SEATTLE NEWS ARCHIVES & FEATURES
Saul Spady: Seattle is becoming Detroit, but it doesn’t have to be this way
Seattle is going the way of Detroit, but Saul Spady says it doesn't have to be this way.
Seattle’s going the way of Detroit. And the legacy Democrats are losing because they have no plan.
As you vote before Tuesday’s primary (print your ballot here), I want you to take a hard look at what’s happening around us. Seattle is staring into the same economic abyss that swallowed Detroit in an economic collapse from 1980-2014.
Back then, it didn’t happen all at once. Detroit bled out slowly. Automation gutted car manufacturing over a decade, middle class families left, revenues tanked and growth stopped, and city and state leadership doubled down on more taxes while the streets fell apart before the exodus began.
Now look around Seattle, any of that sound familiar? We don’t build cars, we code; and the Emerald City may be just as vulnerable as Motor City to economic collapse in the face of automation.
AI is already catching up. Last month, it nearly beat the best human coder in a global competition—humanity won for the last time. A year ago, we won by a mile; next year, the AI probably wins.
When AI can code better than our friends, what happens to 30–40% of our region’s high paying software jobs? You know, the jobs that pay for our schools, transit, and social safety net?
Can Seattle and King County continue with “Housing First”?
Now layer that with what our local leaders are doing.
Washington Democrats just passed a $9 billion tax hike—with no new programs, just treading water to fill revenue gaps. King County raised sales tax, filling a leaky bucket as revenues dip and growth slows across the county. Seattle’s coming after business with another B&O increase… because you guessed it. Not enough revenue from old taxes.
Why are we even raising taxes in the first place? More money into “Housing First” programs that aren’t working. The result? More tents. More fentanyl. More taxpayers moving to Bellevue, if we’re lucky, or out of state, taking the dollars out of Washington forever.
Housing First has failed. The public knows it. You know it. I know it. Yet no one at City Hall or in Olympia wants to admit it. It’s why I’m leading an effort to ban public camping in King County with an ordinance.
We’ve spent billions, built fewer than 10,000 public housing units—costing nearly $1 million each, doubling our state budget since 2015.
The result? Over 16,000 people are still outside in King County, many addicted, untreated, and left to die in public view, plus we are 300,000 units behind across the county.
In fact, we have taxed developers to allow government to build insanely expensive public development that doesn’t solve the problem. No wonder we’ve slowed growth to a halt in the Pacific Northwest.
Democratic Socialists aren’t going to save us
But don’t you worry. While the ship sinks and graffiti expands, Democratic Socialists are out there pitching a plan. Sure, it’s a bad plan (tax everyone, build even more public housing with no accountability for those on the street). But it’s a plan.
What do establishment Democrats offer? Bureaucracy. Blaming Trump and giving blank checks to public housing nonprofits that can’t explain what they actually fix with their investment.
Democrats need a new identity badly.
Let’s stop letting the Democratic Socialists pretend they’re the only bold ones. They’re not bold. They are misguided anti-growth Democrats who’ve mistaken ever-growing graffiti, tents and addiction for progress.
Cascade Democrats can offer hope
What we need are Pro-Growth Cascade Democrats, one that even Republicans can get behind if they want to win in more “progressive” cities where having an ‘R’ next to the name on the ballot is a non-starter.
The Cascade Party knows you don’t solve addiction by handing someone a key to a million-dollar unit they’ll leave within a week. You don’t build housing by declaring a tax, permitting and zoning war on the only people who know how to build said housing affordably. And you don’t revive a city by letting people slowly rot on the sidewalk in the throes of hyper-addiction 2.0.
As leader of the Quality of Life Coalition, here’s what we’re offering via ordinances:
- A public camping ban—with direction to real shelter and support
- 3 strikes = 6 months mandatory rehab (because people dying in the street deserve treatment vs. a revolving criminal justice system based on “compassionate release”)
- 5-year minimum sentences for dealers of fentanyl and meth
- 20-story zoning near light rail—fast permits, local retail on the ground floor, and affordable units because developers want to build and we should let them!
This is about delivering results before it’s too late.
Seattle is on the brink, but there are solutions
Let me be blunt: if Amazon and Microsoft start shedding 30% of their workforce, Seattle’s economy implodes if we don’t adapt in the next four years.
“So what do we do, Saul?” you may be asking.
Rebrand the Democrats as Pro Growth problem solvers with a plan to improve Quality of Life across the West Coast. Reclaim our cities from Seattle to Los Angeles from the failed Housing First policy by investing in shelter, rehab and treatment. And provide a simple plan to reduce the zoning, permitting and red tape preventing the private-public partnership to build the 300,000 units we need in King County.
Stop pouring money into a Housing First model that doesn’t work.
Start investing in shelter, rehab, and increasing housing supply—in partnership with private developers who know how to build and scale.
This is the coalition to improve our Quality of Life. It is the vision of the Cascade Democrats—a movement of pro growth builders, instead of anti-growth bureaucrats.
Seattle doesn’t have to go Detroit. We are dangerously close, and we’re running out of time.
Saul Spady is the founder of the Quality of Life Coalition, which is currently collecting signatures for a King County ordinance banning public camping when there is shelter space available.






Comments
1 Comments
Disingenuous deflection on the part of Spady.
These jails and rehabilitation programs he wants to send the homeless and addicted to cost taxpayer money. We have established that jail is practically junior college for petty criminals, and that it makes it harder when they're released to find jobs and housing once that record has been established. And rehab, because of the nature of addiction often has to be gone through multiple times to begin to stick.
So when Spady wants to use your taxpayer dollars to round them up and pack em' into prisons like sardines for the crimes of addiction and homelessness, he's pretending it's some great savings or solution that puts these people back on the right path and that housing first has failed, full stop.
And yet, Finland would prove otherwise. You see when people have more stable living situations, and support and a case worker, it helps them hold to their treatment plans. It helps them get off drugs. But you have to provide the stability first, because in part, the instability is what helps perpetuate the cycle. Now, if Seattle had invested in this in let's say, the 90s, we would be further along. Instead, we're playing catch-up.
And each time we try to ask for funding for even a band-aid on these societal wounds, people scream about how ineffective it is. Because what we need isn't a band-aid, or Spady's solution of shipping them off to somewhere to keep the cycle going out of the eyes of his cultured and connected wealthy friends and family. He wants you to keep your focus on the real victims! The wealthy of Seattle who are being impeded on by those nasty homeless and the people that want to house them.
Spady is a grifter. A failed radio host who runs interference for his wealthy family so their tax bill doesn't increase, and who are to be fair negatively impacted by loiterers and petty crime. Spady doesn't care what happens to the addicted and unhoused once they're out of his sight, and he knows full well that the housing he wants to deregulate will mostly go to his monied social circle because the working class and the former residents of encampments can't afford them. He knows full well housing costs don't go down in markets like Seattle to the point where it's reachable to that demographic, and he also is against any form of regulation that keeps housing costs under control.
Faux activism aside, Spady's selling a mirage here to Seattle voters. He's betting that you won't research the truth behind fully funded, successful models of housing first in places like Finland, and instead, look at the underfunded and perpetually challenged attempts made in the States that failed precisely because people like the Spady family would never support fully funding and implementing them in the first place. His attitude towards the homeless, in reality, boils down to the following sentiment:
"Eat a bag of Dick's!"