Rantz: The Seattle Times pretends to be baffled that Starbucks’ CEO makes more than a barista
The Seattle Times questions Starbucks CEO pay, but the massive gap reflects market reality, not injustice. Here’s what the paper ignores.
UW professor Cliff Mass says a Seattle Times Climate Lab story on Skagit River flooding ignored federal flow data. (Photo: Linda Thomas, KIRO Newsradio)
(Photo: Linda Thomas, KIRO Newsradio)
The Seattle Times wants readers to clutch their pearls over executive pay at Starbucks. It’s insulting to readers’ basic intelligence.
In a recent piece, the left-wing newspaper plays confused about why the CEO of Starbucks earns dramatically more than the company’s average worker. The framing is not subtle. The article highlights the pay gap and treats it as evidence of something suspect in corporate America. It invites readers to see injustice, not basic economics.
This article is not about exploring how compensation markets function. It is suggesting the gap itself is a problem.
Seattle Times frames CEO pay as a moral failing
The Seattle Times headline, “One WA CEO makes 1,794 times his average employee. Here’s why,” signals the intent. The ratio is the hook. The outrage is implied.
The article notes that Starbucks CEO Brian Niccol’s compensation dwarfs that of the average Starbucks worker, according to the report. It then walks through stock awards and executive incentives as if they are mysterious windfalls rather than standard tools in corporate governance. It’s not exactly breaking news. Or news.
The average Starbucks worker is a barista. It is a low-wage, low-skilled job. It is a job that can be replaced by automation and in many homes already has been replaced by a Keurig. That is not an insult. It is an economic reality.
The CEO, by contrast, is responsible for a global brand, tens of thousands of employees, shareholder value, regulatory compliance, and long-term strategy. The market for that talent is limited, unlike the market for entry-level service workers. And, in this case, Starbucks paid a premium because they need to dramatically rework the brand, which has strayed over the last several years.
Economics is not activism
The Seattle Times wants readers to focus on the 1,794-to-1 ratio. It does not seriously grapple with how equity compensation works or why boards compete aggressively for proven executives. It does not meaningfully explore risk, performance metrics, or the fact that much of CEO pay is tied to stock value.
There is no mystery here. Scarce skills command higher compensation, while broadly available skills do not. If Starbucks replaced its CEO with a random barista, the company would crater. If it replaced one barista, customers would barely notice.
The Seattle Times can keep pretending to be puzzled. The rest of us understand that leading a multinational corporation is not the same as steaming milk.
Listen to The Jason Rantz Show on weekday afternoons from 3 p.m. – 7 p.m. on Seattle Red on 770 AM (HD Radio 97.3 FM HD-Channel 3). Subscribe to the podcast here. Follow Jason Rantz on X, Instagram, YouTube, and Facebook.






Comments
4 Comments
It’s that old saying… “people who have never signed the front of a paycheck” -I think Limbaugh said that about Barry Sotero.
6th graders today are not as smart as they were years ago. Sadly, WA students are being indoctrinated instead of educated.
The Seattle Times has been reduced to a 6th grade school paper. No wait. That's an insult to 6th grade school papers, because 6th grade school papers don't cover up horrific crimes against minors like The Seattle Times did.