UW professor called Holocaust scholar Deborah Lipstadt ‘troubling.’ His colleagues strongly disagreed.
A UW professor condemned the school for hosting Holocaust scholar Deborah Lipstadt. His colleagues pushed back and called out the misrepresentation.
The University of Washington campus in Seattle, where a faculty listserv debate broke out after a professor called a Holocaust scholar's lecture "troubling." (Photo by Karen Ducey/Getty Images)
(Photo by Karen Ducey/Getty Images)
A University of Washington professor triggered a faculty-wide debate this month after publicly condemning the school for hosting a lecture by renowned Holocaust scholar Deborah Lipstadt, calling the event “troubling” and suggesting the university never should have opened its doors to her.
Sasha Senderovich, an associate professor of international, Slavic, and Jewish studies, published a letter in the UW Daily on March 10 criticizing the university for hosting Lipstadt’s lecture, “Fighting Antisemitism Around the Globe,” at the HUB. It earned a rebuke from Lipstadt herself. The event was organized by the Jewish Federation of Greater Seattle in partnership with UW’s Undergraduate Academic Affairs and Alumni Association.
Senderovich’s complaint was based around remarks Lipstadt made in spring 2025, during which she expressed qualified support for enforcement of visa rules against some student protesters. He argued the university had no business lending its facilities to her.
“A university — an institution dedicated to educating students in an environment appropriate to learning — should not have lent its name and facilities to a figure who has endorsed removing students from the U.S. for political protest,” Senderovich wrote.
After posting the letter to the AAUP-UW faculty listserv, some of his colleagues pushed back hard.
UW faculty calls out Senderovich’s misrepresentation of Lipstadt
Victor Menaldo, a professor of political science, posted a lengthy rebuttal arguing Senderovich had badly mischaracterized Lipstadt’s actual record. Menaldo noted that Lipstadt had explicitly distinguished between protected speech and conduct, warned against due-process violations, and later told the Jewish Telegraphic Agency that parts of the Trump administration’s campus crackdown had “gone way too far.”
“To describe her simply as a ‘supporter of student deportations’ erases the distinctions she explicitly drew between speech and conduct, legal process and arbitrary detention, and seriously misstates her position,” Menaldo wrote on the listserv.
Menaldo also raised the broader concern about what happens when faculty publicly pressure university units over speaker choices.
“No one bans anything,” he wrote. “The costs of certain kinds of speech simply rise until people stop engaging in them.”
Gwyneth Parmar, Director for Projects & Strategic Initiatives, was more direct on the listserv: “I find it very dangerous that you would attempt to ban someone for having views that oppose your own.”
Armed security and vandalized posters: the reality of Jewish events at UW
Dan Eisenberg, a professor of anthropology who attended the lecture, noted that the event required a level of security he had never seen in nearly 14 years at UW.
“It was the only university event I’ve ever been to in my almost fourteen years at the UW where there was ample security and every person was security wanded at entry,” Eisenberg wrote.
That context — Jewish events on campus routinely requiring paid security and facing active disruption — helps explain why organizers chose to limit public advertising, according to multiple attendees. A separate but related disclosure in the thread revealed that posters for a February webinar on antisemitism and free speech had been repeatedly torn down in UW’s Denny Hall.
Naomi Sokoloff, a professor and chair in Jewish studies, confirmed the vandalism.
“The posters were repeatedly taken down in Savery Hall and in Denny Hall,” Sokoloff wrote. “I hope we all agree that deliberate, persistent removal of posters advertising an academic event is not good for freedom of speech at UW.”
Who is Deborah Lipstadt?
Lipstadt, it should be noted, is one of the world’s foremost Holocaust scholars, a three-time National Jewish Book Award winner, a former Biden administration special envoy on antisemitism, and a former UW faculty member who taught at the university from 1974 to 1979.
According to JNS, Lipstadt criticized Senderovich’s misrepresentation of her positions.
“It’s not true,” Lipstadt said. “To call me a Trumpist is to completely distort who I am, what I stand for and what I’ve said.”
Listen to The Jason Rantz Show on weekday afternoons from 3 p.m. – 7 p.m. on Seattle Red on 770 AM (HD Radio 97.3 FM HD-Channel 3). Subscribe to the podcast here. Follow Jason Rantz on X, Instagram, YouTube, and Facebook.






Comments
1 Comments
[Enforced] freedom of speech making a comeback at UW. Who'd a thunk it?
Several months ago, my wife and I were lunching at a favorite diner, and seated behind us was a mother and daughter. It was time for collage and the two were having a back-and-forth over the choices. The mother repeatedly offered to help subsidize the daughter's higher education, but the daughter (solid family values on display) didn't want the mother to go into debt on her behalf. Instead, she wanted to find her own way to placement in either the Portland or Seattle area. The conversation began to heat up and I, against my general nature, turned around in my seat and got the daughter's attention. I apologized for butting in, and proceeded to explain precisely why she really didn't want to follow her heart this time. The daughter sat quietly with her head bowed while I spoke, tears on her face, and the mother --who remained silent until I'd finished a good five minutes of barging in where I feared I would be unwelcome-- said a quiet "thank you" and returned to comfort her baby.
I'm a hopless romantic. I pray this return to sanity heralds a UW renaissance and goes viral.