Seattle’s housing market defies economic gravity. The Eastside is acting like an adult.
Seattle's median home price hit $1,025,000 in May even as inventory reached a 14-year high. Broker Matt Goyer says the market is defying gravity.
Washington’s single state school levy takes effect on 2027 property tax bills under ESSB 6162. (Glenda Krull)
(Glenda Krull)
Seattle home prices climbed back toward record highs in May even as inventory hit a 14-year peak, a contradiction that has even one of the city’s most-followed real estate brokers openly puzzled.
Matt Goyer of Urban Living, who tracks the Seattle and Eastside markets weekly, laid out the numbers in his latest newsletter. The median sale price in Seattle hit $1,025,000 in May, up $37,000 year over year, above the 2022 peak, and closing in on the 2025 record of $1,040,000. Total inventory rose 16% from a year ago, with three months of supply on the market, the highest level for any May since 2012. New listings were down 6% year over year.
In a normal market, that combination would cool prices. It hasn’t.
A 14-year inventory high meets a $1 million median
“Supply is steadily outpacing demand, yet prices refuse to budge. Despite inventory hitting a 14-year high in May, fierce competition for the right homes continues to push prices toward record highs,” Goyer wrote in his newsletter.
He also asked subscribers to help him make sense of it. “If anyone has a grand theory on why Seattle continues to completely defy gravity, please hit reply and let me know,” Goyer added.
His firm’s own deal flow underscores the point.
Goyer wrote that Urban Living helped a buyer chase a Ravenna home last week that was listed at $1.3 million, drew seven offers, and ultimately closed at $1.55 million. A Maple Leaf midcentury modern closed at 36% over its asking price the same week. The pattern that has defined Seattle’s housing market for months is one where the well-priced, well-located listings still spark bidding wars while everything else sits.
The numbers are likely impacted by the wealth exodus, with millionaires selling their homes as they escape the Washington Democrats’ income tax.
The Eastside is correcting; Seattle isn’t
Goyer’s data shows the picture is dramatically different east of Lake Washington.
Eastside inventory jumped 44% year over year, also a 14-year high. The Eastside median sale price dropped $35,000 from April to $1,675,000, a 10% dip from a year earlier. Months of supply hit 4.5.
“A massive 44% inventory spike has given Eastside buyers breathing room, turning the tables to create a more balanced market. Buyers are flexing their negotiation power, leading to a noticeable month-over-month price correction,” Goyer noted.
That correction is happening as Redfin calculates a Seattle-area buyer now needs to earn nearly $219,000 a year to afford the median home, an affordability ceiling that continues to thin the qualified buyer pool on both sides of the lake.
Bellevue’s high-end condo market splits
Goyer also flagged a widening gap inside Bellevue’s luxury condo segment. Park Row has racked up $100 million in pending sales right out of the gate, he wrote. A few blocks away, the Avenue tower, which is rebranding to Nobu Residences Bellevue, has closed only two condos all year. The Mari tower sat for six months without a sales team and still has roughly 50 homes left to move.
“To be honest, I was a bit skeptical when the Nobu rebrand first dropped, but bringing in their global ecosystem and a 10,000-square-foot destination restaurant is exactly the kind of shot in the arm that development needs to jumpstart sales,” Goyer wrote of the rebrand.
Seattle’s stretch of the market continues to outrun the regional trends, including the tax environment and tech layoffs that have been thinning the high-end buyer pool for more than a year. According to Goyer’s tracking, that pool is still showing up for the right Seattle listings, even as the overall inventory pile grows.






Comments
0 Comments