ADVERTISEMENT

JASON RANTZ OPINION

Rantz: IOC limits women’s events to biological females — AP called it a trans athlete ‘ban.’ The science says otherwise.

The IOC limited women's Olympic events to biological females for LA28. AP called it a 'ban' on trans athletes. Here's what the science and the policy actually say.

Officials at the Paris 2024 event where the LA28 2028 Olympics logo was displayed, as the committee...

The IOC ruled only biological females can compete in women's Olympic events. AP called it a 'ban' on trans athletes. The science and the facts say otherwise. (Photo by Luke Hales/Getty Images)

(Photo by Luke Hales/Getty Images)

International Olympic Committee (IOC) President Kirsty Coventry announced Thursday that only biological females will be eligible to compete in women’s events at the Olympic Games. The policy is guided by science, and is set to take effect at the 2028 Los Angeles Games. But rather than report the news straight, outlets including the Associated Press immediately declared that transgender women had been “banned” from the Olympics.

That framing is false, and it is not accidental.

What the IOC’s biological female eligibility rule actually says

The new policy limits eligibility for the female category to biological females, determined through a one-time SRY gene screening. Athletes who test SRY-positive, meaning they carry the male Y chromosome marker, are ineligible for women’s events. The IOC was explicit about what that does not mean. Athletes with an SRY-positive screen (biological males) continue to be included in all other classifications for which they qualify, including any male category, a designated male slot within any mixed category, and any open category, or in sports and events that do not classify athletes by sex.

Nobody is banned from the Olympics. Biological males who identify as women are free to compete. They simply have to do it in the category that matches their biology. This is about basic fairness.

ADVERTISEMENT

The policy applies beginning with the LA28 Games and is not retroactive.

How the SRY gene screening works

The IOC will require all female category athletes to undergo a one-time SRY gene screening before competing at any IOC event.

The test is administered through a saliva sample, cheek swab, or blood draw. Athletes who test SRY-negative — meaning no Y chromosome marker is detected — are cleared to compete in the women’s category for the remainder of their career.

The IOC describes it as a “once-in-a-lifetime test,” with a repeat screen required only if there is specific reason to question an initial negative result. Athletes who test SRY-positive remain eligible for the men’s category, a designated male slot in mixed events, or any open category that does not classify by sex.

How AP, ESPN, and CBS turned a science-based policy into a ‘ban’

Calling the IOC’s decision a “ban” requires first accepting the premise that transgender women are women. The Associated Press, ESPN, CBS News, and NBC News, among others, all accepted that premise and embedded it inside their news coverage. That is advocacy journalism.

ADVERTISEMENT

The word “ban” implies total exclusion. A biological male who identifies as a woman is not excluded from the LA28 Games. That athlete is excluded from competing against women, which has been the entire point of having a women’s category in the first place.

Some outlets framed Thursday’s announcement as the IOC bending to political pressure from Washington. That framing is as sloppy as calling the policy a “ban.” IOC President Kirsty Coventry was very direct: “This was a priority for me way before President Trump came into his second term. There’s not been any pressure on us to deliver anything from anybody outside of the Olympic Movement.” The timing is coincidental in the narrow sense that Trump’s “Keeping Men Out of Women’s Sports” executive order was signed and the IOC’s own internal review ran parallel tracks toward the same conclusion. The science, not the White House, is what’s in the IOC’s published document.

ADVERTISEMENT

The data behind the IOC’s female category decision

The policy did not emerge from political pressure. The IOC commissioned a working group spanning all five continents that included sports scientists, endocrinologists, transgender medicine specialists, ethics experts, and input from more than 1,100 athletes surveyed. The IOC document published Thursday said the male performance advantage over biological women was “10-12%” in most running and swimming events, at least 20% in most throwing and jumping events, and can be greater than 100% for explosive power events including punching sports.

While the Radical Left, upon redefining gender, pretend males don’t have a clear and obvious advantage, the science and results tell the truth. You can treat transgender people will respect while also acknowledging that they have an advantage in competitions against women.

Why protecting the female category isn’t discrimination

The IOC did not ban transgender athletes. It defined who qualifies as female for purposes of Olympic competition, a definition that shouldn’t require any political courage to accept because it is basic biology. The outlets screaming “ban” are the same ones who spent years insisting there was no meaningful physical difference between male and female athletes. The IOC’s own working group demolished that argument with data.

ADVERTISEMENT

The policy was developed on the basis that it is universally accepted that providing for a female category is necessary to allow both males and females equal access to elite sport. That sentence is in the IOC’s published document. AP chose a different sentence for its headline.

Listen to The Jason Rantz Show on weekday afternoons from 3 p.m. – 7 p.m. on Seattle Red on 770 AM (HD Radio 97.3 FM HD-Channel 3). Subscribe to the podcast here. Follow Jason Rantz on X, Instagram, YouTube, and Facebook.

Comments

2 Comments

E
Evan Lattimore 8 months ago
The IOC commissioned a working group spanning all five continents that included sports scientists, endocrinologists, transgender medicine specialists, ethics experts, and input from more than 1,100 athletes surveyed. The IOC document published Thursday said the male performance advantage over biological women was “10-12%” in most running and swimming events, at least 20% in most throwing and jumping events, and can be greater than 100% for explosive power events including punching sports.

So they worked hard to figure out what's been known for centuries now to anyone who doesn't have their head up their caboose. Wow. Great job.

A
Angry Orchard 8 months ago

Better late than never. And yet, some crazies will complain about this.