Talmadge, McKenna lead bipartisan fight against Washington’s 9.9% income tax
Former Justice Phil Talmadge and ex-AG Rob McKenna are suing to block Washington's new 9.9% income tax, citing nearly 100 years of legal precedent.
Emails show AG helped Democrats bypass income tax voters. (Photo courtesy of Washington Courts)
(Photo courtesy of Washington Courts)
Former State Supreme Court Justice Phil Talmadge, a Democrat, has joined a high-profile legal challenge against Washington’s new 9.9% income tax, arguing that the law is a clear violation of a century of legal precedent.
“Historically, efforts to provide for tax reform have required a constitutional amendment,” Talmadge told The Jason Rantz Show on Seattle Red 770 AM, noting that the state’s founding documents require all property—including income—to be taxed uniformly.
The lawsuit, filed in Klickitat County Superior Court, sees Talmadge teaming up with former Republican Attorney General Rob McKenna. The bipartisan duo argues that the state legislature ignored nearly 100 years of court rulings when they passed the tax on households earning over a million dollars without asking voters to change the constitution first.
A battle over the definition of property
The core of the legal argument rests on a 1930s decision where the Washington Supreme Court ruled that income is property. Under the state constitution, property taxes must be “uniform,” meaning everyone is taxed at the same rate. Because this new tax is “graduated”—meaning it only hits those earning over a certain amount—Talmadge says it cannot stand under current law.
While some worry the court might redefine the tax to save it, Talmadge pointed out a key difference between this and the recent capital gains tax. “The difference here is this particular bill… nowhere mentions the term excise tax,” Talmadge explained.
He noted that the legislature isn’t trying to hide what this is, straightforwardly calling it an income tax, which makes it harder for the court to ignore past rulings.
Why the bill’s plain language locks in the court
Despite the political pressure surrounding the case, Talmadge expressed confidence that the justices will follow the principle of “stare decisis,” a legal term for following prior precedents. He suggested the legislature made a risky bet by hoping the court would suddenly overturn nearly a century of law.
“I trust the court to consider these issues very, very seriously, very, very carefully,” Talmadge said.
He explained that for the court to change its mind now, it would have to prove that the long-standing rule—that income is property—is somehow “destructive” or “affirmatively harmful” to the people of Washington.
What happens next for Washington taxpayers
While the state has tried to block voters from challenging the tax through a referendum by using an “emergency clause,” Talmadge believes the public will eventually have a say. He expects an initiative to roll back the tax will likely end up on the ballot, even if the signature requirements are higher than a standard referendum.
As for the legal timeline, Talmadge doesn’t expect a final answer from the State Supreme Court until well into 2027. The case will move through a trial judge this summer before likely headed for a direct appeal to the state’s highest court.
Until then, the bipartisan legal team is focused on ensuring the court upholds the protections they say have been settled for generations.
Listen to The Jason Rantz Show on weekday afternoons from 3 p.m. – 7 p.m. on Seattle Red on 770 AM (HD Radio 97.3 FM HD-Channel 3). Subscribe to the podcast here. Follow Jason Rantz on X, Instagram, YouTube, and Facebook.






Comments
0 Comments