Washington Supreme Court bail proposal would gut pretrial rules, let defendants skip court: Jason Rantz
Far-left public defenders want to rewrite Washington's bail rules, making it nearly impossible to arrest defendants who skip court. Public comments close April 30.
The Washington Supreme Court heard arguments Tuesday on a proposal to make bail harder to impose. (Jason Rantz)
(Jason Rantz)
Most Washingtonians have never heard of CrR 3.2. The people pushing to gut it prefer things that way, hoping you don’t realize that they’re trying to create a system that errs even more on the side of releasing dangerous criminals, including those who skip out on court hearings.
The Washington State Supreme Court is accepting public comments through April 30 on a proposal that would rewrite the state’s pretrial bail rules from the ground up. The proposal was put forward by a coalition of far-left public defender offices — the King County Department of Public Defense, the Washington State Office of Public Defense, the Washington Defender Association, and the Snohomish County Office of Public Defense — and the vast majority of Washington residents have no idea it exists.
What CrR 3.2 currently does — and what the proposal would change
Under current Washington law, a court can impose bail or issue an arrest warrant when there is a “likely risk of nonappearance.” Judges can look at someone’s record, their history of skipping hearings, their ties to the community, and make a call.
The proposal would replace that standard with a dramatically higher bar: a “high likelihood of willful flight to avoid prosecution.” Courts would have to find that a defendant had “intentional conduct with a purpose to thwart the judicial process to avoid prosecution.” Under that definition, missing court three times probably does not cut it. You would have to prove the defendant actually intended to evade prosecution as a matter of specific purpose. Try doing that at an arraignment without a time machine.
But it goes even further.
The proposal would give every defendant at least one free pass to miss court before bail can be imposed under the new standard. It would cap bail at $200 for most misdemeanor offenses, excluding domestic violence and DUI cases. And it would create a strong presumption that defendants can post just 10 percent of any bail amount directly with the court clerk rather than through a bondsman. These changes, as a package, do not fix the bail system. They remove the accountability structure that gives the system any teeth.
Supreme Court candidates warn the proposal would paralyze judges
Two men competing for Washington State Supreme Court seats in November have watched this proposal develop with alarm.
Federal Way Municipal Court Judge Dave Larson came within 0.61 percent of winning a Supreme Court seat in 2024 and is running again. He was clear about which one issue pushed him back into the race.
“The straw that broke the camel’s back this year, was a new court rule that’s being proposed that will make it almost impossible to issue a warrant for somebody’s arrest if they don’t show up for court,” Larson explained on The Jason Rantz Show on Seattle Red 770 AM. “It’s just a small example of a rule that might seem insignificant, but the impacts on communities — what’s the incentive to show up for court, if the judge is kind of handcuffed internally? And that’s kind of a bad irony, but handcuffed to not be able to issue a warrant unless it’s proved that you willfully failed to appear. And how do you do that when somebody is not there?”
“We can’t hide behind judicial independence to say we can do what we want,” Larson added. “No, we’re accountable to the people, and that’s the ethic we have to have, and we have to produce results.”
In his own court, his failure-to-appear rate dropped because defendants understood that showing up actually mattered. This rule would undo that logic across the entire state.
Judge Stevens: he already watched this fail in juvenile court
Mason County Superior Court Judge David Stevens, who is running for the seat vacated by Justice Raquel Montoya-Lewis, has already lived through an earlier version of this problem. He told The Jason Rantz Show on Seattle Red 770 AM what happened when the current court’s interpretations stripped judges of warrant authority over juveniles.
“I actually, when I was on the juvenile rotation, could not issue warrants for people that violated their probation because I couldn’t find that there was an actual specific danger, an actual danger,” Stevens said. “So the fact that they’re disregarding court and just refusing to come, I couldn’t do a warrant. I mean, that makes no sense whatsoever, and they’re proposing a rule now that they’re going to do that in superior court and District Court, so they’re going to limit the ability for the courts to issue warrants. And I believe that that’s a policy, and I believe it’s going to be a real problem.”
“We don’t have any diversity of thought on there,” he added. “They all think the same. If you read their opinions, there’s hardly ever any dissent. We’re not getting the other side now. We’re just getting what nine people all believe and agree on.”
He is correct. And this bail rule is one more example of Washington’s Supreme Court using rulemaking to impose what the legislature would never vote for.
Other states ran this experiment — and failure-to-appear rates surged
The far-left proponents frame this as an equity issue. Public defenders from Snohomish County submitted support letters arguing that cash bail traps poor defendants in jail while wealthier ones walk free. Gonzaga law students submitted comments citing Justice William Douglas. But the rule being proposed does not address disparities. It removes accountability across the board, regardless of the defendant’s record or the victims waiting to testify.
Other states have run this experiment already, and none of them got the results the proponents are promising.
Anne Marie Schubert, president and CEO of the Criminal Justice Legal Foundation and a former District Attorney of Sacramento County, submitted a letter opposing the proposal to the court.
“The proposed amendments under Order No. 25700-A-1676 should be rejected,” Schubert wrote. “They are not a modest adjustment — they are a sweeping and dangerous departure from proven pretrial practices that will predictably increase failures to appear, embolden repeat noncompliance, erode judicial authority, and place additional burdens on already strained courts, law enforcement, and victims.”
“By requiring proof of specific intent to evade prosecution — and by explicitly stating that missed court appearances alone are insufficient — the rule effectively guarantees that defendants will receive at least one consequence-free failure to appear before courts can act. This is not reform. It is an open invitation to ignore court orders.”
Opposition mounts from victims groups, lawmakers, and bail professionals
Shannon Moore, a bail bond professional who submitted detailed opposition comments, cited data from Washington counties that ran earlier reduced-bail experiments and watched failure-to-appear rates climb between 15 and 35 percent. She also noted that the proposed $200 misdemeanor cap “removes meaningful accountability, increases repeat FTAs, increases law enforcement warrant service costs, and extends case timelines and court congestion.”
Crime Victims United, a national victim advocacy group, warned the court that “these proposed rules would further tilt an already unbalanced system in favor of defendants while treating victims as collateral damage.” More than 40 Republican members of the Washington State Legislature also weighed in against the proposal, arguing that “changes of this magnitude should be debated through the legislative process,” not handed down through court rulemaking.
The comment period closes April 30. Comments can be submitted to the court clerk at supreme@courts.wa.gov. If this rule concerns you, now is the time to say so.
Listen to The Jason Rantz Show on weekday afternoons from 3 p.m. – 7 p.m. on Seattle Red on 770 AM (HD Radio 97.3 FM HD-Channel 3). Subscribe to the podcast here. Follow Jason Rantz on X, Instagram, YouTube, and Facebook.






Comments
4 Comments
What an awful proposal. This wouldn't even help the defendants who need to get their lives figured out. It just keeps the court proceeding hanging over their head longer without dealing with it. Delay holds back people's lives.
Things just keeps getting worse. There needs to be a study on why democrats/liberals hate everyone, except criminals. Let’s just stop the nonsense and give everyone a free pass to do whatever they please. The only accountability is when a liberal politician or family member is the victim.
Why does it almost always seem that the DEMOCRATS take the side of enabling, protecting and empowering the CRIMINALS?