ADVERTISEMENT

JASON RANTZ OPINION

Rantz: Seattle activists have a new ‘trans refugee crisis’ and, surprise, there’s no proof it exists

Activists want Mayor Katie Wilson to declare a trans refugee crisis. The only problem: there's no data establishing one exists. Jason Rantz breaks it down.

Protester holding transgender pride flag outside the Supreme Court during legal fight over taxpayer...

Mayor Katie Wilson has signaled openness to the LGBTQ Commission's push for a formal civil emergency declaration, despite no verified data establishing a crisis exists. (Photo by Heather Diehl/Getty Images)

(Photo by Heather Diehl/Getty Images)

Seattle’s activist class has found its next crisis. Never mind that nobody can point to verified data establishing that one actually exists. When the word “crisis” gets attached to a sympathetic identity group, the assumption is that facts are optional and scrutiny is bigotry.

The latest push involves Seattle’s LGBTQ Commission, which sent a letter to Mayor Katie Wilson urging her to declare a formal civil emergency over an alleged wave of transgender “refugees” reportedly fleeing hostile states. The commission’s letter, first reported by Seattle Gay News and covered by MyNorthwest, frames these arrivals as “internally displaced persons” in language borrowed from international humanitarian law. Local media that has covered the demand barely mentions there’s no data to back it up, or breezes right by that key point.

That is not a coincidence. The framing is deliberate, and designed to manufacture a sense of scale and urgency that the underlying numbers simply do not support.

Show me the data

Here is the actual evidence underpinning this supposed crisis: a volunteer with Traction, an organization that serves transgender individuals, told a Texas publication that they have “at least 500 people in communication to move to the Seattle area.” Not 500 people who have moved. Five hundred people who have been in communication about the possibility of moving. That is the data. One anecdote from one volunteer at one advocacy group.

The commission’s letter to Wilson acknowledges that “specific numbers on trans migration to Seattle haven’t been studied.” Let me translate that for you. Nobody has the numbers, but they want the declaration anyway. They want the emergency status, the city funding, the coordinated response, and the bureaucratic infrastructure built around a crisis that has not been measured, quantified, or verified.

ADVERTISEMENT

Is it possible that some transgender people moved to Seattle from states with more restrictive laws? Of course it is. People move to Seattle all the time for all kinds of reasons. Seattle being a destination for progressive demographics is not a news story, let alone a civil emergency. What is happening here is the political weaponization of individual relocation decisions to manufacture a collective victim narrative, and then demanding the city respond to that narrative as though it were a documented catastrophe.

We’ve seen this playbook before

The pattern is familiar.

After the Supreme Court overturned Roe v. Wade, the left promised mass death from back-alley abortions. Demonstrators showed up in Handmaid’s Tale costumes to illustrate the coming dystopia. Elected officials competed to see who could make the most alarming declaration about reproductive rights in their jurisdiction. Years later, the predicted catastrophe never materialized. What materialized was political organizing.

ADVERTISEMENT

This trans refugee narrative follows the same storyline and strategy. The Seattle school district that was caught handing out chest binders and tucking underwear to students at Garfield High did not produce a crisis either, despite the activist framing. It produced headlines, outrage, and bureaucratic entrenchment. That is the goal here, too.

Katie Wilson’s political calculus

Wilson’s response to the LGBTQ Commission’s letter was essentially a promise to set up a working group. She wrote that she believes “the most effective and substantive next step is to convene a team alongside the Seattle Office for Civil Rights to work directly with the LGBTQ Commission, the City Council, City agencies, community organizations, and regional partners.” That is the language of a politician who needs to give her activist base something without committing to anything specific, because there is nothing specific to commit to. If that’s the end of this, Wilson should be lauded for pushing off activists who haven’t made their case, but still need to be addressed for political reasons.

ADVERTISEMENT

But I fear, Wilson will give in. She responds to the loudest voices in the room, regardless of whether the underlying claim holds up. The LGBTQ Commission is part of that activist ecosystem, and placating it is a political necessity for a self-described democratic socialist mayor who ran on progressive credentials and now has to deliver something that looks like action.

Declaring a crisis does not invent one. It invents a program, a budget line, and a bureaucracy built around a narrative that was never required to meet any evidentiary standard in the first place. Seattle’s real crises, the ones involving homelessness, public safety, and a mayor who has already picked a fight with the city’s largest employer, do not disappear because a new crisis gets declared. They just get less attention and fewer resources.

Wilson can convene all the working groups she wants. None of them will produce data that did not exist before the letter was written.

ADVERTISEMENT

Listen to The Jason Rantz Show on weekday afternoons from 3 p.m. – 7 p.m. on Seattle Red on 770 AM (HD Radio 97.3 FM HD-Channel 3). Subscribe to the podcast here. Follow Jason Rantz on X, Instagram, YouTube, and Facebook.

Jason Rantz Talk Show Host and Columnist at Seattle Red

Jason Rantz hosts The Jason Rantz Show on Seattle Red 770 AM weekdays from 3 p.m. to 7 p.m.

Comments

6 Comments

A
Angry Orchard 6 months ago

Activists: gender confusion is not a mental disorder.

Also activists: trans people need special social services from society because of their mental health issues.

P
PF George 6 months ago

Also activists: We have no idea what we're protesting against, but we NEED to protest!

W
WhyYou NeedName 6 months ago

I guess Snake Plissken's next movie will be 'Escape from Seattle". Oh wait, it's already happening.