Rantz: Washington Democrats quietly make voter roll cleanup nearly impossible
While Republicans push the SAVE Act to require proof of citizenship, Washington Democrats raise the burden to remove ineligible voters to beyond reasonable doubt.
Saul Spady says Seattle is ready to move away from far-left progressive politics (Photo: KIRO Newsradio)
(Photo: KIRO Newsradio)
Republicans nationally are moving forward with the SAVE Act, legislation designed to require proof of citizenship to register to vote in federal elections. The goal is straightforward. It’s to prevent noncitizens from registering in the first place. But in Washington state, Democrats are moving in the opposite direction.
Engrossed Substitute House Bill 1916 restructures the process for challenging voter eligibility and raises the legal threshold to an extraordinary level. While Congress debates how to prevent illegal voting before it happens, Olympia is making it far harder to remove ineligible names from the rolls after they are discovered. This is not accidental.
Democrats raise the burden beyond reason
Under current law, challengers must prove a registration is improper by clear and convincing evidence, which can include citing public voter registration data. ESHB 1916 raises that standard dramatically. The bill states, “The challenger has the burden to prove beyond a reasonable doubt that the challenged voter’s registration is improper,” according to ESHB 1916.
Beyond a reasonable doubt is the highest burden in American law. It is the standard used to convict someone of murder. Washington Democrats want that same threshold applied to a citizen who raises concerns about voter eligibility.
The bill also mandates automatic dismissal if that burden is not met.
“If the challenger fails to prove beyond a reasonable doubt that the registration is improper, the challenge must be dismissed and any pending challenged ballot must be accepted as valid,” according to ESHB 1916.
More hoops, fewer removals
The legislation further restricts how and when challenges can proceed. A hearing may only be scheduled if there is probable cause and eligibility cannot otherwise be confirmed. In other words, even if a challenge is filed properly, government officials must first determine it likely lacks merit before allowing it to proceed.
At the same time, the bill may ultimately criminalize unsuccessful challengers. It provides that any challenger who knowingly challenges without reasonable cause is guilty of a misdemeanor, according to ESHB 1916.
“Challenging someone’s constitutional right to vote is an extremely serious offense,” sponsor Rep. Beth Doglio (D-Olympia) explained on the House floor, according to The Center Square. “That challenge should be done under the penalty of perjury.”
Taken together, Democrats have created a system where challenging questionable registrations requires near-criminal proof and carries legal risk.
Why Democrats fight to keep illegal voters on the rolls
Republicans at the federal level argue that citizenship verification upfront is necessary to secure elections. Washington Democrats appear focused on ensuring that once someone is registered, removal becomes practically impossible.
That contrast is hardly subtle. It reflects a policy choice. When one side works to tighten eligibility standards and the other side raises barriers to enforcement, the motive is clear.
Washington is not strengthening voter confidence. It is shielding the rolls from scrutiny.
Listen to The Jason Rantz Show on weekday afternoons from 3 p.m. – 7 p.m. on Seattle Red on 770 AM (HD Radio 97.3 FM HD-Channel 3). Subscribe to the podcast here. Follow Jason Rantz on X, Instagram, YouTube, and Facebook.






Comments
10 Comments
the only way they can win is to cheat i guess the only way to have a fair election is to have the supreme court order voter roll clean up and stop mail in ballots it all started when dino rossi had it stolen from him
"Washington Democrats appear focused on ensuring that once someone is registered, removal becomes practically impossible"
That's their voting base, so of course they don't want illegal voters removed! Besides, they only voted illegally, and that isn't a crime, right? RIGHT?
I wonder how long it's been since Washington has had a legitimate election.