ADVERTISEMENT

WEATHER

Cliff Mass calls Washington wildfire drought warning ‘bogus,’ says science doesn’t back it up

UW professor Cliff Mass says science doesn't support Commissioner Upthegrove's wildfire risk warning tied to Washington's drought emergency declaration.

Firefighter silhouetted against wildfire flames in a burning forest at night...

A firefighter stands against the glow of an advancing wildfire. UW professor Cliff Mass says Washington's fire risk depends on summer heat, wind, and lightning — not snowpack. (Photo: Pablo Blazquez Dominguez/Getty Images)

(Photo: Pablo Blazquez Dominguez/Getty Images)

Washington Public Lands Commissioner Dave Upthegrove used last week’s statewide drought emergency declaration to warn residents that four straight years of drought put Washington at elevated wildfire risk this summer. University of Washington atmospheric sciences professor Cliff Mass heard that and called it out by name: “bogus.”

Mass said the science simply does not support the dramatic statements.

What Upthegrove actually said about Washington wildfire risk

As reported by MyNorthwest, Upthegrove was unambiguous at last Wednesday’s news conference.

“Four straight years of drought means we are at a higher risk of wildfires this summer,” he said. “Fires will be more prone to start and will spread faster.”

“So in drought conditions like this, it’s more important than ever that Washington state residents follow the rules,” he added. “I like to quote Smokey Bear: ‘Only you can prevent forest fires.’”

Mass had no issue with the public safety message. He had a big problem with everything before it.

“That’s not true,” Mass explained on The Jason Rantz Show on Seattle Red 770 AM. “Now we’re talking about statements that are really bordering on deceptive and false. There’s very, very little correlation between the snowpack here in late, middle to late spring right now and wildfires later on. I checked the numbers, and anybody who’s honest can tell you that there really is very little correlation.”

ADVERTISEMENT

What actually drives wildfire risk in Washington, according to Mass

Mass didn’t just reject Upthegrove’s framing. He explained what the data actually shows matters for wildfire conditions in Washington.

“The key thing about wildfires here is having a warm, dry summer, having strong winds — that’s very important — and having a lot of lightning,” Mass said on the show. “Those are the crucial things for wildfires around here, not the snow pack. So if anybody claims otherwise, that is false.”

This is consistent with what Mass has argued before on Seattle Red — that low snowpack numbers get used to drive alarm that the underlying science doesn’t back up. It’s a pattern. Officials reach for the most alarming available metric and let the narrative run, whether or not the variables actually connect.

Rantz pressed Mass specifically on the “four straight years of drought” framing Upthegrove leaned on as the basis for elevated fire danger. Mass didn’t soften his answer.

ADVERTISEMENT

“Is bogus, and it is not correct,” he said. “There is no reason right now to expect a greater chance of wildfires over the area because of the meteorological situation. There really is no basis for that.”

Upthegrove isn’t the first official Mass has had to correct

Upthegrove’s wildfire warning came attached to a broader drought declaration from Governor Bob Ferguson and Ecology Director Casey Sixkiller — a declaration Mass also called into question, as Seattle Red reported.

Reservoirs across the state are above normal, the Yakima system is at its highest summertime levels, and the forecast calls for substantial rain over the next several weeks. The snowpack is below normal. The water supply isn’t. Upthegrove’s wildfire warning grafted fire season alarm onto a drought declaration that Mass says already overstates the underlying conditions. One questionable claim layered on top of another.

ADVERTISEMENT

Mass did agree with one piece of Upthegrove’s statement — the part that had nothing to do with weather.

“Wildfires are almost entirely human caused,” Mass noted, acknowledging Upthegrove’s point that residents should follow fire prevention rules. On that part, no argument.

Everything else, Mass said, is unsupported by the data.

Listen to The Jason Rantz Show on weekday afternoons from 3 p.m. – 7 p.m. on Seattle Red on 770 AM (HD Radio 97.3 FM HD-Channel 3). Subscribe to the podcast here. Follow Jason Rantz on X, Instagram, YouTube, and Facebook.

Comments

9 Comments

R
R Ice 7 months ago

Its all about making things look bad so the liberals keep spending money. They never saw a penny that did not NEED to be spent. And when it is gone, TAX baby tax.

E
Erich Britton 7 months ago

Ideology over reality. That is the only way to disseminate information when your a one party Democrat run state.

V
Vegaman Dan 7 months ago

Satellite thermal imagery and smoke alerts are in use today as well, greatly improving coverage.