WSAC report warns soaring liability costs could bankrupt WA counties
Washington’s Paid Family and Medical Leave premium rises to 1.2% of gross wages on January 1, 2027. (Photo: Julia Dallas, MyNorthwest)
(Photo: Julia Dallas, MyNorthwest)
A newly released Washington State Association of Counties (WSAC) white paper shows that decades of court decisions and state requirements have made county liability costs sharply rise, putting several essential services and the public at risk.
“Washington counties are quietly staring down insolvency, and the breaking point has arrived,” Derek Young, WSAC Executive Director, said. “Every single dollar taken from local budgets to fund massive, unfair litigation payouts is a dollar stripped away from law enforcement, the justice system, and health and human services. This isn’t a legal debate; it’s a fiscal emergency that is harming public safety.”
A bipartisan effort that began in the 1960s ensured fair compensation for injured residents and changed the law allowing state and local governments to be held accountable through the courts. Instead, the report showed that lawmakers’ decision to increase accountability actually created “significant, costly unintended consequences.”
Key court decisions have driven up costs, the white paper argues
The white paper argues that the legislature never intended to impose additional liability on state and local governments performing mandated government functions. Different from private companies, state and local governments can’t choose to stop offering services that contain risk.
Washington Supreme Court rulings also changed the liability landscape for state and local governments. Pivotal rulings in Sofie v. Fibreboard Corp., Norg v. City of Seattle, and Essex v. Grant County undermined the government’s ability to defend against claims, which led to unpredictable payouts and added pressure on local budgets.
The white paper also highlighted various trends that are straining budgets, which include:
- Claims submitted to the Washington Counties Risk Pool have increased by more than 60% since 2021.
- Liability insurance premiums have climbed more than 380% in the same period.
- Some county activities are now uninsurable.
“The current system has turned taxpayers into an insurer for the misconduct of others,” Young said. “County budgets can’t continue to absorb these costs. We need a fair, sustainable system that protects residents and keeps essential services running.”
Report singles out WA’s liability framework as a major factor
Counties have also expressed concerns over liability costs resulting from our state’s joint and several liability framework. Under Washington law, taxpayers are on the hook for large payouts even when the state or local government actions played a small role in a claim.
WSAC noted that small counties with limited resources face greater proportional risks, as rising costs threaten mandated services such as public safety, roads, public health, elections, and courts.
The white paper outlined several reform options for lawmakers to consider, which include:
- Exempting certain types of government activities from liability in most cases.
- Implementing caps on damage awards for certain types of tort claims.
- Reforming joint and several liability rules.
- Creating an alternative process for addressing tort claims against state and local governments.
White paper insists genuine wrongdoing shouldn’t go unchecked
The report also emphasized how accountability must remain intact.
“Counties and other local governments should not escape accountability for genuine wrongdoing,” the report stated. “But we need a system that recognizes the unique nature of mandated public services, provides predictable and sustainable cost structures, and ensures that taxpayer resources are used to serve communities rather than to fund excessive or unpredictable litigation.”
WSAC leaders said that the Legislature, in 1981 and 1986, acted when rising costs demanded action, and argue that the need for action has come again.
“Lawmakers are forcing Washington counties into an impossible, dangerous corner: either we pay off out-of-control litigation, or we keep our jails open and our roads safe,” Young said. “The status quo is fundamentally broken and unsustainable. Just as the Legislature stepped up to stop this crisis in the 1980s, today’s leaders must act immediately before the weight of these soaring costs completely bankrupts local governments.”






Comments
0 Comments