Rantz: Democrats know their income tax is unconstitutional. That’s exactly the point.
Governor Bob Ferguson and WA Democrats aren't trying to pass an income tax. They're trying to get the Supreme Court to legalize one.
Washington House Democrats passed a 9.9% income tax Tuesday as Republicans called it unconstitutional, warned the middle class will eventually pay, and blasted the bill's referendum block. (TVW)
(TVW)
Let’s be honest about what’s actually happening in Olympia. Democrats aren’t passing an income tax because they think it will survive. They’re passing it because they want it to fail up to the Washington State Supreme Court. That’s where they hope to win big. And they likely will.
Since 1933, Culliton v. Chase has been the law of the land. Income is property in Washington State, and a graduated income tax is unconstitutional under the uniformity clause. Washington Democrats have spent nearly a century wanting to kill that precedent. Voters have blocked them every step of the way, rejecting income tax measures ten times at the ballot box, with the most recent rejection in 2010.
Last year, voters passed I-2111 specifically banning a state income tax. Democrats just amended their own bill to exempt it from that voter-approved protection.
So what changed? The court.
When Democrats passed the capital gains tax, they had a two-pronged strategy: offer a sympathetic court a way to uphold it without overturning 90 years of precedent, while clearly hoping the court would reverse itself on income taxes altogether. The justices strongly signaled their willingness (even eagerness) to do so in a future case.
That future case is now. Washington taxpayers are, effectively, just five votes away from seeing a century of precedent erased by a Supreme Court that has already telegraphed its intentions. It’s a setup.
The game plan is as simple as it is devious. They will pass an unconstitutional tax, watch it get challenged, hand their far-left Supreme Court the vehicle they’ve been waiting for to torch Culliton and gift Olympia a permanent income tax, all without ever asking voters. They know that left-wing media won’t call this out because reporters share their far-left views. And voters here, even when angry, reflexively vote Democrat anyway.
Ignoring the will of the people
Former Chief Justice Gerry Alexander, former Justice Phil Talmadge, and former Attorney General Rob McKenna have stated unequivocally: income is intangible property under Washington’s constitution. The correct response, as it has always been, is a constitutional amendment put to voters. But Democrats have tried that too — and lost, with margins as high as 77 percent against.
The people have spoken. Eleven times. But Democrats have decided five justices matter more than seven million Washingtonians because when they don’t get their way, they find avenues to pass their agenda, anyway.
Listen to The Jason Rantz Show on weekday afternoons from 3 p.m. – 7 p.m. on Seattle Red on 770 AM (HD Radio 97.3 FM HD-Channel 3). Subscribe to the podcast here. Follow Jason Rantz on X, Instagram, YouTube, and Facebook.






Comments
6 Comments
You know the Democrat Thieves will start high but it's a gateway drug and will find it's way down the scale. They can't help but steal. Anyone with money's going to leave the state, like they're doing in Kooky California. It's what happens when vote Communists in.
It's not even a matter of if, but when. I give it 5 years MAX until this income tax is hitting everyone earning above the poverty line.
Here's the biggest issue: those same folks fleeing kooky Cali are coming here, to Oregon, to Arizona, and to Texas and voting for the same policies that drove them out of CA. The only tax law CA has right is basing property taxes on the most recent sale price of a home and limiting increases to 2% annually.
We get what we vote for.