ADVERTISEMENT

JASON RANTZ OPINION

Rantz: Seattle Times offers advice on how to scare your child about immigration enforcement

Seattle Times publishes parenting guide on talking to kids about ICE, framing immigration enforcement as trauma instead of explaining why borders and deportations exist.

U.S. Border Patrol agents in tactical gear detain a subject against a black SUV during a federal im...

U.S. Border Patrol agents detain a subject during a federal immigration operation. Oregon Gov. Tina Kotek is refusing to issue undercover plates to ICE despite a DOJ lawsuit. (Photo by Jamie Kelter Davis/Getty Images)

(Photo by Jamie Kelter Davis/Getty Images)

There are earnest parenting guides, and then there is whatever The Seattle Times just published under the headline “Talking to your kids about ICE activity? Experts share 6 tips.” A more honest title would be “An abusive parents’ guide to traumatizing your child for political points.”

The premise is that parents must now process President Donald Trump’s immigration enforcement with their children in the same category as birds and bees and gun violence. That is activist-journalism disguises as talk therapy.

“But in light of President Donald Trump’s immigration enforcement crackdown — in Minneapolis and beyond — parents are now faced with helping their children make sense of distressing images and reports of detentions, family separations and violence against protesters,” Ryan Nguyen writes in what could read like parody,

According to the article, this is now a standard parenting hurdle. The Seattle Times cannot acknowledge that we have borders and immigration laws; that we deport people who are here illegally, including dangerous criminals who pose threats to the very children parents the newspaper is talking to. That is not a bedtime horror story. It is called sovereignty.

Seattle parenting advice turns enforcement into trauma

The Seattle Times quotes therapist Christina Alexander, who warns parents not to engage after “doomscrolling on my phone in the morning right before helping my kids get dressed and packed up for school or right before I see a client.” If you are so emotionally dysregulated over ICE that you need a breathing exercise before making breakfast, maybe the problem is not federal law enforcement.

ADVERTISEMENT

Another therapist suggests having “smaller, more bite-sized conversations” so children can process immigration raids gradually, according to the article. Bite-sized conversations about what, exactly? That the United States deports people who violate immigration law. Of course not. This article is meant to talk through the invented trauma that they pretend kids experience when they hear about ICE raids capturing murderers, rapists, and drug dealers that The Seattle Times will repackage as a “Seattle dad” or “Spokane mom” being deported.

The article even urges parents to create a safety plan.

“Let them know what might happen,” Harmony Raveler, a child therapist at Seattle Play Therapy, said, adding that it’s best to be clear with your child, using “simple, honest language” that is age-appropriate. If by simple and honest we mean telling children that the country enforces its laws, fine. If we mean implying ICE agents are lurking outside soccer practice, that is something else entirely.

ADVERTISEMENT

Why borders are not child abuse

Here is the most embarrassing part. The same political ecosystem that demands compassion for illegal immigrants also demands we avert our eyes from the crimes some commit. If someone is a child rapist and here illegally, deportation is not cruelty. It is the bare minimum.

Instead of teaching kids that enforcement equals oppression, how about teaching them why borders exist? Nations control entry. Laws apply equally. Criminals face consequences. The Seattle Times treats immigration enforcement as an emotional hazard to be navigated in candlelit bedrooms with a calming soundtrack to set the mood. That may make for a soothing bedtime ritual. It does not make for responsible journalism.

The real lesson children need is simpler. Governments have laws, those laws matter, and sometimes the adults melting down about them are the ones who need a calming environment and a therapist.

ADVERTISEMENT

Listen to The Jason Rantz Show on weekday afternoons from 3 p.m. – 7 p.m. on Seattle Red on 770 AM (HD Radio 97.3 FM HD-Channel 3). Subscribe to the podcast here. Follow Jason Rantz on X, Instagram, YouTube, and Facebook.

Jason Rantz Talk Show Host and Columnist at Seattle Red

Jason Rantz hosts The Jason Rantz Show on Seattle Red 770 AM weekdays from 3 p.m. to 7 p.m.

Comments

2 Comments

D
Doug Spittler 9 months ago

It all makes perfect sense. When WA legislators made the minimum wage the highest in the land, that put WA farmers in a tough spot. In order to mitigate that move, WA legislators must now do all they can to protect illegal aliens who are loath to complain they're not getting paid the minimum wage. See? It's all good!

"There is nothing so good that politicians can't make it bad and nothing so bad that politicians can't make it worse. Compassion is good but politicians have turned compassion into the welfare state. Crime is bad but politicians have made it worse by going easy on criminals." —Thomas Sowell

S
Shawn m 9 months ago

Sadly, The Seattle Times is often the most persuasive argument against freedom of the press.