ADVERTISEMENT

JASON RANTZ OPINION

Rantz: Clueless Bob Ferguson’s Small Business Week tweet gets torn apart by actual small business owners

Gov. Bob Ferguson claimed the Millionaires' Tax delivers "the largest small business tax cut in state history." Small business owners pushed back hard.

Gov. Bob Ferguson gestures to a crowd of supporters holding "Millionaires Tax is a Win for Tax Fair...

Bob Ferguson surrounded by supporters of Washington's income tax. (Photo: Gov Bob Ferguson/X)

(Photo: Gov Bob Ferguson/X)

Gov. Bob Ferguson used Small Business Week to post what may be his most clueless message yet, claiming credit for “the largest small business tax cut in state history” by way of a 9.9% income tax that targets the very businesses he’s pretending to celebrate.

Ferguson posted Wednesday to his official @GovBobFerguson account on X. “Celebrating the largest small business tax cut in state history thanks to the Millionaires’ Tax. Happy Small Business Week!” The small business community had other thoughts.

Senate Bill 6346, which Ferguson signed in March, imposes a 9.9% levy on household income above $1 million annually. The law does not take effect until 2029 and faces multiple lawsuits arguing it violates 90 years of state Supreme Court precedent. The small business tax relief attached to it is contingent on the income tax surviving a court challenge, which is far from guaranteed. Washington voters have rejected income tax proposals eleven consecutive times since 1932.

The responses to his post made clear that the state’s actual small business owners are not in a celebratory mood.

ADVERTISEMENT

Ferguson’s claim gets shredded by small business owners

Jim Tinsley, who identified himself as a small business owner, responded to the governor directly. “I’m a small business owner and my taxes did not go down at all.” Callie, who also owns a small business, replied on the same thread. “Liar. I own a small business. NO tax cuts. Just the opposite.”

Kalkin Trivedi connected the staged photo in Ferguson’s post to the message behind it: “Complete with ready-made Amen corner holding professionally printed signs with a slogan associated with your side, not ours. I own a small business. And you’re driving me out of business.”

The timing of the promised relief drew consistent fire.

Bob Stevens wrote to the governor. “Giving us imaginary money from an unconstitutional tax that doesn’t even start for years?” Daniel Carlson, another small business owner, said the post had cost Ferguson his credibility. “This is really misleading. I’m a small business owner and I won’t see relief until at least 2029. Why do politicians do this stuff. This is how we lose faith in them. I now don’t trust this guy.”

ADVERTISEMENT

Elan, on the same thread, offered a direct counter to the governor’s framing. “You passed the largest tax hike on small businesses in Washington State’s history.”

‘You were suing small businesses for being open’

Others pulled Ferguson’s own record into the argument.

Jason Vander Kooy wrote: “Remember a couple years ago, you were suing small businesses for being open. We’re trying to survive.” Ferguson, as state attorney general, pursued businesses that remained open during the COVID-19 lockdowns.

As MyNorthwest reported at the time of the signing, the CADF lawsuit challenging the income tax includes plaintiffs who argue the law is already pushing businesses and investment out of the state.

The frustration running through the thread went well beyond the tweet itself. User beatnikdr ran through the governor’s fiscal record. “You passed the LARGEST TAX INCREASE in the history of the state, but that wasn’t enough. You decided to plunder the pensions of firefighters and police to fund your reckless spending. But even that wasn’t enough, so you colluded and passed an illegal INCOME TAX. WORST.”

ADVERTISEMENT

Chuck Heinlen added a warning. “1 in 4 business owners have admitted to making plans to leave Washington state. Look at what we’ve already lost then start counting U-Hauls. Property values are on the cusp of decline in this state and that will drag down ensuing property tax revenues and levies.”

The utter absurdity

Part of what makes Ferguson’s celebration so absurd is who the law actually impacts the most.

Most small businesses in Washington are organized as pass-through entities, meaning S-corporations, LLCs, and partnerships where profits flow directly to the owner’s personal income rather than being taxed at the corporate level. That means a small business owner whose gross receipts push their household income past $1 million faces the full 9.9% rate on that income. The Wall Street Journal editorial board noted the problem directly, writing that Ferguson’s millionaire tax “would slam small businesses organized as pass-throughs.” Senate Minority Leader John Braun had warned as much during the debate, arguing the law would hit “nearly every LLC or S corporation” in the state. Ferguson’s photo op showed him surrounded by supporters holding printed signs. The businesses most likely to get hit by his tax were not in the frame.

ADVERTISEMENT

A new survey from the Association of Washington Business puts a number on the impending exodus: 24% of Washington employers are now considering leaving the state, nearly triple the rate from just 16 months ago. AWB President Kris Johnson called the findings a “911 emergency” for Washington’s economy.

Listen to The Jason Rantz Show on weekday afternoons from 3 p.m. – 7 p.m. on Seattle Red on 770 AM (HD Radio 97.3 FM HD-Channel 3). Subscribe to the podcast here. Follow Jason Rantz on X, Instagram, YouTube, and Facebook.

Jason Rantz Talk Show Host and Columnist at Seattle Red

Jason Rantz hosts The Jason Rantz Show on Seattle Red 770 AM weekdays from 3 p.m. to 7 p.m.

Comments

2 Comments

J
Johnny Ruger 7 months ago

Bob Steven's just now doesn't trust this guy? Anyone with half a brain cell could see Bob was crooked BEFORE the election. You get what you vote for

D
Doug Spittler 7 months ago

A perfect example of why it's bad judgement to vote for politicians whose sole claim to fame is being a politician. Yes, they know how to garner votes and win elections, but...that's all.

BTW, is "Seattle Red™" ever going to name those Supremes who allowed the "millionaire's tax" to be claimed as a "necessity," even though it doesn't even come into play for another year? It would be useful to know just who gets the "credit" for this travesty...