ADVERTISEMENT

JASON RANTZ OPINION

Rantz: Why Seattle liberals tolerate homelessness and open drug use on their streets

Seattle liberals vote for the politicians who caused the homelessness crisis, then defend them. Jason Rantz on the psychology behind the willful blindness.

A person covered by a blanket sits slumped against a shuttered storefront on a downtown Seattle sid...

A person slumped against a shuttered downtown Seattle storefront, draped in a blanket with belongings piled beside them, as foot traffic moves past feet away. (Jason Rantz / Seattle Red)

(Jason Rantz / Seattle Red)

I’ve spent years asking (and being asked) a version of the same question. How do liberal Seattle residents live in a city where people die of fentanyl overdoses on the sidewalk, where parks that used to host kids’ soccer games are now open-air drug markets, where blocks of downtown look like something out of a war documentary; and still come out defending the politicians and policies that made it this way?

The easy answer is ideology. Seattle progressives believe what they believe. But that’s not actually an answer. It’s a label. The more interesting question is psychological: what internal mechanism allows an intelligent adult to watch a decade of failure unfold in real time and conclude the problem is everyone else?

I think there are several things happening at once. None of them reflect well on the people involved.

The guilt that dare not speak its name

A meaningful share of Seattle’s progressive voters know, on some level, that they caused this. They voted for the politicians who banned encampment sweeps. The defund movement had their enthusiastic support. They dismissed everyone who warned this would get worse. And now it’s worse.

Admitting that publicly would require accepting real responsibility. Not just intellectual responsibility. Moral responsibility. They watched people die in encampments they voted to protect. They funded politicians who distributed fentanyl smoking kits instead of demanding treatment. Coming to terms with that is genuinely painful to those with a soul. So most don’t. They find ways to reframe it. The problem isn’t the policy. It wasn’t funded enough, or wasn’t implemented correctly, or would have worked if not for housing costs, or systemic racism, or anything else that keeps the finger pointed somewhere other than inward.

ADVERTISEMENT

Psychologists apparently call this motivated reasoning. I call it the loudest silence in Seattle.

Agreeing with a conservative is heresy

Then there’s the reflex.

I’ve seen it up close more times than I can count. A Seattle progressive will privately acknowledge the encampments are out of control. They’ll tell you, quietly, that their neighborhood feels unsafe. They’ll admit the billion dollars spent on Housing First produced more tents, not fewer. But the moment you point out that conservatives have been saying exactly that for years, and were called heartless for it, the shutters come down.

Acknowledging that a conservative was right about something feels, in their world, like a criminal betrayal. It isn’t really about the policy anymore. It’s about identity. If I was right, then the Stranger was wrong. If Ann Davison’s approach to prosecuting drug use was the right call, then the people who ran her out of office were wrong. In a city where your entire social and professional circle shares the same politics, being publicly wrong has real costs. So they stay wrong quietly instead.

ADVERTISEMENT

The most efficient echo chamber in America

I’ve written about why Seattle became the most ideologically captured city in the country. The structures matter.

Five decades of one-party rule. A local media that functions as a Democratic Party communications arm. Public schools running activist curricula. A tech industry that imported hundreds of thousands of workers with a very specific political profile and enough insulated income to absorb the costs of bad policy without ever feeling them. The result is a city where most residents have no meaningful exposure to conservative ideas. Not as caricatures. As actual arguments made by actual people.

When you’ve never heard a good-faith conservative critique of Housing First, you have no idea how to evaluate one. When every institution around you, your newspaper, your TV news, your employer’s HR training, your city council, speaks in one ideological voice, that voice starts to sound like objective truth. I cannot count how many times I’ve been told by a left-wing social media user that I’m making up my stories of out-of-control homelessness, even when my stories come with video.

ADVERTISEMENT

Dissent gets pathologized. People who question the prevailing approach get treated as suspect, as heartless, as political. After enough of that, most people stop questioning at all.

Compassion as a status symbol

There’s another piece to this, and it’s subtler.

Seattle’s progressive culture has turned tolerance into social currency. Being okay with the encampment outside your apartment building isn’t just a political position. It’s how you signal to your neighbors that you’re a good person. That you’re not judgmental. That you have the right values.

Demanding enforcement, insisting on accountability, saying out loud that drug addiction needs to be treated as the crisis it is rather than managed and enabled; all of that gets coded as cruelty. It gets you labeled. In a city where being labeled the wrong thing carries real social costs, it’s easier to perform tolerance than to demand results.

ADVERTISEMENT

This is what produces the absurdity we’ve watched play out election after election in Seattle: voters who watch the city deteriorate, congratulate themselves on the “progress” made, and then re-elect the same types of candidates who lit the match.

When it comes to Seattle’s homeless crisis, the moment you question the orthodoxy out loud; what if that person in the tent has a fentanyl addiction that no apartment is going to fix? You become the bad guy. You don’t care. You’re blaming the victim. You’re heartless. So people don’t say it. Even when they’re thinking it. Even when they’ve watched the same person cycle through shelter offers for two years and refuse every one.

What it adds up to

The result is a city where the political incentives run entirely backward.

Honesty gets punished. Enabling gets rewarded. Politicians who demand accountability for the billions spent get attacked; politicians who ask for more billions with no accountability get re-elected. And the people sleeping in the encampments keep dying on our streets.

ADVERTISEMENT

Understanding why Seattle’s progressive voters have convinced themselves this is acceptable doesn’t make it acceptable. Seattle has become a regional magnet for the homeless precisely because its leaders and the voters who put them there refuse to hold anyone accountable. Not the failed programs. Not the politicians who funded them. Certainly not themselves.

At some point, motivated reasoning runs out of road. The fentanyl deaths don’t stop. The encampments don’t shrink. The city doesn’t get cleaner. Eventually, even in Seattle, that becomes harder to rationalize than it is to admit.

We’re not there yet. But we’re closer than Seattle Democrats want you to believe.

Listen to The Jason Rantz Show on weekday afternoons from 3 p.m. – 7 p.m. on Seattle Red on 770 AM (HD Radio 97.3 FM HD-Channel 3). Subscribe to the podcast here. Follow Jason Rantz on X, Instagram, YouTube, and Facebook.

Jason Rantz Talk Show Host and Columnist at Seattle Red

Jason Rantz hosts The Jason Rantz Show on Seattle Red 770 AM weekdays from 3 p.m. to 7 p.m.

Comments

16 Comments

M
Mark Mad 6 months ago

Jason, I think you are leaving out greed. Government is the largest employer in Seattle, King County, and WA (UW Med included). There are countless companies and NGOs financially linked to the government. This state is turning into communist China in slow motion. Drink the Kool-Aid, get paid. Resist, get punished.

S
Shawn m 6 months ago

Nice work, Jason. Elicits the ring of truth in one's gut.

A
Angry Orchard 6 months ago

Gad Saad calls it “Suicidal Empathy”. Feeling so sorry for others that you won’t stand up for yourself.