ADVERTISEMENT

SEATTLE RED OPINION

Jim Walsh: Washington Supreme Court slaps down Ferguson’s attempt to let unelected commission fire your sheriff

The Washington Supreme Court refused to reinstate SB 5974, keeping Ferguson's sheriff removal law frozen as candidates file for election statewide.

Washington state Rep. Jim Walsh...

State Rep. Jim Walsh (R-Aberdeen), chairman of the Washington State Republican Party, confirmed he is actively discussing a potential 2028 gubernatorial run while pushing to build conservative voter turnout infrastructure across the state. (Washington State GOP)

(Washington State GOP)

On May 5, the Washington State Supreme Court (writing through one of its court commissioners) upheld a lower court’s injunction stopping Senate Bill 5974—the “anti-sheriff” proposal. This is the highly-controversial scheme that would allow an unelected, governor-appointed commission to decertify and effectively remove from office elected county sheriffs. It also would apply dubious “eligibility” standards to candidates running for sheriff in Washington.

This ruling is worth close review, for what it says about the anti-sheriff bill. And other shoddy legislation coming out of Olympia.

How a Thurston County judge stopped Ferguson’s sheriff removal law one day before it took effect

A week earlier, Thurston County Superior Court Judge Christine Schaller had issued a preliminary injunction blocking SB 5974. The matter was urgent because the bill had been designed to take effect before candidate filing week for 2026 elections and would have prevented several current candidates from running for sheriff.

“I find that the challenged language in [SB 5974] is unconstitutional,” Schaller said. “It fails to provide the kind of notice that will enable an ordinary person, or an ordinary sheriff, to understand what conduct it prohibits.”

Schaller voiced serious concerns with the scheme—and particularly with its Section 9, the focal point of her injunction. That Section:

ADVERTISEMENT
  • imposed new requirements on sheriffs, including age and experience standards; and
  • opened the door for the governor-appointed commission to target free speech rights by reviewing past conduct, including social media posts and associations, to determine whether a sheriff should be decertified.

What Section 9 would have let an unelected commission do to elected sheriffs

Finally, Schaller concluded that the scheme unfairly held sheriffs to higher eligibility standards than other elected officials. And that no other elected officials in Washington can be removed by an unelected commission. It was a powerfully-made decision that will be difficult to undo.

State Solicitor General Noah Purcell, who handles controversial court arguments for the State Attorney General’s Office, appealed Schaller’s ruling to the State Supreme Court—which agreed to review the matter quickly.

The State Supreme Court kept the injunction against SB 5974 in place. Doing so, it expanded in useful ways on some of the conclusions Schaller had reached:

ADVERTISEMENT
  • “Section 9 in particular completely revamps and extensively adds to the qualifications for sheriffs set forth in RCW 36.28.025, which before the new statute essentially had only one qualification (completion of a basic law enforcement training program).”
  • “Among many other requirements, every person filing for candidacy for the office of sheriff must provide a sworn statement that the candidate meets the requirements of section 9. Candidates also must pass background checks by the Washington State Patrol verifying eligibility and…, if elected, must obtain certification from the Criminal Justice Training Commission…and thereafter maintain certification.”
  • “…the legislation unlawfully adds to the eligibility requirements for elected county offices set forth in article XI, section 5 of the Washington Constitution; unlawfully adds to constitutional provisions governing the removal of elected officials not otherwise subject to impeachment set forth in Washington Constitution article I, section 33, and article V, section 3; violates constitutional due process principles by failing to give fair notice of the conduct that could render a person ineligible for the office of elected county sheriff, and by authorizing an arbitrary or discriminatory certification process; and requires sheriffs and candidates for sheriff to give what amounts to a loyalty oath, in violation of constitutional free speech rights.”
  • “[Schaller] issued a preliminary injunction, finding that [sheriffs] had shown that they are likely to prevail on the merits, that they have a well-grounded fear of immediate invasion of their constitutional rights…and that the balance of equities favor preserving the status quo pending final resolution of the validity of the provisions governing sheriffs.”

Supreme Court sides with sheriffs: status quo holds while case moves forward

Furthermore, the Supreme Court agreed with current sheriff candidates in Kitsap and Asotin Counties who argued that they would be unconstitutionally prohibited from even filing to run under SB 5974:

ADVERTISEMENT

For persons who wish to run for reelection to the office of sheriff, or for those seeking to run for the first time, immediate implementation of the provisions applicable to sheriffs risks rendering candidates who are qualified under the former law but not under the new legislation unable to file or qualify for candidacy during the current one-week filing window. No “fruit” of an ultimately successful challenge to the statute can restore lost candidacies for this year’s elections.

The State Supreme Court concluded that upholding Schaller’s injunction meant that “the system that has long been in place will continue for the time being.” And that Solicitor Purcell had not shown that immediate harm was likely to result “from at least temporarily maintaining this status quo.”

So, it kept Schaller’s injunction in place. And SB 5974 remains on hold. Not categorically dead (no bad bill in Olympia ever is) but certainly dying. Again, the case against SB 5974 has been made powerfully and will be difficult to undo.

ADVERTISEMENT

One last point: Reviewing Schaller’s injunction, the State Supreme Court noted that SB 5974 contained an emergency clause, so common these days in controversial bills that Washington Democrats don’t want people overturning by referendum. Here, the Court wrote:

The legislature included an emergency clause accelerating the effective date of [SB 5974] so that it would apply to this year’s elections, and this clause is to be given considerable deference when considering whether the legislation is subject to referendum. But the clause does not establish as a fact that the balance of harms favors granting a stay in the specific circumstances of this case.

This suggests an argument that might work in the future to remove inappropriate emergency clauses from Olympia bills: Argue that the “balance of harms” in the “specific circumstances” of the bill require that the emergency clause be removed.

ADVERTISEMENT

Jim Walsh is a Republican state representative from Aberdeen who serves as chairman of the Washington State Republican Party, where he has focused on rebuilding party infrastructure, candidate recruitment, and grassroots engagement.

Follow Seattle Red on-air at 770 AM, on the Seattle Red app, and streaming audio and video on SeattleRed.com.

Jason Rantz Talk Show Host and Columnist at Seattle Red

Jason Rantz hosts The Jason Rantz Show on Seattle Red 770 AM weekdays from 3 p.m. to 7 p.m.

Comments

1 Comments

C
Candis Gauvin 7 months ago

I voted for Pierce County Sheriff Swank and am so HAPPY this ridiculous and unconstitutional bill is not going into effect!