Seattle tried to run out the clock on Brandi Kruse’s public records request. A court just ruled it illegal.
A Washington appeals court ruled Seattle violated the Public Records Act in its handling of Brandi Kruse's request — overturning a lower court win for the city.
Brandi Kruse discusses her public records victory against the City of Seattle on her unDivided podcast. (unDivided Media)
(unDivided Media)
After three years, two courts, and a legal team working on donated funds, Brandi Kruse finally won. The Washington State Court of Appeals issued a unanimous ruling finding Seattle violated the spirit of the Public Records Act when it stalled a narrow, straightforward document request filed in 2023.
Kruse, host of the unDivided podcast, said the story started with then-Seattle City Councilmember Andrew Lewis, who delivered a shocking no vote in June 2023 on an ordinance that would have given police tools to crack down on open drug use downtown. The day before the vote, nobody saw it coming.
“A day before the vote happened, everyone thought he was going to be a yes vote,” Kruse noted. “And then all of a sudden, 24 hours later, he voted no, and it just took everyone by surprise. So I thought, well, did somebody get in his ear and tell him to vote no? What would have led to this?”
She filed a public records request for Lewis’s emails, texts, and voicemails to find out. Given how narrow the request was, she expected a quick turnaround.
“I’ve probably done hundreds, if not more than 1,000 public records requests in my career, and some are more complicated than others,” Kruse explained. “But this was a really simple request. It was for a 10-hour period of time, a very narrow window. The request was very specific. It was only for one council member. So based on experience, I thought they’d probably get these to me in a month.”
The city’s response to Brandi Kruse’s public records request
The first batch of records landed after the August primary. The estimated date for the second installment was November 11 — days after the general election in which Lewis was on the ballot.
“I thought, ‘Okay, this is just getting laughable,'” Kruse warned. “That cannot be a coincidence, and there is no way that it should take them six months to fulfill such a narrow request.”
Without the budget to fund a lawsuit herself, Kruse connected with the Citizen Action Defense Fund.
“They reached out to me and said, ‘Hey, we want to take this case,'” she added. “So we ended up filing suit.”
What the lawsuit’s discovery uncovered about Seattle’s records division
The discovery process turned up a public records division that had effectively gone dark, Kruse said. The records officer had gone on leave, the city never posted the job opening, and under its own rules it was required to bring in outside help. It didn’t.
“There was an opening in the public records division that the city never even tried to fill,” Kruse stressed. “Didn’t even post the job. And under the city’s own rules, they have to have someone, even if it’s a public records officer from a different agency, step in to fill for someone when they’re on an extended vacation. They didn’t do that, and they weren’t even trying to get someone to do it. So these requests were just sort of languishing.”
She stopped short of calling it deliberate: “I think something more nefarious happened, but there really was no smoking gun to prove that the city intentionally delayed the release of these records until after the election.”
A King County judge sided with the city in spring 2025. Kruse appealed. The State Court of Appeals heard the case in November 2025 and this week ruled unanimously in her favor.
Taxpayers pay either way
The case is not technically over. The city could still appeal to the state Supreme Court, which would only deepen the tab for Seattle residents.
“Unfortunately, when someone like me or the Times is forced to sue to get the city to change its behavior, ultimately that costs the taxpayers money,” Kruse pointed out. “Because if we win, they have to pay our attorneys’ fees. There are penalties associated with it.”
Seattle’s record on this front is ugly. The city faced a similar lawsuit from The Seattle Times. And the vanished text messages from the CHOP occupation remain one of the more notorious transparency failures in the city’s recent history.
An opening for the current administration
Kruse argued that current Mayor Katie Wilsons and City Attorney Erika Evans, neither of whom were in office when the violations happened, have a clear shot at changing course.
“Seattle’s leadership has changed and had more turnover than a normal city of its size,” she said. “We’ve had three or four mayors in a row where they’ve only had one term, and so then you lose that element of responsibility.”
She laid out exactly what a course correction would look like.
“I think they have an opportunity to say, ‘We see this pattern that happened before we came into office, we believe in transparency, so we’re going to make the changes that previous administrations did not,'” Kruse told Rantz. “And it could be a good thing for them.”
As for what was actually in the documents the city eventually turned over, the answer is almost nothing useful. By the time they arrived, Lewis had left office. And the records suggested he had been routing communications through a personal cell phone.
“What the request told me is that he was actually probably using his personal cell phone to do a lot of communication on this issue,” Kruse said. “And we would have immediately turned around and requested that. But once he left office, it wasn’t ours to request.”
Listen to The Jason Rantz Show on weekday afternoons from 3 p.m. – 7 p.m. on Seattle Red on 770 AM (HD Radio 97.3 FM HD-Channel 3). Subscribe to the podcast here. Follow Jason Rantz on X, Instagram, YouTube, and Facebook.






Comments
1 Comments
The mismanagement, loss, or failure to create records seems to be a mighty effective defense against audits and public records requests. I wonder if there's any law or policy that doesn't contain some form of a Democrats-Only backdoor for occasions where circumvention is valued.