawyer says this case has major implications
Alaska Airlines fired two Christian flight attendants for answering a question it posed on the Equality Act. The Ninth Circuit just sent the case to a jury.
An Alaska Airlines plane takes off at Los Angeles International Airport (LAX) following the Thanksgiving holiday on December 2, 2024 in Los Angeles, California. (Photo: Mario Tama, Getty Images)
(Photo: Mario Tama, Getty Images)
Alaska Airlines is heading to a jury trial for firing two flight attendants who did nothing more than answer a question the company itself asked them.
Lacey Smith and Marli Brown were terminated in 2021 after the Seattle-based airline announced its support for the Equality Act on an internal employee forum and invited workers to comment. The two women, both Christians, responded through their faith. Alaska called their answers hateful and offensive and fired them. A federal district judge threw the case out before trial, but on June 24 the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals reversed that decision and sent it back for a jury to weigh, reviving claims against both the airline and the flight attendants’ union. You can read more in Seattle Red’s coverage of the decision.
Stephanie Taub, senior counsel at First Liberty Institute, argued the case before the appeals panel and represents both women. She’s celebrating the court’s reversal.
A question Alaska Airlines asked
“So, the company posted its support of the Equality Act, and then asked for comments. Lacey posted, as a company, do you think it’s possible to regulate morality? That was it, one question,” Taub said on The Jason Rantz Show on Seattle Red 770 AM.
Brown’s comment ran a little longer, roughly a paragraph, raising concerns about the legislation’s effect on churches, religious freedom, conscience protections, and the opening of women’s private spaces to anyone based on how they identify. Alaska deleted both posts the same day, launched investigations, and fired the women.
The airline had spent years branding itself as a progressive employer, even becoming the first U.S. carrier to roll out gender-neutral uniforms for its staff.
The union turned on them
The flight attendants’ union, the Association of Flight Attendants, is also a defendant, and Taub said the lawsuit exposed how the people meant to protect Smith and Brown instead worked to bury them.
The union president reported the two women’s comments to the airline while privately telling colleagues he hoped there would be repercussions and that he hated one of them, Taub said. According to court documents, a union representative wrote that Smith and Brown should be thrown in a burlap bag and dropped down a well, in a chat with other union reps.
“Employers need to realize that employees have many different faith backgrounds, and simply because you don’t like their religious beliefs, that is not an excuse to fire your employees, especially when they are simply respectfully disagreeing with a public policy position that you are posting on your internal website,” she added.
What a win means for workers of faith
The Ninth Circuit, not a court conservatives usually count on, did not rule on whether Alaska broke the law. It found only that the evidence was strong enough for a jury to hear. It is not the only Seattle workplace facing a discrimination claim; two openly gay Seattle police officers recently sued the city over promotions. Taub said the precedent here matters on its own.
“So this Ninth Circuit opinion is very important because it shows that employers can’t get away with just labeling these religious beliefs as offensive and firing them without any repercussions, so that’s what Alaska thought it could do. It thought it could get away with just saying we disagree with your religious beliefs and we’re going to fire you, but that’s not the case,” she told the show. “So employers need now this is precedent in the Ninth Circuit, so employers need to take this seriously and realize that they are on the hook for this kind of blatant religious discrimination.”
A trial date has not been set. Taub expects one in the next few months, with the case to be heard in Washington.
Listen to The Jason Rantz Show on weekday afternoons from 3 p.m. – 7 p.m. on Seattle Red on 770 AM (HD Radio 97.3 FM HD-Channel 3). Subscribe to the podcast here. Follow Jason Rantz on X, Instagram, YouTube, and Facebook.






Comments
5 Comments
Why even ask the question if you are going to fire someone for their opinion?
Sounds like the union president is the one who should be fired.
Huh, it's almost like religious beliefs are a legally protected enumeration.
Because a MAN should not be in a place where young GIRLS are exposed.
Make NO mistake, you can change your appearance through surgery, make-up, clothes...but you can NOT change WHAT you are.
If the skeleton of a trans-woman is found in the forest, and to identify it they run a DNA test on the bones, what gender/sex is the test going to show (really don't even need the DNA test to determine it, just one bone) ?