Rantz: Rare UW backlash as professors condemn extremist campus activists and colleague
UW faculty split over SUPER UW activists after one professor defended those charged and two others condemned the building takeover, vandalism, and violence.
The University of Washington placed 260th out of 261 schools in FIRE's 2027 College Free Speech Rankings. (Photo courtesy of KIRO 7)
(Photo courtesy of KIRO 7)
A rare split among University of Washington (UW) faculty is out in the open after one faculty member used the American Association of University Professors (AAUP) UW listserv to defend activists charged in the May 2025 takeover of the Interdisciplinary Engineering Building. Two other professors pushed back and explicitly noted the vandalism and destruction tied to the occupation.
That is notable because faculty responses to the far-left SUPER UW activists (and those aligned with the cause) have too often leaned toward excuse-making, even after the illegal occupation ended with arrests and roughly $1 million in damage. King County prosecutors this week charged 33 people with criminal trespass, but said they lacked the evidence needed to bring vandalism-related felony charges against specific defendants.
The fight on the faculty listserv started after UW issued a March 3 statement saying it was “pleased to see criminal charges filed with the court related to the occupation of the Interdisciplinary Engineering Building.” The statement added, “This is an important step in ensuring accountability for those who perpetrated this occupation.”
UW faculty finally break with activist orthodoxy
Assistant Professor Tomas Rocha objected to the UW language, pretending the suspects are the real victims.
“As I documented on this list last spring, many student protestors lost scholarships, employment, housing, health insurance, and in some cases program admissions as a result of lengthy (and legally questionable) emergency suspensions placed on them days after the protest and prior to a disciplinary hearing,” he wrote. “Several required medical care for injuries sustained during their arrest. Some were subjected to dehumanizing remarks from police officers. King County prosecutors have declined all felony and vandalism charges for lack of evidence. The students are back on campus. Each now faces a misdemeanor trespass charge carrying a potential sentence of up to a year in jail and a $5,000 fine.”
“A university, of all institutions, might be expected to announce the criminal prosecution of its own non-violent, conscientious objectors with something other than pleasure,” he added.
Rocha even compared the anti-Israel radical suspects with a civil rights protest.
One wonders whether our communications office would have led with an expression of pleasure had criminal charges been filed against the students who occupied a university building in 1968. That protest, led by the Black Student Union (BSU), ended with President Odegaard signing a statement agreeing to the students’ demands. Eight years ago, the same office that is now “pleased” at criminal charges for our students celebrated the BSU occupation’s fiftieth anniversary under the headline “Born of protest,” crediting it with establishing our Office of Minority Affairs & Diversity. The UW magazine has honored that same occupation. The Seattle Civil Rights & Labor History Project, hosted on UW servers, suggests our Department of American Ethnic Studies owes partial thanks for its creation to institutional reforms catalyzed by BSU protests.
Not everyone accepted this bizarre framing.
The pushback
Professor Alexes Harris forcefully rejected Rocha’s attempt to compare the current activists to the 1968 Black Student Union protest.
“It is false to compare the 1968 non-violent sit-in by student activists to what the students did in May of 2025,” Harris wrote. “There was no property destruction – no spray painting, fires, shattered widows, or equipment destroyed.” She also called Rocha out directly: “I find it dishonest and misleading for people who do not know about the 1968 BSU protests at the UW to make the statements you have posted.”
Political science professor Mark Smith went even further, drawing a line between lawful protest and the chaos tied to SUPER UW.
“The SUPER UW protest, based on an illegal occupation of a building, instead degenerated into vandalism and property destruction,” he wrote.
He added: “There could be one good outcome from this mess, however, if we recognize that we failed these students as educators. They somehow thought that occupying a building, and protecting the reckless participants in their midst, would advance their political goals. Instead, the actual cause the students were promoting got lost on this list, in the Seattle media, and in the public conversation more broadly. Those of us who have regular interactions with students need to do better in teaching them about the work in history, sociology, political science, and other disciplines about effective and ineffective protest tactics.”
At a campus where extremist activism is often indulged by faculty, the substance of those responses matters. This time, at least some professors were willing to say the obvious. Illegal occupations, vandalism, and fire-setting are not noble protest tactics just because the activists claim the right politics.
Listen to The Jason Rantz Show on weekday afternoons from 3 p.m. – 7 p.m. on Seattle Red on 770 AM (HD Radio 97.3 FM HD-Channel 3). Subscribe to the podcast here. Follow Jason Rantz on X, Instagram, YouTube, and Facebook.






Comments
5 Comments
Sadly, this vandalism may delay bio-medical or bio-mechanical developments needed to assist people suffering from various maladies.
But you protesters just do what you must. And we're sorry about that little boo-boo you suffered during your arrest.
minor progress
“Several required medical care for injuries sustained during their arrest. Some were subjected to dehumanizing remarks from police officers."
Clearly, nobody expected that acting like a pack of rabid animals would generate immediate consequences. Hey, I'm surprised, too. Professors Alexes Harris and Mark Smith earned their gold stars with this one.