Jim Walsh: These are the three worst bills to hit Olympia in decades
Three unconstitutional Olympia bills would gut your rights, silence critics, and hand bureaucrats unchecked power.
Governor Ferguson and Olympia Democrats are pushing three unconstitutional bills that centralize state power, gag critics, and strip voters of their elected sheriffs. (Photo courtesy of House Republicans of Washington)
(Photo courtesy of House Republicans of Washington)
Three bad bills peddled by Governor Bob Ferguson, Attorney General Nick Brown and Washington Democrats in Olympia are worth considering together. They have a kind of negative synergy—they create bigger problems together than each would individually.
The current governor’s unconstitutional state income scheme, via Senate Bill 6346, would impose a 9.9% tax on some Washington families. The State Senate version included a massive tax break for large corporations, mostly in the technology sector; the House committee stripped that tax break out. After that happened, a group of tech industry executives sent a letter to the current governor, urging him to pause the state income tax scheme and raise the (equally unconstitutional) state capital gains tax instead.
A tax built on constitutional sand
The fatal constitutional flaw in the governor’s state income tax scheme is that it is not applied in a “uniform” manner, as required by Article VII of the State Constitution. Worse, the scheme assumes that the State Supreme Court will overturn its own precedent decision Culliton v. Chase. That precedent has long held that personal income is, for tax purposes, property. Democrat politicians have tried to set a narrative frame around this issue by whining that the Culliton precedent is 90 years old and should be overturned because…it’s old.
That’s a specious argument that distracts from the actual point: a bill based on the assumption that the Court will reverse its own precedent is a house built on a foundation of sand.
A non-uniform state income tax requires an amendment to Article VII of the State Constitution. The current governor’s current version does not do that. An alternate version—offered by Democrat Rep. Amy Walen—does include a constitutional amendment. But the current governor’s supporters assume that the State Supreme Court will rubber-stamp their unconstitutional version. If they’re right, that’s an affront to our state’s separation of powers. The Court should not be a rubber stamp. That weakens checks and balances and encourages centralization of political power—away from the people.
A final thought on this unconstitutional state income tax scheme: Although it doesn’t take full effect until 2029—three years from now—it currently carries a “necessity” clause, similar to an emergency clause, that puts the scheme into law immediately. Why does a new tax that doesn’t take effect for three years need to be implemented immediately?
It doesn’t. That clause is there to block the people’s right to mount a referendum to overturn the unconstitutional state income tax scheme. This might be the worst insult in the worst bill to ooze through Olympia in decades.
The AG’s new weapon against you
Senate Bill 5925 will lead to a massive expansion and likely weaponization of the State Attorney General’s investigative powers. It should cause intense concern for everyone in Washington.
The bill allows the State Attorney General to issue himself “civil investigative demands”—a kind of search warrant—in any non-criminal situation. It’s authoritarian. And tyrannical. The only way to defend yourself against a civil investigative demand is to hire an attorney and file a lawsuit against the state. So, the State Attorney can weaponize the tool—bankrupting a person or business in Kafkaesque courtroom battles before he takes any enforcement action or decides not to take any enforcement action.
Even worse: the bill allows a judge to issue a “gag order” on any civil investigative demand and resulting actions. So, the targeted person or business could not speak publicly about what’s happening. And the people of Washington would never know.
Targeting the sheriffs who won’t comply
The anti-sheriff political witch hunt bill, Senate Bill 5794, has gotten a lot of media attention because it’s clearly designed to remove outspoken sheriffs like Pierce County’s Keith Swank, Klickitat County’s Bob Songer and Thurston County’s Derek Sanders from office. Of course, it does worse than that. It allows any elected sheriff to be de-certified and effectively removed at the whim of a governor-appointed commission. It includes very few guardrails around commission’s actions.
Here’s what Thurston County Sheriff Sanders (who’s not particularly conservative, as far as sheriffs go) had to say about the bill: “This is one of the most unpopular, hypocrisy ridden bills ever passed. This bill undermines local elections, creates unnecessary mistrust toward our state government, spits in the face of our democratic process, and doesn’t solve any real problems facing Washingtonians while artificially creating new ones.”
He’s right.
Pierce County Sheriff Swank took the bill—and the rhetoric around it—more personally: “Maybe [this bill] has to happen for the citizens of Washington state to say ‘that is overreach, that is too much. Even if I don’t like Swank, I don’t want him removed from office for what he said because that could happen to someone I agree with down the road’.”
He’s also right.
You don’t need to be a targeted sheriff to oppose this anti-sheriff bill. County sheriffs are more than just law enforcement officers. They are reflections of the values and priorities of the people who elect them. A governor-appointed bureaucratic commission effectively removing locally-elected county sheriffs from office is a flagrant violation of Article I, Section 1, of the State Constitution: “All political power is inherent in the people, and governments derive their just powers from the consent of the governed….”
County sheriffs must be elected by the people of their counties.
Three bills, one very dangerous pattern
What do these three bad bills, that are oozing toward the current governor’s desk, have in common?
First, they’re all unconstitutional. Second, they’re all wildly unpopular. Third, they all centralize control and power within state bureaucratic agencies.
That last point is the biggest problem. These bills, taken together, create an overall drift in state law toward centralization of control and political power within the state bureaucracy. This runs against the spirit—and letter—of Article I of the State Constitution. More than any tax, more than any pseudo-search warrant, that bureaucratic power insults the foundational premise of Washington law that “all political power is inherent in the people.”
Jim Walsh is a Republican state representative from Aberdeen who serves as chairman of the Washington State Republican Party, where he has focused on rebuilding party infrastructure, candidate recruitment, and grassroots engagement.
Follow Seattle Red on-air at 770 AM, on the Seattle Red app, and streaming audio and video on SeattleRed.com.





Comments
5 Comments
WA State's governing and political leadership is embracing a very rapid metamorphosis. A change where there is nothing but a downside; a Democracy Fragmenting and an AutocracyGaining Mass and Momentum.
A definition borrowed from Google:
Autocracy is a form of government where supreme, absolute power is concentrated in the hands of one person (an autocrat) or a small group, with no effective constitutional checks or accountability to the public. Rulers in an autocracy, such as dictatorships or absolute monarchies, exercise total control over civil liberties, laws, and the state.
Anyone who at any time voted for any democrat for any position directly shares the responsibility for the power and money grabs that the democrats are attempting to carry out. Votes for democrats embolden, encourage and strengthen them as a whole. NEVER VOTE FOR ANY DEMOCRAT EVER.
Thank you for creating awareness around this dangerous shift toward raw power grabs by one-sided rule. Well written and argued.