Why did city of Edmonds ditch cameras that find missing kids? Politics
Edmonds canceled its Flock Safety camera contract over privacy politics, even after the mayor admitted the cameras find missing kids and catch suspects.
The Lynnwood City Council is considering 24/7 school zone speed cameras months after canceling its Flock Safety contract. (Photo courtesy of Redmond Police Department)
(Photo courtesy of Redmond Police Department)
Edmonds has pulled the plug on its license plate cameras, and the official reasons say far more about Seattle-area politics than about public safety.
The City of Edmonds canceled its contract with Flock Safety, Mayor Mike Rosen announced at a Tuesday council meeting, making it the third Snohomish County city to walk away from the automated license plate reader company after Mountlake Terrace and Lynnwood. Rosen cited privacy concerns and a 404 Media report that the FBI wants to spend up to $36 million for warrantless access to a nationwide plate reader network. The city had already paused its 19-camera network back in December.
What Rosen glossed over is that those same cameras, by his own account, work.
Even while killing the contract, Rosen credited the technology with finding missing children through Amber Alerts, helping catch murder suspects, and recovering stolen cars across jurisdictions at remarkable speed. Then he canceled it anyway.
The case Edmonds buried in its own announcement
Dan Haley, chief legal officer at Flock Safety, says these decisions are running on the political moment rather than the record.
“I understand if that’s your politics, that’s your impulse, you want to do something, but it’s an ineffective gesture,” Haley said on The Jason Rantz Show on Seattle Red 770 AM, responding to cities that switch off cameras to protest immigration enforcement. He argued the company has nothing to do with ICE and never touches the footage itself.
“We don’t sell it, we don’t share it, we don’t provide side or back door access to it. If a community wants to share data with federal law enforcement, they can opt to do that, and if they want to absolutely prohibit that, they can do that as well,” Haley said.
The fear driving cities like Edmonds traces back to an October University of Washington report claiming federal agencies accessed Flock networks across the state thousands of times. Haley said the system was engineered to expose that kind of sharing, not conceal it.
“It is set it and if you decide to share data, every single sharing of data is permanently logged in the system,” he noted.
Flock contacted the report’s authors and submitted a correction, he added, though that correction rarely gets cited when the report comes up.
Politics over the people who benefit
Haley also pushed back on the surveillance-state framing that Democratic council members keep reaching for.
“These systems have no bias, they have no ability to have bias, and one would think that would be an attractive thing,” he said, pointing to low-income neighborhoods where the cameras cut crime.
He finished with a line pointed straight at the activists.
“None of us wants to live in a surveillance state. Nobody working at Flock wants to live in a surveillance state,” Haley said.
After Gov. Bob Ferguson signed Senate Bill 6002 in March, restricting how agencies share plate data, several paused cities flipped their cameras back on once the rules were settled. Spokane and Pierce counties went the opposite direction and shut their networks down entirely, saying the new law made the tool useless. Edmonds picked the option that scores the most political points while doing the least for the parents Haley keeps describing. The cameras worked. The council simply decided that working was not quite the point.
Follow Seattle Red on-air at 770 AM, on the Seattle Red app, and streaming audio and video on SeattleRed.com.






Comments
0 Comments