Rantz: New Seattle proposal is guaranteed to raise your rent
Seattle Mayor Katie Wilson wants to ban rental junk fees, but Jason Rantz says the plan just buries the same charges in your rent and saves renters nothing.
Seattle Mayor Katie Wilson is pushing a City Council proposal to ban many rental "junk fees," though she concedes the costs would likely be added to base rent. And not all "junk fees" are actually junk. (Jason Rantz)
(Jason Rantz)
Seattle Mayor Katie Wilson wants to ban rental “junk fees,” and I understand the impulse, but her plan won’t save renters a dollar; it just buries the same costs inside your rent.
I know these fees as well as any other renter. I pay $10 a month for the privilege of accessing my building’s mailroom to pick up packages, and another $50 a month for pet damage protection against a dog, D’Artagnan, who has never chewed a baseboard in his life. Some of these charges are absurd. But Wilson’s proposal, now in front of the Seattle City Council, does not make a single one of them disappear. It only changes where the charge shows up in the paperwork.
The legislation creates a list of fees landlords are allowed to charge and bans everything not on it. That sounds like relief. It isn’t.
The fees don’t vanish, they move
Under the plan, landlords could still charge for security deposits, utilities, late rent, key replacement, bounced checks, and parking. Banned would be separate fees for pet rent, mail service, in-unit appliances, paying rent by check or money order, and access to common areas, according to MyNorthwest.
Strip out a fee and the cost does not evaporate. It gets folded into base rent, which every tenant pays whether they use that service or not.
Wilson knows this. She admitted the costs would likely be added to base rent, then argued the tradeoff is worth it because renters get transparency. But this leads to less transparency because you don’t even know you’re being absurdly charged for, say, mailroom access. It’s now hidden in the rent. Put another way, you will pay the same money; Wilson will just call it something else and take credit for “helping” you.
Bundling punishes the renter who opts out
The bundling is where the consumer protection pitch falls apart.
An unbundled fee means you pay for what you actually use. I get gouged $10 for mail access, fine, kill that one. But there are reasonable charges I will never trigger, like a fee to reserve a common room for a party I am not throwing. I don’t like parties. I barely like people. Ban that fee, roll it into everyone’s rent, and now I am subsidizing my neighbor’s birthday through my monthly rent. Multiply that across pet rent, appliance fees, and common area access, and the renter who wants none of it ends up paying for all of it.
“When you go to rent an apartment, and you see the sticker price of your monthly rent, and then you sign your lease, and you find that in the fine print there are all kinds of obscure fees that you’re also on the hook for, that’s not a good feeling,” Wilson told the Seattle Times. Neither is a higher sticker price that hides the same fees inside it.
This is the same move Washington Democrats have run on housing for years. They cannot build units or lower rent, so they regulate the paperwork and call it a win. A landlord in a contracting market will recover every dollar he or she is allowed to recover. Wilson is not cutting your costs. She is rearranging them and hoping you thank her.
Listen to The Jason Rantz Show on weekday afternoons from 3 p.m. – 7 p.m. on Seattle Red on 770 AM (HD Radio 97.3 FM HD-Channel 3). Subscribe to the podcast here. Follow Jason Rantz on X, Instagram, YouTube, and Facebook.






Comments
7 Comments
A mailroom charge is a joke, but you have the option to rent elsewhere. Each time our enlightened politicians add new regulations to business they are adding cost to comply.
Performative politics. It's all she's got.
Time to sell the rental and move it to a different city,, with normal landlord and renter rules that are fair