Chris Cargill: Startling new business formation data – turns out businesses like states that don’t punish them
New data shows how Washington's job growth is being surpassed by more business-friendly states like Idaho and Montana, writes Chris Cargill.
New businesses flock to low tax, low regulation states like Idaho and Montana. (Photo by Mario Tama/Getty Images)
(Photo by Mario Tama/Getty Images)
Entrepreneurs do not start businesses in a vacuum. They make decisions in an environment created in significant part by public policy: taxes, labor costs, licensing requirements, regulatory complexity, the cost of hiring employees, and the amount of uncertainty government introduces into long-term planning.
Those policies cannot explain everything about why businesses start in one state rather than another. Population growth matters. Migration matters. Access to capital matters. Industry clusters, demographics, geography, universities, and decades of accumulated economic development all matter.
But public policy matters too. And a new ranking of business formation across the 50 states provides a revealing look at just how different entrepreneurship is unfolding across America.
A better way to track business activity
The 2025 Business Formation Reality Score, published by SMB Statistics and updated in July 2026, attempts to measure something more meaningful than the raw number of people applying for Employer Identification Numbers. Instead, it tries to determine whether those applications are actually turning into businesses likely to employ workers.
The Business Formation Reality Score is valuable partly because it attempts to solve an obvious problem with conventional business-formation statistics. Simply counting business applications can produce misleading results.
States such as Wyoming and Delaware attract enormous numbers of legal registrations from companies whose owners, workers, and customers may actually be located somewhere else. An entrepreneur living in another state can organize a company in Wyoming or Delaware and use a registered-agent address there even though little or none of the company’s economic activity occurs within the state.
How the Business Formation Reality Score works
The score therefore tries to distinguish between legal registrations and genuine employer-business formation. Its five underlying measures are:
- projected employer formations per resident;
- projected formations relative to existing employer establishments;
- planned-wage business applications per resident;
- private-establishment growth; and
- the density of unincorporated business returns and forms.
It then applies a filing-distortion adjustment designed to identify states where raw applications appear disproportionately driven by entity-registration activity rather than actual businesses operating locally.
Idaho and Montana outpace WA in job growth
The results are striking. Montana ranks first in America. Idaho ranks third. Washington ranks fifteenth.
And when the underlying data are examined more closely, the gap between these neighboring Western states becomes even more consequential. For every 10,000 residents, Montana is projected to produce 21 new employer businesses. Idaho is projected to produce 18.1. Washington produces just 14.3.
That means Montana is producing projected employer businesses at a rate approximately 47 percent higher than Washington, while Idaho’s rate is roughly 27 percent higher.
The difference raises an important question for policymakers: Why are entrepreneurs in Montana and Idaho apparently having greater success turning business ideas into actual employers than entrepreneurs in Washington?
It turns out pro-business policies attract new businesses
The answer is unlikely to be a single tax or regulation. But taken together, the policy environments of these states point toward a larger lesson: government can either lower the price of entrepreneurship or raise it. Increasingly, Montana and Idaho have chosen the former. Washington has been moving toward the latter.
Idaho’s approach to regulation offers perhaps the clearest contrast with Washington. When Gov. Brad Little entered office in 2019, Idaho’s administrative code contained 736 chapters, more than 8,200 pages and at least 72,000 regulatory restrictions. The administration subsequently launched a broad regulatory-reduction effort.
According to the governor’s office, Idaho’s administrative code ultimately fell from 736 chapters and more than 8,200 pages to 381 chapters and 4,659 pages. The Idaho Legislature made the periodic zero-based review process permanent in 2023, requiring rule chapters to undergo review every eight years. Idaho created a system in which agencies are repeatedly asked: Does this rule still need to exist?
High taxes make WA less competitive than its neighbors
Idaho has simultaneously been reducing taxes. The Tax Foundation’s 2026 State Tax Competitiveness Index now ranks Idaho #9 nationally. Montana’s tax structure is also among the most competitive in the country. Tax Foundation ranks Montana #6 overall in its 2026 State Tax Competitiveness Index. Washington’s tax structure operates very differently. This is one reason Washington ranks #45 in the Tax Foundation’s index.
Montana and Idaho should not be viewed as proof that every tax cut produces another entrepreneur or that every regulation destroys a business. They should be viewed as evidence that a consistent policy orientation toward lower barriers, competitive taxation and regulatory restraint can coexist with extraordinarily strong business formation.
Follow Seattle Red on-air at 770 AM, on the Seattle Red app, and streaming audio and video on SeattleRed.com.






Comments
0 Comments