ADVERTISEMENT

SEATTLE RED OPINION

Joseph St. Clair: What socialism rewards

Air Force veteran Joseph St. Clair explains what he learned about socialism while imprisoned by the Maduro regime, and provides a warning to Americans.

Seattle protesters hold a “Free President Maduro” sign during a rally opposing the U.S. operati...

Seattle protesters hold a “Free President Maduro” sign during a rally opposing the U.S. operation in Venezuela, openly demanding the release of an unelected dictator accused of drug trafficking and human rights abuses — a message largely omitted from mainstream coverage of the demonstration. (Photo: Jonathan Choe)

(Photo: Jonathan Choe)

While imprisoned in Venezuela, I read Jung Chang’s Wild Swans, a memoir of life under Mao. The characters who stayed with me were not Mao or the famous revolutionaries. They were Mr. and Mrs. Ting, a vindictive couple who learned how to convert political loyalty into personal power.

The Tings were recognizable. In an ordinary society, people like them might remain merely petty. Give them ideological authority, captive targets and protection from meaningful appeal, and they become dangerous.

I met their Venezuelan equivalents inside Rodeo I.

A firsthand account of the evils of socialism

We knew one of them only as Cacique, a Spanish word for a chief or leader. I never saw his face. His mask exposed only a narrow slit and the dead, dark eyes behind it.

Cacique was one of the few higher-ranking officials who regularly entered our floor. He seemed to enjoy manufacturing conflict. A French prisoner held near me had a food allergy. Cacique knowingly gave him food he could not safely eat, then told him that if he refused it, he would not eat at all.

The Frenchman was a natural freedom fighter. He did not quietly accept arbitrary treatment. He responded with protests and stunts of his own. Cacique would then present the Frenchman’s reaction as the original problem and punish him more severely.

The pattern kept repeating. First came an impossible condition. Then came resistance. The resistance became proof that the prisoner was dangerous and required greater control.

ADVERTISEMENT

Divide and conquer

Cacique treated guards beneath him in much the same way. When one guard overstepped his position and caused an unnecessary clash with a politically valuable prisoner, Cacique made him repaint an entire prison wall black even though it had just been painted. The punishment was hazing disguised as correction.

The irony was that Cacique created the same kind of unnecessary conflicts. He was simply better at preserving plausible deniability. He understood how to provoke someone without appearing to have provoked him.

We could pass long periods in relative harmony. Prisoners from different countries and religions found ways to coexist even when their politics differed. We shared food. We translated for one another. We developed routines and found ways to pass the time.

What my time in a Venezuelan prison taught me about socialism

Certain guards could not allow that harmony to continue. They introduced humiliations or arbitrary restrictions, then punished the disorder they had created.

ADVERTISEMENT

I cannot know every guard’s private motive. I know what I watched. Peace was followed by provocation. Provocation produced a reaction. The reaction became the justification for punishment.

That pattern taught me more about socialism than any slogan could.

The revolution eats its own

The danger is not that every socialist is cruel. Many Venezuelans sincerely believed they were constructing a more just society. Some prisoners I met were still Chavistas. Others had served the government as civilian officials or military officers. They had supported the revolution and worked inside its institutions. Some had enforced its policies. They ended up in the same prison as its declared enemies.

One senior oil executive told me that he had been arrested alongside dozens of his subordinates and sentenced to 30 years after a pipeline malfunction. I cannot independently verify every detail of his case. His presence still fit a broader pattern I could see directly. The system had begun consuming people who had served it.

ADVERTISEMENT

Loyalty offered no permanent protection because the machinery required failures to explain and enemies to punish. When a centralized government promises control over an entire economy and society, ordinary mistakes become political threats. A broken pipeline cannot remain a broken pipeline. Someone must be guilty of sabotage, corruption or betrayal.

The same logic operated on the prison floor. A peaceful prisoner reduced the apparent need for coercion. A provoked prisoner could be classified as a threat.

A warning to Americans

This is what Americans should consider when evaluating socialism. Do not look only at the motives of its supporters. Ask what kind of institutions it creates. Ask who receives discretionary power and whether anyone can meaningfully appeal their decisions. Then ask what happens when the government’s promises fail.

Most importantly, ask what kind of person the system rewards. The Tings are never on the brochure. The brochure shows equality, solidarity and justice. The Tings arrive later, after power has been concentrated and resistance has been redefined as proof of guilt.

ADVERTISEMENT

In Nineteen Eighty-Four, O’Brien tells Winston to imagine “a boot stamping on a human face—forever.” Was that the future? Perhaps. Winner-take-all systems bend toward it as power centralizes. Yet the human spirit keeps rising. Americans must decide whether we want a country built to press the boot down or one where the human spirit can endure and flourish.

By the time such a system takes root, even the true believers may find themselves inside its prisons.

Joseph St. Clair served for ten years as a U.S. Air Force airborne cryptologic linguist supporting special operations and holds a JD from Berkeley Law. He is the author of The Architecture of Gold, a philosophical examination of moral agency, meaning and human flourishing.

Follow Seattle Red on-air at 770 AM, on the Seattle Red app, and streaming audio and video on SeattleRed.com.

Comments

1 Comments

S
Shawn m 3 months ago

Meaty observations with an insightful warning --thank you!