ADVERTISEMENT

JASON RANTZ OPINION

Rantz: Tacoma invents a food desert while five grocery stores are within walking, driving distance

Tacoma leaders and KING 5 call the James Center Fred Meyer closure a food desert. Five grocery stores sit within two miles. The real problem is rent and theft.

A Fred Meyer store in Washington....

The Fred Meyer at James Center in Tacoma is scheduled to close January 30, 2027, the city's second Fred Meyer closure in roughly 16 months. (Photo courtesy of KIRO 7)

(Photo courtesy of KIRO 7)

Tacoma is about to lose its second Fred Meyer in roughly 16 months, and the city’s response has been to hold a vigil for a food desert that does not exist. KING 5 gladly went along with the claim.

But Grocery Outlet and WinCo are less than a mile from the James Center store. Whole Foods Market, Trader Joe’s and Safeway are within about two miles. That is five grocery stores inside a short walk, bus ride, or drive of a location that has not even closed yet, and Tacoma’s leadership is talking like the last wheat field just burned.

The James Center store at South 19th and Mildred is scheduled to close January 30, 2027. UFCW Local 367, the union representing roughly 100 workers there, said Kroger told them the store was closing because of a rent increase. Kroger has offered nothing publicly beyond a statement about making the decision after a careful evaluation.

Rent is the only explanation actually on the record, as MyNorthwest reported, and it is also the least useful one politically. So the story got an upgrade.

KING 5 built its coverage around food deserts, pharmacy access, and the burden on shoppers who walk or ride the bus. Mayor Anders Ibsen put out a statement describing the closure as a serious blow and warning that residents fear worsening food deserts and reduced access to medications. It is a tidy narrative that is easily contradicted by a Google map.

Five grocery stores is not a food desert

A food desert is a real thing with a real definition, and it does not mean a Fred Meyer relocated your errand by a mile and a half. It means people cannot reach fresh food. West End Tacoma can reach fresh food at WinCo, Grocery Outlet, Safeway, Trader Joe’s, Whole Foods, and the remaining Fred Meyer on South 19th near Stevens, which happens to sit across the street from a Walmart.

ADVERTISEMENT

Even the shopper KING 5 found on camera did not describe a crisis of access. He described a crisis of price.

“It’s too bad for people that are on the west side,” shopper Mike Adamczyk told KING 5. “I think, maybe some pricier options only in this area, like Whole Foods.”

That is a complaint about cost in a state where Democrats have spent a decade making everything cost more. But it’s also selective concern: don’t want to spend money at Whole Foods? Go the four other cheaper options.

It is also not a humanitarian emergency, and it certainly is not the social justice story the city and its favorite TV station are trying to build out of it.

The word nobody in Tacoma wants to say

Ibsen, to his credit, let something slip. He acknowledged that safety concerns were part of the conversation around the Pacific Avenue store at South 72nd, which closed in September 2025 and has sat as an empty box ever since.

ADVERTISEMENT

Washington leads the nation in retail theft, and grocers here have been telling anyone who will listen for years. When Seattle got a Safeway that tried to protect itself by closing a second entrance, the city cited the store instead of the thieves. When Washington Democrats blocked the Kroger-Albertsons merger and then acted stunned as Kroger consolidated, they discovered that scolding a company is not a business plan.

Tacoma does not have a food desert. It has a landlord, an expensive lease, a theft problem the city will not name more directly, and elected officials who find a manufactured equity crisis easier to talk about than the one they built.

Listen to The Jason Rantz Show on weekday afternoons from 3 p.m. – 7 p.m. on Seattle Red on 770 AM (HD Radio 97.3 FM HD-Channel 3). Subscribe to the podcast here. Follow Jason Rantz on X, Instagram, YouTube, and Facebook.

Jason Rantz Talk Show Host and Columnist at Seattle Red

Jason Rantz hosts The Jason Rantz Show on Seattle Red 770 AM weekdays from 3 p.m. to 7 p.m.

Comments

9 Comments

S
Sean Gill 2 months ago

The people whining about a desert now are the ones who wanted the merger with Safeway blocked. Pretty sure Safeway could have helped with the rent. No one exclusively walks around Tacoma when bums just ride the bus for free and these same people who can't buy a cheap beater to drive to the grocery store or their hypothetical job are the ones shoplifting Fred Meyer out of business.

J
Jake Morningwood 2 months ago

Food desert may soon surpass genocide as the most ignorantly over used word in the lefty lexicon.

B
Blip Ferguson 2 months ago

Policies matter. Lack of enforcement matters. this should NOT be a surprise