ADVERTISEMENT

TAXES

Ex-senator blasts Nick Brown’s deceitful ballot warning on income tax repeal as a scare tactic

Former state Sen. Lynda Wilson says AG Nick Brown's ballot warning on the WA income tax repeal is a scare tactic over money the state won't collect until 2029.

Attorney General Nick Brown in the KIRO Newsradio studios...

Attorney General Nick Brown hired Bryan Cave Leighton Paisner to defend Initiative 638 in court. (KIRO Newsradio)

(KIRO Newsradio)

Washington Attorney General Nick Brown’s office has handed income tax defenders a weapon printed on the ballot itself, and former state Sen. Lynda Wilson says it is a scare tactic presenting as neutral information.

On July 23, Brown’s office filed the public investment impact disclosure for IP26-645, the Let’s Go Washington initiative to repeal the state’s new 9.9% tax on individual income over $1 million. The single sentence voters will read on their November ballots says the measure would decrease funding for public K-12 education, higher education, and human services, primarily healthcare. Backers had until Monday to appeal the wording, which they did.

The problem, critics point out, is that the tax has not collected a dollar and will not until 2029.

A warning about money that does not exist yet

Wilson, a Vancouver Republican who spent years as the ranking Republican on the Senate Ways and Means Committee, torched the disclosure in a post on X.

“This is government-sponsored advocacy masquerading as neutral ballot information. And it creates a deliberately uneven playing field,” Wilson wrote.

She noted that the tax has not collected a single dime and will not produce revenue until 2029, and that its proceeds are not dedicated to schools, children or health care but instead flow into the general fund, where future legislators decide how or whether to spend them.

The timing matters. The tax passed during the 2026 session and signed by Gov. Bob Ferguson does not take effect until 2028, with collections beginning the following year. Yet a voter filling out a ballot has no way of knowing that when they read a warning that schools lose money the moment they vote yes.

ADVERTISEMENT

Wilson argued the state is weaponizing its own authority.

“Yet the government is using its official position and the ballot itself to suggest that voting for this initiative means taking money away from children and vulnerable people. That is not a statement of fact. It is a political scare tactic designed to make voters do the government’s campaigning for it,” she wrote.

No warning for the families paying the bill

Wilson’s other complaint is that only one side gets a printed message. “Meanwhile, the families and small businesses that will ultimately bear the consequences do not get their own warning printed on the ballot. Their side of the story is nowhere to be found,” she said.

She is not alone.

Ryan Frost, budget and tax policy director at the Washington Policy Center, told The Center Square the language is misleading, saying voters deserve disclosures that explain in plain English what the initiative actually does rather than generic wording meant to scare them.

ADVERTISEMENT

The disclosure will appear on every ballot mailed to Washington voters, a fact tax opponents have flagged for weeks. Brian Heywood has already promised a court fight over the wording, and the public sector unions bankrolling the opposition have every reason to want the warning to stand.

“This is the predictable result of decades of one-party control with no meaningful checks and balances. The people who imposed the tax now get to write the official warning telling voters why they should not repeal it,” she wrote.

Follow Seattle Red on-air at 770 AM, on the Seattle Red app, and streaming audio and video on SeattleRed.com.

Comments

6 Comments

A
ANDREW SELL 4 months ago

Washington has a history of voters passing initiatives only to have them overturned on legal technicalities or due to ballot wording. I-695 and I-976 are good examples. The RTA tax was another case in which many voters didn't realize their car tabs would be based on an outdated vehicle valuation schedule rather than the actual market value. Voters deserve clear, honest ballot language.

Now I'm reading the latest campaign mailers from incumbent legislators, all claiming they need to be re-elected to continue their "good work fighting for working families." This comes after the largest tax increase in state history and a new wealth tax. The disconnect is remarkable. It feels like Olympia is living in a different reality than the people paying the bills.

D
Donald Saul 4 months ago

Even IF/WHEN the initiative passes to repeal the tax, us "regular people" have pretty much zero confidence that it will actually be repealed. As you state, we have one-party rule: no checks and balances; taxation without representation. We look at all the times we passed a limit on car tab taxes via initiative that were subsequently ignored. Sigh.

T
The Watosh 4 months ago

The leftist mantra is and has always been "The leftist end fully justifies any and all leftist means".