Oregon athletes win free speech fight after transgender podium protest; Title IX battle continues
Protesting Oregon athletes settled their free speech suit, reclaiming medals while continuing their Title IX challenge.
Protesting Oregon athletes win free speech suit, continue Title IX fight. (Photo by Christian Petersen/Getty Images)
(Photo by Christian Petersen/Getty Images)
Two former high school athletes, Alexa Anderson and Reese Eckard, have settled their free speech lawsuit against the Oregon School Activities Association (OSAA). The dispute began last May when the girls stepped off the medal podium at a state championship to protest competing against a transgender athlete.
The settlement successfully restored the athletes’ medals. But it also highlighted the league’s uneven application of free speech rules regarding political expression. A separate legal challenge concerning Title IX protections for women’s sports remains ongoing.
Athletes claimed retaliation
Anderson and Eckard alleged that OSAA officials punished their protest by excluding them from the official podium photo and refusing to hand over the medals they earned. Anderson described the incident to Fox News, saying an official told her the medals would be shipped to the school, but “they were never shipped.”
The athletes filed a free speech lawsuit in July, and their legal team, the America First Policy Institute (AFPI), claims the medals were only finally delivered to their law firm afterwards. A key part of the athletes’ legal argument focused on the OSAA allowing certain political messages, such as those supporting Black Lives Matter and pro-LGBTQ pride, while allegedly punishing their protest.
A U.S. District Court Judge last month sided with the athletes by refusing to strike down this part of the lawsuit, keeping the issue of selective speech enforcement relevant.
Lawsuit dismissed, declared a win
With the core goals of the lawsuit achieved, the athletes’ AFPI lawyers moved to dismiss the case, a move the OSAA did not oppose. AFPI Director of Litigation Andrew Zimmitti hailed the result as a success stating, “We protected these young women, we exposed how officials retaliated against them… and we elevated their story to a national audience,” according to Fox News.
AFPI Chief Legal Affairs Officer Leigh Ann O’Neill called the settlement a “major victory,” ensuring the girls not only received their earned medals but also had their First Amendment right to peaceful expression restored.
The athletes emphasized the importance of their stand.
“We spoke up because what was happening wasn’t fair,” Anderson said, according to Fox News.
Anderson and Eckard were later honored for their stand at the 2025 Fox Nation Patriot Awards, where they received the Most Valuable Patriot award and were formally given their state championship medals.
Separate Title IX fight continues
While the free speech lawsuit is now finished, the athletes have an ongoing, separate lawsuit against the OSAA concerning Title IX violations—the federal law that ensures equal opportunity for women in sports. AFPI stated this Title IX fight will now be their primary focus.
AFPI stated this Title IX fight will now be their primary focus, aiming to hold officials accountable for redefining basic terms like “sex” in athletic competition.
Follow Seattle Red on-air at 770 AM, on the Seattle Red app, and streaming audio and video on SeattleRed.com.






Comments
0 Comments