ADVERTISEMENT

JASON RANTZ

Rantz: Seattle Mayor Katie Wilson quietly pitched firefighters to back fire district levy to cover city’s budget gap, says source

Mayor Katie Wilson's team met with Seattle Fire Local 27 to pitch converting SFD to a fire district. The union didn't buy it, and the mayor's office disputes the account.

Seattle Fire Department engine outside Seattle, Washington...

Seattle Fire Department crews respond to a call in the city. Mayor Katie Wilson's office is pushing to convert SFD into an independent fire district, but the union says the city's plan would leave firefighters with the name of a district and none of the financial independence that comes with one. (Jason Rantz)

(Jason Rantz)

Mayor Katie Wilson’s office made an unusual, largely unannounced move last week, sending a team directly into a meeting with Seattle Fire Department members to pitch converting the department into an independent fire district. Union members walked out unpersuaded, and a source who was in the room says the pitch did not feel like it was really about improving how the city delivers fire service.

The meeting comes as Seattle stares at a structural deficit the mayor’s office pegs at $175 million for the coming year, part of a three-year budget hole approaching half a billion dollars, as MyNorthwest reported Tuesday. The administration has already ordered departments to draft 5% and 10% spending reductions, and city officials have been hunting for new revenue options that avoid cutting politically favored programs. Firefighters who attended the session say they recognized the pitch for what it was.

A source who was present at the meeting shared detailed notes with The Jason Rantz Show on Seattle Red 770 AM.

Two very different visions for a fire district

Local 27 is not opposed to the idea of a fire district. The source said the union went into the meeting acknowledging the concept had real potential.

“Local 27 is open to the idea of a fire district. It could potentially help us serve the citizens better give us more autonomy guaranteed funding,” the source acknowledged, seeking anonymity since he was not authorized to share details of the meeting.

The problem is that what some union members have in mind and what the city proposed are structurally different things. The position reportedly relayed to Wilson is that any conversion must come with levy funding flowing directly to SFD and genuine governance independence, including elected commissioners.

“The main hang up is that we want guaranteed funding from Direct levies that would come to the fire district. And also, we want to have five Fire commissioners better elected throughout the city to oversee the fire department,” the source said.

ADVERTISEMENT

What the city put on the table was something else. “The city wants us to turn into a district, but they want us to support a fire district levy, where the money goes to the city and the city Council continues to manage the fire department and over see us.”

In other words: the union would lend its credibility to a levy campaign, the money would flow into the city’s general fund, and the City Council would retain oversight. Firefighters would get the name of a fire district without the autonomy that defines one.

The meeting that went nowhere

The source characterized Wilson has having “begged to come meet with our union membership in Seattle fire today. Kind of unprecedented. They are desperate to find more revenue.” Both the Mayor’s Office and the Seattle Fire Fighters Union, IAFF Local 27, via separate statements, said she was invited.

The source described what the mayor’s team was selling.

ADVERTISEMENT

“She came with her team and wants to sell us on promoting a new levy to change the Seattle fire department from a city fire department to a Seattle fire district, which would necessitate a levy that would support Seattle firefighters in our new district. And then the city would use the extra savings to support their broader city budget shortfall,” according to the source.

What drove the meeting?

The source was explicit about what the source believed drove the meeting. “Their angle is to close a big financial gap in the city budget. The city is gonna be down about $200 to $300,000,000 and they’re gonna be no longer able to kick the can down the road. The Mayors Office does not want to cut any of their favorite pet projects that continue to enable fentanyl and crime and drugs, etc.”

The source also said the administration had hit a wall with union president Kenny Stuart before resorting to the station-level outreach. “So because they were at an impasse with Kenny Stuart, they rushed a meeting with our Station representatives to try to bypass him and convince us directly.”

ADVERTISEMENT

It did not work, according to the source. “The union is completely behind Kenny and does not trust the Mayor’s Office. We want it in writing that we will have independent funding, and within two years, we will have Fire commissioners that we answer to and no longer the city Council. They are unwilling as the city to provide that in writing, however, they wanted to verbally express to us that we should trust them, and that they would do that for us.”

Did the mayor make progress pitching the idea?

The meeting lasted about an hour. “They did not make any headway with the Local,” the source said. “The general sentiment was that everybody is very skeptical and not behind supporting the Mayors Office plan to turn the city of Seattle fire department into a district fire department.”

The source said the mayor’s team also delivered a warning about what refusal would cost. “She said if we don’t agree, there will be cuts and layoffs to the Seattle fire department.”

ADVERTISEMENT

Union members pushed back on the premise of the whole thing. “Basically, it’s not our job to solve their financial woes and mismanaged spending. We solve all of the major problems on the street as it is along with the police.”

Kenny Stuart did not respond to a series of questions about the meeting or their position. Instead, he responded with a press release confirming some information conveyed by the source.

“Mayor Wilson asked Local 27 leadership if she could meet with Seattle Fire Fighters to discuss this plan and she was invited to a meeting with Local 27 Station Representatives. Local 27 is currently evaluating the mayor’s plan,” the press release read in part.

This is not the first time Wilson’s administration has clashed with organized labor over a major institutional decision. Earlier this year, the mayor reversed course on her City Light CEO pick following a union backlash.

ADVERTISEMENT

Mayor’s office responds

Deputy Communications Director Sage Wilson offered some details in a written response to The Jason Rantz Show on Seattle Red 770 AM.

On the budget pressure behind the proposal, the deputy communications director wrote: “The mayor came into office having inherited a massive $175 million structural budget deficit, which is about 10% of the general fund. The gap is far too large to address with the kinds of temporary fixes that have been used in the past, and closing this deficit with cuts alone would require reductions in critical services and substantial layoffs across departments. Half of the general fund goes to public safety and human services, so there are no easy solutions here.”

On the fire district concept specifically, Sage Wilson wrote: “New state legislation that passed this year opened up the possibility of establishing a fire district as another potential path forward to stabilize SFD resources while also protecting other public services, and that has been under consideration by the mayor’s team. We have been working closely with SFD Chief Scoggins as well as the leadership of Local 27 to see if we can find a path forward that balances varying needs around revenue, public safety, and good governance.”

ADVERTISEMENT

The office also directly disputed the account that city staff attempted to go around union leadership. “The mayor did request a meeting with Local 27 membership, which was coordinated through the leadership of the union, and any legislative proposal would of course be in writing. I’m not sure the source of your information, but we did not, would not, and could not bypass elected leadership, and we did share proposals in writing with union leadership.”

Sage Wilson added that any final legislation would need to pass through City Council, which would have final say on the details.

What a fire district conversion would actually mean

A fire district is a separate governmental entity from a city department. It would draw revenue from dedicated property tax levies approved by voters, giving SFD a guaranteed funding stream not subject to general fund budget battles or competing city priorities. That is precisely why the union sees potential in the idea.

ADVERTISEMENT

The problem, from some with Local 27, is that the city’s version does not actually deliver that. If levy revenue flows to the city rather than directly to an independent SFD, and if City Council retains management authority, the conversion amounts to a new revenue tool for a budget-strapped administration that has already struggled to make hard spending choices. Firefighters would be asked to help pass a levy that, under the city’s framework, leaves them no better off governmentally than they are today.

Listen to The Jason Rantz Show on weekday afternoons from 3 p.m. – 7 p.m. on Seattle Red on 770 AM (HD Radio 97.3 FM HD-Channel 3). Subscribe to the podcast here. Follow Jason Rantz on X, Instagram, YouTube, and Facebook.

Jason Rantz Talk Show Host and Columnist at Seattle Red

Jason Rantz hosts The Jason Rantz Show on Seattle Red 770 AM weekdays from 3 p.m. to 7 p.m.

Comments

11 Comments

V
Vegaman Dan 6 months ago

The moment any fire dedicated levy revenue goes into the general fund, it will be immediately repurposed to other projects.

At no time has Wilson said she would be reducing funds to her social projects.

M
Mark Mad 6 months ago

Like bye bye mayor

J
John Stouffer 6 months ago

I am a fire service consultant and have worked on many projects throughout the U.S. Becoming an independent fire district would be a positive thing so long as the city no longer controls the fire department. I totally agree with Local 27's position. Also, this must be carefully considered as taxes would increase.