ADVERTISEMENT

JASON RANTZ OPINION

Rantz: Seattle spends $465,000 a year on ‘smart toilets’ because the drug crisis it won’t fix keeps wrecking the cheap ones

Seattle can't keep cheap bathrooms clean because homeless drug addicts destroy them, so taxpayers now pay $100K per toilet per year during a $488M budget crisis.

Interior of a Throne Labs public bathroom unit featuring tropical leaf wallpaper, wall-mounted porc...

The interior of a Throne Labs public bathroom unit, now installed in Pioneer Square and near Lumen Field ahead of the FIFA World Cup. The units feature tropical wallpaper, wall-mounted porcelain toilets, running water, and solar-powered lighting. Seattle is paying $100,000 per unit annually through the Seattle Transportation Levy, a price point driven in part by the city's decades-long failure to keep cheaper public bathrooms out of the hands of drug-addicted homeless. (Seattle Department of Transportation)

(Seattle Department of Transportation)

Seattle can’t maintain a basic port-a-potty without it turning into a fentanyl den or a makeshift brothel. So now taxpayers are on the hook for pricey “smart toilets” with QR code entry and a ten-minute limit (though it’s unclear how this would be enforced). It’s happening as the city is staring down a $488 million budget deficit.

Mayor Katie Wilson presided over what was billed as a “toilet paper ribbon cutting” in Pioneer Square last week, inaugurating four Throne Labs bathroom units just ahead of the FIFA World Cup. Wilson made jokes. People applauded. Meanwhile, Seattle’s projected deficit has grown to $488 million over the next three years, with $175 million of that gap arriving in 2027 alone.

You cannot make this up.

Why cheap doesn’t work

Seattle doesn’t have simple public bathrooms in Pioneer Square because the city’s track record with them is catastrophic. Every time the city installs one, the homeless drug addict population uses it for drug use, sex, and the occasional overdose. That is what actually happens.

In 2001, the city put up five self-cleaning pod-style toilets across Seattle at over $1 million each. Within a few years the pods became hotspots for crime. City leaders finally gave up and sold all five by 2008 for $12,500.

King County Metro recently went through the same exercise, replacing port-a-potties at two transit centers with Throne units at an estimated $270,000 per year for both, because the cheaper option was being destroyed. The same story played out at Everett’s public library, where homeless drug addicts took over the bathrooms to smoke fentanyl and forced the library to install drug sensors. A former resident at a South Lake Union tiny house village documented facility toilets “clogged with foil, needles, and cookers.” Conditions across the city have deteriorated rapidly under Wilson, with We Heart Seattle founder Andrea Suarez warning they have returned to levels not seen in years.

ADVERTISEMENT

Rather than address that population through enforcement and treatment, Seattle decided to spend its way around the problem.

A throne for the unhoused

The Throne Labs units are legitimately impressive, if “impressive” is a word you can use about a bathroom. Flush toilets, running water, solar-powered lights, ambient music, flowery fragrance pumped inside. Access comes through a QR code, phone app, or text message. Every user gets an anonymous ID, and after each visit, the next person in rates how clean it is. The company dispatches maintenance crews based on that real-time feedback.

Each unit costs $100,000 per year. Seattle’s four Pioneer Square and Lumen Field units draw from the Seattle Transportation Levy, at a combined $465,000 annually. I wrote two years ago that the city would keep calling these public bathrooms without admitting they are built primarily for the homeless. Nothing has changed. Officials and Throne’s CEO talk about serving “every human” who needs a toilet. What they mean is they have engineered a bathroom the drug-addicted homeless population is less likely to destroy. That is its function. And it costs $400,000 a year.

ADVERTISEMENT

The math doesn’t add up

Wilson called cutting $175 million from next year’s budget “a terrifying prospect.” Her budget director said on camera the city is not spending beyond its means. These are the same people who just threw a ribbon-cutting ceremony for high-tech toilets.

Before the Throne units went in, the Downtown Seattle Association’s cleaning crews were responding to an average of 65 incidents of human waste per week in the area, according to the Seattle Times. If the underlying drug crisis were addressed, the solution would not need to cost $100,000 per toilet per year.

Seattle gets a press event, bathroom jokes, and a hefty bill. The half-billion-dollar hole keeps widening. These bathrooms will probably outlast the $1 million pods. But they are a very expensive way to manage a crisis the city has no intention of fixing.

Listen to The Jason Rantz Show on weekday afternoons from 3 p.m. – 7 p.m. on Seattle Red on 770 AM (HD Radio 97.3 FM HD-Channel 3). Subscribe to the podcast here. Follow Jason Rantz on X, Instagram, YouTube, and Facebook.

Jason Rantz Talk Show Host and Columnist at Seattle Red

Jason Rantz hosts The Jason Rantz Show on Seattle Red 770 AM weekdays from 3 p.m. to 7 p.m.

Comments

2 Comments

E
Evan Lattimore 6 months ago
Before the Throne units went in, the Downtown Seattle Association’s cleaning crews were responding to an average of 65 incidents of human waste per week in the area, according to the Seattle Times.

I was walking along Pike just this morning, had to go to one side because they were cleaning the other side with that nasty soapy water they use. On my way back I went on the side they supposedly just cleaned, only to find poo spread out on the sidewalk with the nasty soaping water. It was a microcosm of Seattle: Spend money on a bad idea (nasty soapy water) that doesn't address a problem (addicts pooing on the sidewalk) and implement the bad idea poorly (nasty soapy pooey water).

J
Jake Morningwood 6 months ago

What a crappy solution!