ADVERTISEMENT

TAXES

Leaked AG memo says Washington wealth tax has ‘realistic’ shot at being ruled unconstitutional

A leaked AG memo warned Gov. Bob Ferguson the proposed Washington wealth tax has a "realistic possibility" of being ruled unconstitutional.

Washington Gov. Bob Ferguson after a press conference about state tax policy....

Washington faces a projected $4 billion shortfall in the first year of the next budget after the November 16 revenue forecast. (Governor Bob Ferguson/Facebook)

(Governor Bob Ferguson/Facebook)

Washington Gov. Bob Ferguson received a confidential warning from his own Attorney General’s Office last year that the wealth tax Democrats keep dangling over the state has a “realistic possibility” of being struck down in court for violating the state constitution.

The March 7, 2025 memo, written by Assistant Attorney General Andrew Krawczyk and addressed to Ferguson, the Department of Revenue, and the Office of Financial Management, was obtained exclusively by The Center Square and reported Monday. The document examines the proposed Financial Intangible Assets Tax (FIAT), a 1% annual property tax on stocks, bonds, and other intangible assets worth more than $50 million per taxpayer.

AG’s office flags two structural problems

Krawczyk identified the wealth tax exemption itself as the constitutional weak point.

He wrote, “It is difficult to say how Washington courts would answer your questions concerning constitutional uniformity of the FIAT and the idea of a $10 million tax cap. There are unresolved reasonable arguments both for and against the constitutionality of the FIAT. The provisions that pose the greatest risk are the $50 million threshold exemption and the credit for similar taxes paid to another state.”

Washington’s constitution requires that property within the same class be taxed at the same rate, a rule that has tripped up every progressive income tax scheme Democrats have tried for nearly a century. The AG’s memo concedes the FIAT runs that same risk. Krawczyk warned, “If challenged, the FIAT will be presumed constitutional and proponents have some good arguments for defending it, however, the presence of this exemption creates a realistic possibility FIAT will be found to violate the requirements of Article VII section 1.”

ADVERTISEMENT

A cap on the tax makes the legal problem worse

Some legislators floated capping total liability under the wealth tax at $10 million per filer, according to The Center Square. The AG’s office said that idea makes the constitutional picture worse.

“Yes, this likely depends in part on how the cap is written, but generally a cap on total tax liability would increase the chance of the FIAT violating Article VII, section 1,” Krawczyk noted.

The memo added that capping the tax begins to resemble “tax bracketing,” which sits in murky constitutional territory after the 1930 ratification of Amendment 14.

Krawczyk did offer Ferguson a workaround. He suggested rewriting the policy as a full exemption tied to a characteristic of the owner rather than a partial exemption tied to asset value. Krawczyk recommended, “Accordingly, the Legislature could completely exempt the property of a person who had less than $50,000,000 in taxable assets. The property of a person who had more than $50 million in taxable assets would pay the tax on all taxable assets unless a different exemption applies.”

ADVERTISEMENT

Critics say the warning confirms what they have argued for years

Paul Guppy, vice president for research at the Washington Policy Center, told The Center Square the memo confirms what tax skeptics have argued for decades.

“What is the point of having a constitution if the leaders of the state don’t follow it? You don’t need to be a lawyer to understand the uniformity clause. The people who drafted it … knew it wasn’t technical. It was plain English,” Guppy argued.

Ferguson has already signed SB 6346, the 9.9% income tax on earnings over $1 million, which is facing its own lawsuit on identical uniformity grounds. The wealth tax was stripped from the final budget package this year after corporate pushback, but Washington Democrats have repeatedly signaled they intend to revive it as a test case to force the state Supreme Court to revisit its century of uniformity precedent. The AG’s own memo suggests their legal odds are not as comfortable as they have been pretending.

ADVERTISEMENT

Follow Seattle Red on-air at 770 AM, on the Seattle Red app, and streaming audio and video on SeattleRed.com.

Comments

1 Comments

C
Clockwork Wyrm 5 months ago

If WA had impartial Supreme Court judges, these unconstitutional taxes would have no chance. Unfortunately, we have activist judges who have no problem legislating from the bench. I have no confidence that the WA Supreme Court will rule correctly if they think they can get away with pushing their Leftist agenda.