Alaska Airlines fired two Christians for faith-based comments. Now a jury will weigh in.
A federal appeals court revived the lawsuit of two Christian Alaska Airlines flight attendants fired in 2021 over their faith-based views, sending it to a jury.
Alaska Airlines is changing how much families pay to fly with infants on international award tickets. (Jason Rantz)
(Jason Rantz)
Alaska Airlines fired two veteran flight attendants for voicing mainstream Christian beliefs about sex and gender, after inviting feedback, and a federal appeals court has now ruled that a jury, not the company, should decide whether the firings broke federal civil rights law.
The Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals on Wednesday revived the lawsuit brought by Lacey Smith and Marli Brown, reversing a lower court that had thrown out their claims before trial. The two women, both Christians, were terminated in 2021 after responding to a post on an internal employee network in which Seattle-based Alaska Airlines announced its support for the Equality Act and invited workers to comment.
Smith had spent six years at the airline and Brown eight, both with clean disciplinary records.
The posts that got them fired
Smith’s offending contribution was a single question. “As a company, do you think its possible to regulate morality?” she wrote, according to court documents.
Brown went further, warning that the proposed federal law would erode protections for women and girls.
“The Equality Act would affect everything from girls’ and women’s showers and locker rooms to women’s shelters and women’s prisons, endangering safety and diminishing privacy,” she wrote in the same forum, according to court documents. “Giving people blanket permission to enter private spaces for the opposite sex enables sexual predators to exploit the rules and gain easy access to victims.”
Those are not fringe positions. They mirror the concerns of millions of Americans and of members of Congress who blocked the same legislation in the Senate. Alaska deleted both comments the day they were posted, opened investigations, and fired the women, calling their remarks discriminatory, hateful, and offensive. One airline vice president testified that Brown’s use of the phrase “opposite sex” was itself discriminatory because it implied there are only two sexes.
What the court actually decided
The appeals court did not declare Alaska broke the law. It ruled the evidence is strong enough for a jury to make that call, a defeat for an airline that wanted the case dismissed quietly.
“Indeed, Alaska was fully aware that some would object to the Equality Act for religious reasons,” the panel wrote in its opinion. “That Alaska created a forum for employee discussion on controversial issues, then fired Brown after she made religious objections of the kind Alaska anticipated, provides a further reason for regarding this case as presenting a genuine dispute of fact on the reason for Brown’s termination.”
Stephanie Taub, senior counsel at First Liberty Institute, which represents the two women, welcomed the ruling.
“We are grateful the court recognized the clear evidence of religious discrimination against Marli and Lacey by both Alaska Airlines and the flight attendants’ union,” she said. “The Ninth Circuit’s decision today reinforces that federal civil rights laws protect people of faith from discrimination by their employer or their union. You cannot be fired because your employer does not like your religious beliefs.”
A pattern worth noticing
The firings fit a company that has spent years leaning hard into gender ideology, from gender-neutral uniforms to pronoun pins for frontline staff. They echo a wider Washington pattern in which people of faith keep getting punished for refusing the state’s preferred orthodoxy, as when DCYF stripped a Christian foster family of its license over a pronoun mandate before settling a federal religious discrimination suit. The same favoritism shows up in how Seattle celebrates some forms of expression while treating Christians as the problem.
The case heads back to federal district court in Seattle. Smith and Brown are seeking reinstatement, back pay, and additional damages, and their attorneys expect a trial within months.
Follow Seattle Red on-air at 770 AM, on the Seattle Red app, and streaming audio and video on SeattleRed.com.





Comments
4 Comments
Didn't Alaska used to have prayer cards on the trays when they served meals in First Class?
Maybe after this lawsuit, Alaska can focus on keeping the doors on its planes during flight operations.
If they didn't want discussion, why ask the question? It wasn't necessary and had nothing to do with operations.