Lawsuit challenges Washington Gov. Bob Ferguson’s new income tax as unconstitutional
Former AG Rob McKenna and ex-Justice Phil Talmadge are suing to strike down Washington's new 9.9% income tax as unconstitutional.
Gov. Bob Ferguson's office delayed a state correction to inflated Climate Commitment Act emissions data for weeks, records show.(Screengrab: TVW)
(Screengrab: TVW)
A coalition of farmers, small business owners, and two of the state’s most credentialed attorneys filed suit Wednesday challenging Washington’s newly enacted income tax, recently signed into law by Governor Bob Ferguson, arguing the law violates the state constitution and roughly a century of settled court precedent.
The Citizen Action Defense Fund (CADF) filed the complaint in Klickitat County Superior Court on behalf of individual taxpayers and business organizations representing thousands of small businesses statewide. The suit seeks to invalidate the tax entirely. The law imposes a 9.9% tax on income above $1 million while taxing everything below that at zero.
Rob McKenna and Phil Talmadge lead the constitutional challenge
CADF retained former Washington Attorney General Rob McKenna of Orrick, Herrington & Sutcliffe to lead the legal challenge, with former Washington Supreme Court Justice and Senate Judiciary Chair Phil Talmadge of Talmadge/Fitzpatrick joining as co-counsel.
The lawsuit argues the tax violates Article VII of the Washington Constitution on two fronts. It imposes a non-uniform tax on property by taxing similar income at different rates, and it blows past the constitutional 1% cap on property taxes with a top rate nearly ten times that limit.
Former AG and former justice: their legal argument
Washington courts have held for close to a century that income is property, and that property taxes must be uniform and capped. Democrats in Olympia ignored both requirements.
“For nearly a century, Washington courts have been clear: income is property, and property taxes must be uniform and limited,” McKenna said in a statement. “This law disregards both the plain language of the constitution and decades of consistent Supreme Court precedent. We are confident the courts will strike it down.”
Talmadge, who served on the Supreme Court before chairing the Senate Judiciary Committee, shared the assessment.
“This legislation is not a close call — it is a direct conflict with settled constitutional law,” he said. “The Washington Supreme Court has repeatedly reaffirmed that graduated income taxes are unconstitutional. This lawsuit ensures those protections are upheld.”
What the lawsuit actually says
The complaint wastes no time framing what Democrats did as a straight-up power grab. The opening paragraph invokes George Washington’s Farewell Address, warning that a government branch seizing power the constitution never granted it — even when dressed up as good intentions — is “the customary weapon by which free governments are destroyed.”
The lawsuit lays out that Washington courts have held this ground for close to a century, citing a 2019 Court of Appeals ruling that put the constitutional prohibition clearly. The complaint quotes that ruling, noting the court found that “the Washington Supreme Court has unequivocally held income is property, a tax on income is a tax on property, taxes on property must be uniformly levied, and a graduated income tax is not uniform. Therefore, the Washington Constitution bars any graduated income tax.”
The complaint describes the new law as “blatantly unconstitutional under longstanding Washington precedent” on both counts: the non-uniform rate structure and the 9.9% figure that blows past the 1% constitutional ceiling by nearly ten times.
The necessity clause that blocked a voter referendum
Perhaps the most damning section covers how the legislature deliberately blocked voters from having a say. The complaint argues lawmakers added a “necessity clause” to the bill knowing full well it would short-circuit any referendum drive. The legislature declared the tax “necessary for the support of state government and its existing public institutions,” even though it doesn’t take effect until January 1, 2028 and won’t generate a dollar until April 2029. The complaint says the legislature “acted deliberately to frustrate any such voter rejection.”
The economic stakes are spelled out, too. The complaint cites a recent Association of Washington Business survey finding that 44% of business leaders are now considering moving their personal residence out of state, a figure that doubled after the income tax was first proposed. Washington’s new top rate would rank as the fifth-highest in the nation.
Let’s Go Washington files a parallel challenge at the Supreme Court
The CADF suit isn’t the only legal challenge Democrats are facing. Let’s Go Washington (LGW) has taken a parallel fight to the State Supreme Court, arguing that Secretary of State Steve Hobbs used a doctored version of the Constitution to block voters from having any say on the tax at all.
LGW founder Brian Heywood says Hobbs’ rejection letter actually misquotes the Constitution, adding words that created a loophole allowing lawmakers to shield any bill from a public vote simply by stamping it “necessary.”
The Supreme Court has already granted an emergency hearing on the challenge.
Farmers, small businesses, and ethnic chambers join as plaintiffs
The named plaintiffs run wide. Alongside individual taxpayers from Chelan, Benton, Klickitat, and King counties are the Ethnic Chamber of Commerce Coalition, the Yakima and Klickitat Farm Association, the National Federation of Independent Business, and the Building Industry Association of Washington.
“The minority-owned small businesses we represent are already navigating rising costs and economic uncertainty,” said Mike Sotelo, Co-Chair of the Ethnic Chamber of Commerce Coalition. “This tax adds another layer of instability that makes it harder for entrepreneurs to grow, hire, and stay in Washington. We’re proud to stand with our members in challenging a law that threatens their future.”
Elizabeth Milito, Vice President and Executive Director for the Small Business Legal Center of the National Federation of Independent Business, put it plainly.
“This law puts small business owners in our state directly in the crosshairs,” Milito said. “Washington has long been a place where entrepreneurs can thrive — this tax changes that overnight. NFIB is committed to fighting for our members against policies like this new income tax that are both economically harmful and constitutionally unlawful.”
Voters have rejected an income tax 10 times in 92 years
The lawsuit also flags Washington’s track record at the ballot box. Voters have rejected income tax proposals ten separate times over the past 92 years. Democrats in Olympia pushed the tax through anyway.
The suit warns the law directly threatens Washington’s long-standing advantage as a no-income-tax state and is already driving businesses and investment out.
Listen to The Jason Rantz Show on weekday afternoons from 3 p.m. – 7 p.m. on Seattle Red on 770 AM (HD Radio 97.3 FM HD-Channel 3). Subscribe to the podcast here. Follow Jason Rantz on X, Instagram, YouTube, and Facebook.






Comments
3 Comments
Comes from all the Bobbing and weaving he's been doing.
Bob’s combover looks like he’s flustered.
No kings! Seems President Trump isn't the only threat to democracy.