ADVERTISEMENT

LEGAL

Religious families can serve as foster parents in Washington after DCYF drops gender ideology mandate

Washington's DCYF agreed to drop its pronoun mandate for religious foster families and pay $250,000 in fees to settle a federal religious discrimination lawsuit.

Shane and Jennifer DeGross, represented by Alliance Defending Freedom, outside federal court after ...

Shane and Jennifer DeGross fostered children in Washington for nine years before the state pulled their license in 2022 over a gender ideology mandate. Their federal lawsuit forced DCYF to scrap the pronoun rule entirely and pay $250,000 in attorneys' fees. (Alliance Defending Freedom)

(Alliance Defending Freedom)

Washington’s Department of Children, Youth, and Families (DCYF) has agreed to a permanent injunction barring officials from denying foster care licenses to religious families who refuse to push gender ideology on children in their care. The settlement ends a federal lawsuit filed by a Tacoma-area Christian couple who spent nine years fostering children before the state stripped their license because they would not certify compliance with a pronoun mandate.

This is the second time DCYF has been forced to settle over its policies excluding religious families. The state previously reached a separate agreement with a couple seeking to care for their great-granddaughter. Rather than learning from that outcome, Washington Democrats enacted a new rule requiring all foster parents to use a child’s chosen pronouns. The predictable result was more lawsuits, more losses, and a $250,000 attorneys’ fees bill taxpayers have to pay.

Nine years, then a licensing ban

Shane and Jennifer DeGross fostered children from 2013 until the state began enforcing its pronoun mandate in 2022. When their license came up for renewal, DCYF told them they would need to sign off on the new gender ideology requirements. They refused on religious grounds and lost their license.

The DeGrosses, represented by Alliance Defending Freedom attorneys, sued state officials in 2024 for religious discrimination. Washington allowed them to re-apply, but after a prolonged renewal process, officials still refused to issue a standard license. The restriction was explicit: the couple could not receive placement of any child over five years old unless they abandoned their religious convictions about biological sex.

ADVERTISEMENT

That restriction drew a rebuke from a federal district court in April, which found the policy requiring foster parents to socially “transition” children plausibly violated the First Amendment. Pressure on DCYF had been building for weeks even before the settlement was reached.

Settlement terms and what changes

Under the agreement, DCYF will revise its licensing policies to stop attaching conditions or restrictions to a license based solely on an applicant’s religious beliefs, covering speech and actions related to marriage, gender, or sexual relationships. The state will also remove its regulation requiring foster parents to use chosen pronouns entirely.

ADF Senior Counsel Johannes Widmalm-Delphonse welcomed the news in a statement.

“Washington’s policy failed to respect religious diversity because it singled out applicants with traditional religious beliefs on the sanctity of the human body,” he said. “The DeGrosses merely asked to be treated the same as any other family — without being asked to compromise their core beliefs. This is a win-win because it will ensure more families can serve as foster parents to help meet the needs of every precious child in Washington’s foster-care system. We are thrilled to see common sense and religious liberty prevail.”

ADVERTISEMENT

Washington already faces serious scrutiny over DCYF’s stewardship of child welfare. Blacklisting experienced, faith-based families over a pronoun litmus test was never child-welfare policy. It was ideology.

Listen to The Jason Rantz Show on weekday afternoons from 3 p.m. – 7 p.m. on Seattle Red on 770 AM (HD Radio 97.3 FM HD-Channel 3). Subscribe to the podcast here. Follow Jason Rantz on X, Instagram, YouTube, and Facebook.

Jason Rantz Talk Show Host and Columnist at Seattle Red

Jason Rantz hosts The Jason Rantz Show on Seattle Red 770 AM weekdays from 3 p.m. to 7 p.m.

Comments

1 Comments

C
Candis Gauvin 6 months ago

Awesome 🙏