Jim Walsh: Olympia Democrats treating pensions like a piggy bank
Washington House Democrats pass HB 2034 to transfer $4B from the overfunded LEOFF1 pension plan for cops and firefighters.
Washington State Republican Party Chair Jim Walsh says Democrats fell short of a legislative supermajority. (Photo: Washington State Republican Party)
(Photo: Washington State Republican Party)
Last week, House Bill 2034, “Concerning termination and restatement of plan 1 of the law enforcement officers’ and firefighters’ retirement system,” passed off the House floor in Olympia. This was shocking. The bill takes some $4 billion from the oldest state pension fund for cops and firefighters, known as LEOFF1.
HB 2034 doesn’t “borrow” or “adjust” pension funds. It simply steals the money.
The vote was 55-39. All of the “Yea” votes were Democrats. The “Nay” votes were all the Republicans, plus three Democrats who remembered that their Party used to be for working people.
Taking money out of a state pension fund used to be considered a “third rail” issue in Olympia. Tax-and-spend politicians would occasionally talk about doing it—but the hard truth was that, if the actually did it, their careers would be electrocuted.
Suddenly, Washington Democrats are fine raiding pensions
Years ago, one “progressive” Leftist legislator tested the idea of raiding state pensions to start up a “state bank.” That test failed. More recently, there were some suggestions to take a few billion from the pensions to fill a projected “deficit” in the state’s operating budget. Those were ignored. But this year, it may actually happen.
What changed? Why are state employee pensions such a tempting target for increasingly desperate tax-and-spenders? Because, as the famous bank robber Willy Sutton said, that’s where the money is. For decades, we’ve been careful about managing our state pensions. Olympia isn’t careful about anything financial anymore. So, everything’s at risk.
Washington’s public-employee pension system is among the best-funded in the United States. The state operates 15 different plans for state and local government employees. These plans have a total of about $218 billion in assets and include over 700,000 participants (counting both active employees and retirees collecting benefits), according to the Washington State Department of Retirement Systems (DRS). The plans have assets equal, on average, to 96 percent of their projected obligations. While DRS runs the whole system, the separate Washington State Investment Board (WSIB) is responsible for managing the investments. And WSIB has historically done very well, outperforming analogous boards in other states.
Context around pensions
Historically, Washington hasn’t manipulated or borrowed against public-employee pensions as states like California and Illinois have. (California owes more than $270 billion to its state pension funds; Illinois owes more than $200 billion.)
Here in Washington, the average public-employee pension plan is funded at 96 percent—but a few are substantially overfunded. That means they have more cash and investments on hand than they need to cover projected payments to retirees. It’s a rare thing in the public-employee pension marketplace.
As I’ve mentioned, HB 2034 takes money away from the LEOFF1 plan. It’s one of the most overfunded plans in our state—currently managing assets worth 160 percent of its projected obligations to retirees. (The term used in pension-management circles is “160 percent Actuarial Value of Assets.”) And the numbers are projected to get even stronger: By the end of the 2027-2029 state budget cycle, LEOFF1 will have a 225 percent Actuarial Value of Assets. That translates into a surplus of more than $4 billion. That’s worth something like $800,000 to each retiree in LEOFF1.
Addicted to taxing and spending
Tax-and-spend politicians in Olympia want to take the $4 billion out of LEOFF1 and are using HB 2034 to do that. Their excuse is that, when LEOFF1 was started nearly 50 years ago, some of the initial capital was provided by the State General Fund; so that should be paid back to the General Fund.
According to HB2034, in 2029, the State Treasurer must transfer funds equal to 110 percent of projected LEOFF1 pension obligations into a new “Restated LEOFF.” From the estimated $4 billion surplus, $569 million will be transferred to the state’s Climate Commitment Account and the rest to the General Fund.
Is this constitutional? Yes, the federal and state constitutions both allow the legislative branch to manage things like government salaries and pension plans.
Is it legal? Very likely, yes. Federal law that applies to governmental pension plans allows “termination” and/or “restatement,” which basically means the settling of obligations of a plan. Private-sector pensions must comply with the extensive regulatory framework that exists under the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974 (ERISA) and Federal Internal Revenue Service (IRS) rules. State governmental pension plans are not subject to ERISA, and most IRS rules also do not apply.
So, HB 2034 is likely constitutional and legal. But is it a good idea? No.
Basic money management ignored
When my children were getting old enough to understand how money works, one of the key lessons I tried to teach them was: Don’t give up long-term capital assets to cover short-term operating costs. In other words, don’t use retirement money to pay monthly bills. Or don’t borrow against your house to go on vacation. Trading long-term savings or assets for short-term gratification is the path to poverty.
That’s exactly what HB 2034 does. It steals $4 billion from a long-term asset—our overfunded LEOFF1 pension plan—to pay the state-government equivalent of monthly bills (the General Fund) and vacation (the Climate Commitment Act). It’s reckless financial management. And it’s a horrible precedent.
Teachers and state employees, watch out: If this raid on a pension plan for cops and firefighters passes into law, your pensions are next.
There’s still time to stop HB 2034. The State Senate hasn’t voted on it yet.
Jim Walsh is a Republican state representative from Aberdeen who serves as chairman of the Washington State Republican Party, where he has focused on rebuilding party infrastructure, candidate recruitment, and grassroots engagement.
Follow Seattle Red on-air at 770 AM, on the Seattle Red app, and streaming audio and video on SeattleRed.com.






Comments
8 Comments
Those funds will be solvent, too, owing to the transfer of money from LEOFF 1 to the TRS and other accounts.
Questions: Is the legislature willing to take on the potential ire of the WEA and lose powerful backing, or is the WEA complicit? Perhaps this isn't an either/or situation, and I'm missing something important here. For example, does the legislature's rogue power grab render WEA's support as superfluous?
Why doesn't the Legislature consider reducing pension plan contributions; at least temporarily. Budget Deficit would be reduced and risk of depleting the over funding cushion would be not be reduced so abruptly, thereby reducing beneficiary risk. How would the over funding look if the stock market reset and dropped 30%?